Close X
Saturday, November 30, 2024
ADVT 
National

Lawyer wants autopsies on dead babies from Winnipeg storage locker to be fair

Darpan News Desk The Canadian Press, 07 Nov, 2014 10:33 AM

    WINNIPEG — A lawyer for a woman accused of hiding the remains of six infants in a storage locker says an independent pathologist should observe the autopsies which are to determine whether the babies were viable.

    Greg Brodsky, who represents Andrea Giesbrecht, told a judge Friday he is not on a "fishing trip" and just wants to ensure the examinations are done fairly. Brodsky referred to the remains as "fetuses" and said they are not considered people under the law if they were less than 20 weeks gestation.

    He added that the autopsy also has to determine if the infants were stillborn. That determination may come down to a matter of opinion, Brodsky said.

    "It's like a traffic accident," he told provincial court Judge Brian Corrin. "Two people see different things although they're looking at the same thing."

    Giesbrecht, who showed no emotion during the hearing, is charged with six counts of concealing a body and one count of breaching probation.

    The 40-year-old has been in custody since the remains were discovered by employees at a U-Haul storage facility in Winnipeg on Oct. 20. They had gone to do inventory since the bill hadn't been paid.

    The state of the remains was such that police said it could take months of forensic examination before it might be known who the parents were, how the infants died and whether they were full term.

    Thambirajah Balachandra, Manitoba's chief medical examiner, is opposed to Brodsky's request. He said it would be like having the accused in the examination room. His lawyer has said the autopsies are already "90 per cent complete."

    Brodsky said police are allowed to observe the autopsies so his client should be given the same right.

    "The person who has the most to lose is not entitled to be there, according to the Crown," Brodsky said. "If you look hard enough, you may find evidence that doesn't exist."

    He pointed to the notorious case of a woman in Australia charged with the death of her baby, even though she always said the infant was killed by a wild dingo. She was eventually exonerated.

    "People looking at the same injuries saw different things," Brodsky said.

    The judge asked the lawyer if he would be satisfied if police were also excluded from the autopsy room. Brodsky said he would take that suggestion under advisement if a pathologist is not allowed to watch the examination.

    The pathologist hired by the defence would not influence the autopsy, but would simply observe the examination "with his hands in his pockets and Velcro on his mouth," Brodsky said.

    "All I want is someone to observe."

    Crown attorney Debbie Bours argued the provincial court doesn't have jurisdiction over the medical examiner's office. She said the Crown would be filing a motion with Court of Queen's Bench that the hearing is outside the scope of Corrin's courtroom.

    "We have indicated previously that was our position," she told the court.

    MORE National ARTICLES

    Newfoundland and Labrador premier faces first big test with three byelections

    Newfoundland and Labrador premier faces first big test with three byelections
    ST. JOHN'S, N.L. — Paul Davis faces a major test as Newfoundland and Labrador premier with three byelections scheduled this month, the first in a Progressive Conservative stronghold.

    Newfoundland and Labrador premier faces first big test with three byelections

    Scotiabank to cut 1,500 positions worldwide, take profit hit in fourth quarter

    Scotiabank to cut 1,500 positions worldwide, take profit hit in fourth quarter
    TORONTO — Scotiabank (TSX:BNS) plans to cut 1,500 jobs — about two-thirds of them in Canada — as it restructures its operations and closes 120 branches at its international banking arm.

    Scotiabank to cut 1,500 positions worldwide, take profit hit in fourth quarter

    Details on next steps for federal refugee health care to be unveiled today

    Details on next steps for federal refugee health care to be unveiled today
    OTTAWA — Immigration Minister Chris Alexander says the government will comply with a court ruling that set today as a deadline to create a new refugee health care program.

    Details on next steps for federal refugee health care to be unveiled today

    Visa, Mastercard agree to cut fees they charge merchants who accept credit cards

    Visa, Mastercard agree to cut fees they charge merchants who accept credit cards
    OTTAWA — The federal government has announced a voluntary agreement by Visa and Mastercard to reduce merchant credit card fees to an average effective rate of 1.5 per cent for the next five years.

    Visa, Mastercard agree to cut fees they charge merchants who accept credit cards

    'Q' executive producer on leave amid Ghomeshi scandal

    'Q' executive producer on leave amid Ghomeshi scandal
    TORONTO — The most senior producer at the CBC Radio show "Q" is taking time off amid the scandal around its former host, Jian Ghomeshi, a spokesman said Tuesday.

    'Q' executive producer on leave amid Ghomeshi scandal

    RCMP Vessel Rescues Crew From Sunken Tug Off Vancouver Island's West Coast

    RCMP Vessel Rescues Crew From Sunken Tug Off Vancouver Island's West Coast
    NANAIMO, B.C. — RCMP says its patrol vessel, the Inkster, was just minutes away from a sinking tug when its crew sent out a mayday call on Sunday morning.

    RCMP Vessel Rescues Crew From Sunken Tug Off Vancouver Island's West Coast