Close X
Tuesday, September 24, 2024
ADVT 
National

Lawyers who challenged Nadon appointment to high court get only $5K in costs

Darpan News Desk The Canadian Press, 10 Dec, 2014 10:54 AM

    OTTAWA — The lawyers who set out to challenge Marc Nadon's nomination to the Supreme Court of Canada have been rebuffed in a bid to recoup their costs.

    Toronto lawyer Rocco Galati and the Constitutional Rights Centre claimed more than $68,000 in fees and costs, but were instead awarded a $5,000 lump sum by the Federal Court of Canada.

    Galati filed for $51,706.54 and the centre sought $16,769.20 for work done by lawyer Paul Slansky.

    In his decision, Federal Court Judge Russel Zinn calls those bills unwarranted.

    Zinn says the application challenging the 2013 appointment of Nadon — whose nomination was ultimately rejected in a ruling by the high court itself — would have been complicated and important had it gone ahead.

    However, he says it was essentially sidelined by a subsequent governmental reference to the Supreme Court, rendering their cost claims excessive.

    "Although the application would have involved complex issues of law and have been of importance to the judicial system and the Constitution of Canada, the application was derailed and supplanted by the reference," Zinn wrote in his ruling.

    "As such, very little work needed to be done on the application by the applicants. The mere filing of it appears to have had the desired result."

    He added, though, that the challenge was important.

    "At the time the application was filed, there was no apparent objection made to the appointment of Justice Nadon on constitutional grounds by any person or government. To that extent, one could argue that the applicants have done Canada a service and should not be out-of-pocket in so doing."

    That was Zinn's justification for the $5,000 lump sum.

    Galati had argued that Nadon, a judge of the Federal Court of Appeal, was not eligible to be appointed to one of the three high court seats reserved for Quebec.

    The Supreme Court agreed and Nadon's appointment was rescinded.

    Suzanne Cote was appointed to fill the vacancy.

    MORE National ARTICLES

    Mariner Appeals Conviction In Fatal Ferry Sinking Off BC

    Mariner Appeals Conviction In Fatal Ferry Sinking Off BC
    VANCOUVER — B.C.'s highest court is set to hear the case of the navigating officer who was on the bridge of a provincial passenger ferry the night the vessel sank, killing two people.

    Mariner Appeals Conviction In Fatal Ferry Sinking Off BC

    Fire co-ordinator discusses chaos at scene of Quebec fire that killed 32 people

    Fire co-ordinator discusses chaos at scene of Quebec fire that killed 32 people
    RIVIERE-DU-LOUP, Que. — A regional fire-safety co-ordinator has described a scene of chaos when he arrived early one morning last January at a Quebec seniors' home where 32 people died.

    Fire co-ordinator discusses chaos at scene of Quebec fire that killed 32 people

    Magnotta trial hears psychiatrist unable to track down accused's acquaintances

    Magnotta trial hears psychiatrist unable to track down accused's acquaintances
    MONTREAL — A psychiatrist who assessed Luka Rocco Magnotta for criminal responsibility says he wasn't able to interview two people the accused said had a major presence in his life.

    Magnotta trial hears psychiatrist unable to track down accused's acquaintances

    Residential school lawsuits in Newfoundland and Labrador could face delay

    Residential school lawsuits in Newfoundland and Labrador could face delay
    ST. JOHN'S, N.L. — Former Newfoundland and Labrador residential school students suing for an apology and compensation listened today as a federal application was argued that could delay the case for months.

    Residential school lawsuits in Newfoundland and Labrador could face delay

    Jury sees damaged boat at murder trial of lobster fisherman in Cape Breton

    Jury sees damaged boat at murder trial of lobster fisherman in Cape Breton
    PORT HAWKESBURY, N.S. — The damaged boat that Phillip Boudreau was on before he disappeared in a Cape Breton harbour was shown to the jury on Tuesday at the second-degree murder trial of a man who has pleaded not guilty in his slaying.

    Jury sees damaged boat at murder trial of lobster fisherman in Cape Breton

    Manitoba moves to get children under government care out of hotels

    Manitoba moves to get children under government care out of hotels
    WINNIPEG — The Manitoba government is taking steps to reduce the number of children in care housed in hotels.

    Manitoba moves to get children under government care out of hotels