Close X
Thursday, October 31, 2024
ADVT 
National

Lisa Raitt Stands By Railway Safety Self-Regulation, Despite Lac-Megantic Report

Murray Brewster Darpan, 19 Aug, 2014 01:15 PM
    OTTAWA - The Harper government's faith in a deregulated railway safety system remains unshaken and won't be abandoned in the wake of the Lac-Megantic tragedy, Transport Minister Lisa Raitt insisted Tuesday, even as the country's top transportation investigator questioned the current amount of oversight.
     
    The tragedy that killed 47 people and incinerated the downtown of the sleepy Quebec village had a myriad of causes, the Transportation Safety Board said in its long-awaited report.
     
    Raitt said keeping the responsibility for railway safety in the hands of rail operators is still "absolutely the way to go." But she was quick to steer blame for the disaster toward Montreal Maine & Atlantic, the now-defunct railway that operated the doomed train.
     
    Raitt also carefully put distance between herself and the department she inherited in last year's cabinet shuffle, which followed the spectacular crash of the crude oil-laden train last July.
     
    The quality of Transport Canada's follow-up audits, especially with short-haul railways, has repeatedly been raised by critics who were quick to accuse the Conservatives of gutting rail safety.
     
    Wendy Tadros, the head of the Transportation Safety Board, gave those critics even more ammunition Tuesday with a report that essentially accuses the government of providing inadequate oversight.
     
    "Who was the guardian of public safety?" Tadros told a news conference. “That is the role of the government — to provide checks, balances and oversight.”
     
    But Transport Canada has been provided with the resources it needs to carry out its mandate, said Raitt, adding she is now looking at the department for answers to some of the transportation watchdog's fundamental concerns.
     
    The notion that Canada's 46,000 kilometres of track can be fully monitored around the clock is simply a non-starter, she added.
     
    "You cannot possibly have enough inspectors at every waypoint, on every train, at every single moment to have that kind of continuous oversight," Raitt said.
     
    The current system of self regulation, in one form or another, has been around for 20 years and has worked well in both airlines and the shipping sector, she added.
     
    "The focus is very much on the department to ensure that they continue to implement (safety management systems) regulations and that companies implement it as well...It is the appropriate way to go."
     
    But the board took aim at Transport Canada, saying it failed to recognize MM&A had urgent safety problems and was not following the rules. The department failed to audit safety procedures at the railway and didn’t do enough inspections.
     
    "We need to remember that in terms of safety, the government puts the rules in place," Raitt said. "The companies are expected to follow the rules. The company did not follow the rules, and that's a very important fact here too.”
     
    New Democrat transport critic Hoang Mai said it's now clear that self-regulation of railways has failed, and he urged the federal government to step up surveillance.
     
    "Conservatives left companies to monitor themselves — an approach that ended in tragedy," Mai said.
     
    In the aftermath of the disaster, the government made two-person crews mandatory on trains carrying hazardous goods. It also introduced more stringent rules around the application of brakes and how unattended trains must be parked.
     
    Officials are also working with industry to phase out older and weaker DOT-111 tanker cars whose thin steel hulls are prone to puncture. That effort, however, won't be completed until 2017.
     
    Green party Leader Elizabeth May called for a public inquiry to explore rail safety shortcomings in Canada.
     
    "We need to bring in a system that can stop or slow a train before certain accidents occur, such as positive train control technology, which is currently being implemented in the U.S.," May said in a statement.
     
    "A full public inquiry is needed to demonstrate the weak safety culture that exists in Canada today at the expense of Canadians."

    MORE National ARTICLES

    Study estimates 36% of Canadian businesses know they've been hit by cyber attack

    Study estimates 36% of Canadian businesses know they've been hit by cyber attack
    More than one-third of Canada's IT professionals know — for sure — that they'd had a significant data breach over the previous 12 months that could put their clients or their organizations at risk, a cybersecurity study suggests.

    Study estimates 36% of Canadian businesses know they've been hit by cyber attack

    Health minister denies feds' anti-pot campaign aimed at Justin Trudeau

    Health minister denies feds' anti-pot campaign aimed at Justin Trudeau
    Health Minister Rona Ambrose denies the federal government's marijuana awareness campaign is aimed at Justin Trudeau.

    Health minister denies feds' anti-pot campaign aimed at Justin Trudeau

    B.C. RCMP make an arrest after a suspicious death on a Mackenzie property

    B.C. RCMP make an arrest after a suspicious death on a Mackenzie property
    Police say a dead person was discovered on a property on the east side of Mackenzie and an investigation was started on Saturday....

    B.C. RCMP make an arrest after a suspicious death on a Mackenzie property

    B.C. authorities use controlled burns to stifle wildfires in the province

    B.C. authorities use controlled burns to stifle wildfires in the province
    Bill Miller of the Regional District of Bulkley-Nechako says controlled burns will start today around the 37-square-kilometre China Nose fire southeast of Houston....

    B.C. authorities use controlled burns to stifle wildfires in the province

    Trudeau confident Liberals on right track to victory in 2015 federal election

    Justin Trudeau doesn't put much stock in public opinion surveys that suggest the federal Liberal party vaulted into the lead once he took the helm 16 months ago and has stayed on top ever since...

    Trudeau confident Liberals on right track to victory in 2015 federal election

    English Bay a beacon for runners, sunbathers and sightseers in Vancouver

    English Bay a beacon for runners, sunbathers and sightseers in Vancouver
    English Bay offers a spectacular view, ships anchored in the water, an expansive number of beaches and a surprising amount of art....

    English Bay a beacon for runners, sunbathers and sightseers in Vancouver