Close X
Monday, January 13, 2025
ADVT 
National

Legal Battle Over Set-Top TV Boxes Pits Copyright Against Innovation

The Canadian Press, 12 Jul, 2016 11:36 AM
    TORONTO — A legal battle is brewing over the use of TV boxes that grant access to web streaming content in a standoff that raises questions about the need to protect copyright while fostering innovation.
     
    The David-and-Goliath standoff pits some of the country's biggest cable companies against small, little-known firms that sell set-top boxes, devices that come preloaded with software that allow customers to watch shows on their TVs — legally or not.
     
    Bell, Rogers, Videotron and Groupe TVA Inc. argue in a statement of claim that the distributors of the set-top boxes are infringing on their copyright by selling the devices and are asking the courts to permanently force them off the market.
     
    Last month, a judge ordered an injunction that prevents five defendants and any future ones named in the lawsuit from selling set-top boxes until the case is resolved. After the injunction was granted, the cable companies added 11 defendants to their lawsuit.
     
    Two of the 16 defendants, WatchSaveNow Inc. and MTLFREETV.COM, have filed a statement of defence denying allegations including that they advertised their services as a way to watch free TV. They also rejected accusations that they developed, produced, serviced or maintained the software loaded onto the boxes.
     
    They have also filed an appeal of the injunction and a counterclaim for yet-to-be-determined damages for loss of business, business reputation and goodwill.
     
    Ariel Katz, an associate professor and innovation chair in electronic commerce at the University of Toronto's faculty of law, said it's not clear that what people are doing with the devices is illegal.
     
     
    Even if it were, the seller is not authorizing copyright infringement by providing equipment that could be used to obtain copyrighted material, said Katz.
     
    Computers, for example, often come with preloaded content that can be used to reproduce copyrighted materials, he said.
     
    "In order to prohibit the sale of something ... there needs to be a legal basis for doing that, and the fact that people can use it for illegal purposes is not necessarily a good enough reason," he said.
     
    It's hard to know how the injunction can apply to other products, he added.
     
    Jacqueline Michelis, a spokeswoman for Bell, said the case boils down to the need to protect copyright.
     
    "Loading uncertified TV boxes up with off-the-shelf piracy apps isn't innovation, it's illegal," she said in an email.
     
    Jennifer Kett, a spokeswoman for Rogers, said in an email the company is an innovator "at heart" and the TV industry will continue to evolve to meet customer needs, but this is a "very obvious" case of piracy.
     
    But Meghan Sali, a digital rights specialist with advocacy group OpenMedia, said fears of costly legal battles could further stifle innovation in Canada by preventing entrepreneurs from receiving capital during the start-up phase of their business or discourage them from pursuing innovative solutions.
     
     
    Katz agrees.
     
    "If you're a small business and you can't afford the millions that (you) might require to properly defend such a case, then you just decide, 'OK, it's not really worth it,'" said Katz.

    MORE National ARTICLES

    MP John Aldag Appointed to Special Parliamentary Committee on Electoral Reform

    MP John Aldag Appointed to Special Parliamentary Committee on Electoral Reform
      “I am very excited to have been asked to join this committee and I am thrilled that we are starting this important dialogue with Canadians.”

    MP John Aldag Appointed to Special Parliamentary Committee on Electoral Reform

    Police Investigate Human Bone Fragment Found On Newfoundland Beach

    Police Investigate Human Bone Fragment Found On Newfoundland Beach
    FERRYLAND, N.L. — The RCMP in Newfoundland and Labrador are investigating after a human bone fragment was found on a beach.

    Police Investigate Human Bone Fragment Found On Newfoundland Beach

    Five Years In Prison For Drunk Driving Crash Which Killed London, Ont. University Student

    Five Years In Prison For Drunk Driving Crash Which Killed London, Ont. University Student
    Jared Dejong had more than twice the legal limit of alcohol in his blood when he was arrested in the October 2015 collision that claimed the life of 18-year-old Andrea Christidis.

    Five Years In Prison For Drunk Driving Crash Which Killed London, Ont. University Student

    Emergency Declared As Receding Flood Waters Reveal Damage In Dawson Creek

    Emergency Declared As Receding Flood Waters Reveal Damage In Dawson Creek
    Dale Bumstead issued the declaration Friday morning, saying it is the next step in the community's recovery from flooding that forced evacuations, destroyed or damaged bridges and washed away the CN rail line.

    Emergency Declared As Receding Flood Waters Reveal Damage In Dawson Creek

    Trudeau Touts Canadian Tech Industry At New Microsoft Centre In Vancouver

    Trudeau Touts Canadian Tech Industry At New Microsoft Centre In Vancouver
      The prime minister took a tour of the Microsoft Canada Excellence Centre at its official opening on Friday morning.

    Trudeau Touts Canadian Tech Industry At New Microsoft Centre In Vancouver

    Police Probe Theft Of Tiger Skin From Historic Victoria Watering Hole

    Police Probe Theft Of Tiger Skin From Historic Victoria Watering Hole
    Police say the tiger pelt that was a traditional fixture at the former Bengal Lounge at Victoria's Fairmont Empress Hotel was stolen this week.

    Police Probe Theft Of Tiger Skin From Historic Victoria Watering Hole