Close X
Saturday, December 14, 2024
ADVT 
National

Lawyer Proposing Cold-FX Class Action Is 'Manufacturing' Case, Says Drug Maker

The Canadian Press, 07 Apr, 2016 11:45 AM
    VANCOUVER — The lawyer pushing for a class-action lawsuit over the alleged shortcomings of a popular cold and flu remedy is manufacturing a case with no real complainants, a court has heard.
     
    Valeant Pharmaceuticals (TSX:VRX) says lawyer John Green's proposed legal action is a construct and that British Columbia Supreme Court shouldn't grant it class-action certification.
     
    The drug company is defending allegations it misled customers about the natural-health product's short-term effectiveness in reducing cold and flu symptoms, which its advertising claimed in the past.
     
    "Class actions are intended to be for real people with real complaints and they are not intended to be … manufactured by entrepreneurial counsel," said Valeant lawyer Alan D'Silva.
     
    "These cases are meant for real complainants and real grievances. There are none in this case."
     
    Vancouver Island resident Don Harrison launched a claim in 2012 against Valeant and its subsidiary, Afexa Life Sciences, over advertising that said Cold-FX offered "immediate relief of cold and flu symptoms'' if taken over a three-day period at the first sign of illness.
     
    D'Silva told the court that at no point has Harrison sworn an official court document explaining the reason he purchased Cold-FX, whether he took it, if he felt he was misled or whether he ever complained and asked for a refund.
     
    "He doesn't even say he was unhappy," said D'Silva.
     
    "One of the fundamental problems is that ... more than four years into this litigation, they still do not have a single person (who's) come forward to swear an affidavit and say these things. Not a single person."
     
    Earlier this week, Green pointed to an internal Valeant study that he said surfaced during court proceedings and shows the drug is no more effective at reducing symptoms than a placebo.
     
    D'Silva disputed both Green's conclusion, as well as the allegation the drug maker in any way attempted to conceal the research.
     
    "What Mr. Green has done, both in his argument and in his many comments and discussions with the media leading up to today's hearing, is to very selectively cherry-pick a chart out of one of the studies, which does not accurately reflect what we've put in the record," D'Silva said.
     
    He pointed to that particular study's conclusion, which said Cold-FX was in fact effective at treating a runny nose.
     
    D'Silva also opposed the lawsuit receiving class-action approval because of the absence of an easily defined class of complainants, which is one of the criteria for certification.
     
    Not everyone who purchased Cold-FX would be eligible, rather only those who bought the product with the intention to use it in the way that was allegedly falsely advertised, namely to treat immediate symptoms with a three-day dosage routine, he said.
     
    If the case is granted class-action certification and goes on to win in court, Green says anyone who bought Cold-FX to treat immediate cold and flu symptoms could be eligible for a refund.

    MORE National ARTICLES

    Ontario Elementary Students To Get Five Hours A Week Of Math Instruction

    Ontario Elementary Students To Get Five Hours A Week Of Math Instruction
    Education Minister says the province will spend $60 million to help students improve their test results in math

    Ontario Elementary Students To Get Five Hours A Week Of Math Instruction

    TransCanada Shuts Down KeyStone Pipeline After Oil Spill In South Dakota

    TransCanada Shuts Down KeyStone Pipeline After Oil Spill In South Dakota
    The pipeline, which carries about 500,000 barrels of oil a day, was shut down in minutes

    TransCanada Shuts Down KeyStone Pipeline After Oil Spill In South Dakota

    Rental Housing Is For Residents, Says Vancouver Councillor Eyeing Airbnb Rules

    Rental Housing Is For Residents, Says Vancouver Councillor Eyeing Airbnb Rules
    Coun. Geoff Meggs wants to expand and accelerate a study already underway by city staff on the effect Airbnb and similar websites are having on the supply of rental housing.

    Rental Housing Is For Residents, Says Vancouver Councillor Eyeing Airbnb Rules

    Online Tool Educates Teachers To Help Kids Returning To School After Concussion

    Online Tool Educates Teachers To Help Kids Returning To School After Concussion
    Teachers across Canada can now get advice from a new program to help students returning to school after a concussion.

    Online Tool Educates Teachers To Help Kids Returning To School After Concussion

    B.C. Seniors-Care Facility Cuts Entire Staff Over Reports Of Chronic Underfunding

    B.C. Seniors-Care Facility Cuts Entire Staff Over Reports Of Chronic Underfunding
      More than 150 employees at Wexford Creek Care Home in Nanaimo, B.C., ranging from nurses to care aides, received pink slips on Friday.

    B.C. Seniors-Care Facility Cuts Entire Staff Over Reports Of Chronic Underfunding

    Transport Canada Report Raises Alarm Over Aging Coast Guard Fleet

    A report done for Transport Canada and quietly tabled in the House of Commons, paints a grim portrait of the country's coast guard fleet, saying it is understaffed, desperately in need of new ships 

    Transport Canada Report Raises Alarm Over Aging Coast Guard Fleet