Close X
Wednesday, December 4, 2024
ADVT 
National

Lawyer Held Personally Liable For Legal Costs Of Failed Court Actions

Darpan News Desk The Canadian Press, 22 Jun, 2016 11:46 AM
    TORONTO — A prominent Toronto lawyer who pursued a frivolous action on behalf of a client was found personally liable Tuesday for the legal costs incurred, a decision he said could deter lawyers from taking on tough cases.
     
    In upholding the $84,000 costs award against Paul Slansky, the Ontario Court of Appeal faulted his conduct for his involvement in the vexatious proceeding.
     
    Slansky, the Appeal Court said, had wasted money unnecessarily by "acting on unreasonable instructions from, or providing unreasonable advice to, his client."
     
    In response, Slansky said he disagreed with the ruling.
     
    "Lawyers who act in good faith for a client in difficult cases must now be concerned that if the case is lost, they may be found liable for costs if a judge thinks that the action was not well-founded," Slansky told The Canadian Press.
     
    "This creates a chill on all lawyers deterring them from taking on difficult cases."
     
    The situation began in 2007 when Donald Best sued 62 defendants for negligence and economic loss. The action was stayed in 2009, and Best was later found in contempt for failing to comply with court orders. In 2012, he accused the defendants and their lawyers of perjury, conspiracy, fraud, obstruction of justice and fabrication of evidence — accusations a judge rejected as baseless.
     
    Best served 60 days in prison for contempt. He then engaged Slansky to appeal.
     
    In doing so, Slansky tried to force the opposing lawyers to step down by repeating Best's allegations of serious misconduct against them. That attempt failed and a court awarded costs against Best, who tried unsuccessfully to get the Supreme Court of Canada to intervene. He didn't pay up.
     
    While this was going on, Best also launched a new suit through Slansky against 39 defendants. He again made serious allegations of misconduct against opposing lawyers, police and private investigators.
     
     
    A judge eventually found Best had used the rules to "create the need for an unnecessary and time-consuming motion" and that his behaviour had been reprehensible, unnecessary and unreasonable.
     
    On several occasions before and after that decision, lawyers for the other side warned Slansky they would seek costs against him personally for his various legal delays and manoeuvres.
     
    "Your approach to this litigation has been abusive and continues to waste an astonishing amount of money on legal costs," they wrote.
     
    "You personally have caused these costs to be incurred without any reasonable cause by either acquiescing to absolutely unreasonable instructions from your client, or worse by advising your client to take the unreasonable steps he has taken through you."
     
    Last fall, Justice Susan Healey dismissed the various actions brought by Best, saying they were without a "scintilla of merit" and that it was the most "vexatious and abusive" claim ever to come before her. In October, Healey found Slansky liable for $84,000 in costs.
     
    Slansky turned to the Court of Appeal, which on Tuesday rejected his argument the costs award was unfair and flowed from his pursuit of a weak case.
     
    The Appeal Court also ordered Slansky to pay another $30,000 for the costs of the appeal.

    MORE National ARTICLES

    Cape Breton University Soccer Player Banned From Play After Drug Violation

    OTTAWA — An elite soccer player from Cape Breton has been banned from the game for 18 months after admitting to taking a prohibited substance last year.

    Cape Breton University Soccer Player Banned From Play After Drug Violation

    Canadian Brands Cashing In On 'Anti-Trumpism' To Appeal To Americans

    Canadian Brands Cashing In On 'Anti-Trumpism' To Appeal To Americans
    Canadian companies are cashing in on so-called anti-Trumpism in the United States, offering our neighbours to the south an escape plan should Donald Trump win the presidential election in November.

    Canadian Brands Cashing In On 'Anti-Trumpism' To Appeal To Americans

    $85m Grant For Chrysler Not Corporate Welfare, Wynne Says

      Wynne made the announcement today at the Fiat Chrysler Automotive Research and Development Centre in Windsor.

    $85m Grant For Chrysler Not Corporate Welfare, Wynne Says

    Manitoba Legislature Could See Gender-Neutral Washrooms: Premier

    Manitoba Legislature Could See Gender-Neutral Washrooms: Premier
    Manitoba Premier Brian Pallister, a Progressive Conservative long accused by his NDP opponents of being homophobic, said Tuesday he is considering a request to have a gender-neutral public washroom in the legislature.

    Manitoba Legislature Could See Gender-Neutral Washrooms: Premier

    RCMP Investigating 3 Sex Assault Allegations Against Male Student: SFU

    RCMP Investigating 3 Sex Assault Allegations Against Male Student: SFU
    Male student who is the subject of the allegations is not on campus, but he did not say if he was suspended or expelled.

    RCMP Investigating 3 Sex Assault Allegations Against Male Student: SFU

    Edmonton Doctor Ismail Taher's Appeal Of Sex Assault Conviction On Patient Turned Down

    Edmonton Doctor Ismail Taher's Appeal Of Sex Assault Conviction On Patient Turned Down
    Ismail Taher voluntarily stopped practising medicine after he was found guilty of groping an 18-year-old woman who went to a medicentre in Sherwood Park

    Edmonton Doctor Ismail Taher's Appeal Of Sex Assault Conviction On Patient Turned Down