Close X
Thursday, October 3, 2024
ADVT 
National

Liberals' proposed AI law too vague

Darpan News Desk The Canadian Press, 07 Feb, 2024 05:14 PM
  • Liberals' proposed AI law too vague

Representatives from Big Tech companies say a Liberal government bill that would begin regulating some artificial intelligence systems is too vague.

Amazon and Microsoft executives told MPs at a House of Commons industry committee meeting Wednesday that Bill C-27 doesn't differentiate enough between high- and low-risk AI systems.

The companies said abiding by the law as written would be costly.

Nicole Foster, director of global artificial intelligence and Canada public policy for Amazon, said using the same approach for all applications is "very impractical and could inadvertently stifle innovation."

The use of AI by a peace officer is considered high-impact in all cases, she said — even when an officer is using auto-correct to fill out a ticket for a traffic violation. 

"Laws and regulations must clearly differentiate between high-risk applications and those that pose little or no risk. This is a core principle we have to get right," Foster said.

"We should be very careful about imposing regulatory burdens on low-risk AI applications that can potentially provide much-needed productivity boosts to Canadian companies both big and small."

Microsoft gave its own example of how the law doesn't seem to differentiate based on the level of risk that particular AI systems introduce.

An AI system used to approve a person's mortgage and handle sensitive details about their finances would be considered the same as one that is used to optimize package delivery routes using public data. 

Industry Minister François-Philippe Champagne has been offering some information about amendments the government expects to put forward to the bill to ensure it is up-to-date. 

But in spite of that additional detail, companies said the definitions in the bill are still too ambiguous. 

Amanda Craig, senior director of public policy at Microsoft's office of responsible AI, said not differentiating between the two would "spread thinly the time, money, talent and resources of Canadian businesses — and potentially mean finite resources are not sufficiently focused on the highest risk." 

Bill C-27 was tabled in 2022 to target what are described as "high-impact" AI systems. 

But generative AI systems such as ChatGPT, which can create text, images and videos, became widely available to the public only after the bill was first introduced.

The Liberals now say they will amend the legislation to introduce new rules, including requiring companies behind such systems to take steps to ensure the content they create is identifiable as AI-generated.

Earlier this week, Yoshua Bengio, dubbed a "godfather" of AI, told the same committee that Ottawa should put a law in place immediately, even if that legislation is not perfect.

Bengio, the scientific director at Mila, the Quebec AI Institute, said a "superhuman" intelligence that is as smart as a human being could arrive as soon as in a few years.

Advanced systems could ultimately be used for cyberattacks, he said, and the law needs to get out ahead of that risk. 

AI already poses risks. Deepfake videos, which are generated to make it look like a real person is doing or saying something that they never did, can be used to spread disinformation, said Bengio.

 

MORE National ARTICLES

Nicole Chan feared she'd lose job: VPD sergeant

Nicole Chan feared she'd lose job: VPD sergeant
A civil lawsuit filed on behalf of Chan's family last year claims she died by suicide in January 2019 during a severe mental health crisis after being "extorted" by Sgt. David Van Patten to continue their sexual relationship.

Nicole Chan feared she'd lose job: VPD sergeant

Drug decriminalization data to be made public

Drug decriminalization data to be made public
Over 11,000 people have fatally overdosed in the province from toxic street drugs since it was declared a public health emergency in 2016. The new policy means people who carry drugs up to the permitted threshold for their own use will no longer be arrested or charged, and their illegal substances will no longer be seized.

Drug decriminalization data to be made public

NDP want emergency debate on private health care

NDP want emergency debate on private health care
It’s a top priority for the leader as members of Parliament return to the House Monday following a holiday break. Singh spent some of that time away holding round table discussions on health care in British Columbia to discuss emergency room overcrowding and worker shortages.

NDP want emergency debate on private health care

Canadian police chiefs speak out on Nichols' death

Canadian police chiefs speak out on Nichols' death
The condemnation of the actions that led to Tyre Nichols' death came as authorities in Memphis, Tenn., released a video of what happened. The footage shows officers holding Nichols down and striking him repeatedly as he screamed for his mother.    

Canadian police chiefs speak out on Nichols' death

Dix 'delighted' premiers will meet PM on health

Dix 'delighted' premiers will meet PM on health
Adrian Dix says the premiers had long been asking to meet Justin Trudeau as they call on Ottawa to boost its contributions through the Canada Health Transfer. Dix says a "major impediment" has been overcome simply by agreeing to sitting down at the Feb. 7 talks in Ottawa, as the premiers had been asking to meet for two years.

Dix 'delighted' premiers will meet PM on health

129 cattle seized from B.C. property: SPCA

129 cattle seized from B.C. property: SPCA
They were also suffering from a range of medical issues, including untreated eye infections, lameness, inflamed udders, overgrown hoofs and diarrhea. The statement says "numerous carcasses" of dead cows were also discovered on the property.

129 cattle seized from B.C. property: SPCA