Close X
Sunday, November 24, 2024
ADVT 
National

Lift Extreme Secrecy Shroud Over RCMP Harassment Case, Lawyer Urges Court

Darpan News Desk The Canadian Press, 18 Apr, 2015 01:25 AM
    NEWMARKET, Ont. — A shroud of secrecy thrown over part of an extraordinary case involving allegations of harassment within the RCMP should be lifted as much as possible, an Ontario justice heard Friday.
     
    The court-imposed secrecy, which ostensibly involves the identity of a confidential informant but may also be linked to Prime Minister Stephen Harper's family life, is so extreme that even the reasons for the order are unknown.
     
    "This is an extraordinary situation," media lawyer Brian MacLeod Rogers told Superior Court Justice Mary Vallee. "I'm in the dark about what's been going on."
     
    Rogers, who represents several media outlets, said reporters have been unable to raise concerns since last December, when they were abruptly excluded from the courtroom in a civil case involving RCMP Sgt. Peter Merrifield.
     
    The officer alleges senior officers ruined his career after he launched an unsuccessful bid to run for the federal Conservatives in 2005.
     
    Merrifield had called "Witness X" to testify in early December but the proceedings went in-camera. Vallee ordered material related to the hearing sealed, including a copy of her sealing order itself.
     
    On Friday, the National Post, citing sources, reported the material at issue includes four letters sent by private investigator Derrick Snowdy to assistant RCMP commissioner Stephen White.
     
    The Post said the letters are believed to contain allegations the RCMP leaked private information about Harper's family.
     
    The federal government maintains that Section 37 of the Canada Evidence Act allows for confidentiality where openness would encroach upon the public interest.
     
    Rogers — who represents Postmedia News, CBC, Maclean's and the Toronto Star — said he saw no issue with measures to protect the identity of a confidential informant.
     
    However, he argued, it's not good enough for the government to make general claims about the risk to the public interest by releasing information in a case involving allegations of wrongdoing by the country's national police force.
     
    "I don't see a specified public interest," he said.
     
    Merrifield's lawyer Laura Young said her client wants his case to be heard and "understood publicly."
     
    Federal lawyer Barney Brucker said he was unable to say much given the circumstances, although he agreed the proceeding should be open as much as possible.
     
    "I'm in somewhat of a difficult situation as well," he said. "I can't say very much about the specific public interest."
     
    If some material is to be released, he told Vallee, she should allow the parties involved to see what it would be so they could make submissions.
     
    Asked whether the sealing order related to the prime minister's family, Brucker said only he "wouldn't think so."
     
    "We're protecting the public interest," he said outside court. "I can't say anything further."
     
    Vallee reserved her decision.

    MORE National ARTICLES

    B.C. Man Alleging 'false Imprisonment' In China To Get Day In Canadian Court

    B.C. Man Alleging 'false Imprisonment' In China To Get Day In Canadian Court
    VANCOUVER — A British Columbia man has won the right to sue a company in a Canadian court that he alleges conspired with Chinese authorities to force him to spend years behind bars in China.

    B.C. Man Alleging 'false Imprisonment' In China To Get Day In Canadian Court

    Conservatives Fuel Opposition To Ontario's Sex-Ed Curriculum: Liberal Minister

    Conservatives Fuel Opposition To Ontario's Sex-Ed Curriculum: Liberal Minister
    TORONTO — Conservative groups are fuelling the vocal opposition to Ontario's new sex-education curriculum, Liberal Education Minister Liz Sandals said Tuesday as thousands of people protested outside the legislature.

    Conservatives Fuel Opposition To Ontario's Sex-Ed Curriculum: Liberal Minister

    Justin Trudeau Might Be Open To Forming Coalition With NDP, But Not With Mulcair As Leader

    Justin Trudeau Might Be Open To Forming Coalition With NDP, But Not With Mulcair As Leader
    OTTAWA — Liberal Leader Justin Trudeau says he would "maybe" be more open to the idea of forming a coalition with the NDP if Tom Mulcair was not running the party.

    Justin Trudeau Might Be Open To Forming Coalition With NDP, But Not With Mulcair As Leader

    B.C. 'Hosed' In Coquitlam Land Sale To Liberal Donor

    B.C. 'Hosed' In Coquitlam Land Sale To Liberal Donor
    NDP justice critic Mike Farnworth said British Columbians were "hosed" when the government sold about 150 hectares of property in Coquitlam for $85 million when the land was appraised at $128 million.

    B.C. 'Hosed' In Coquitlam Land Sale To Liberal Donor

    ID Of RCMP Agent To Stay Secret In Case Of Accused Pakistani Bomb Plotter

    ID Of RCMP Agent To Stay Secret In Case Of Accused Pakistani Bomb Plotter
    TORONTO — The identity of an undercover RCMP officer who befriended a Pakistani man accused of plotting terror attacks in Toronto should remain secret, the Immigration and Refugee Board ruled Tuesday.

    ID Of RCMP Agent To Stay Secret In Case Of Accused Pakistani Bomb Plotter

    Ontario Lawyer Disbarred After Faking Court Documents, Emails, Misleading Client

    Ontario Lawyer Disbarred After Faking Court Documents, Emails, Misleading Client
    TORONTO — An Ontario lawyer has been disbarred after fabricating a series of court orders and emails while pretending to take legal action on behalf of one of his clients.

    Ontario Lawyer Disbarred After Faking Court Documents, Emails, Misleading Client