Close X
Wednesday, December 4, 2024
ADVT 
National

Lawyer for pharma company argues against single trial in B.C. opioid damages case

Darpan News Desk The Canadian Press, 29 Nov, 2023 02:15 PM
  • Lawyer for pharma company argues against single trial in B.C. opioid damages case

A lawyer for a pharmaceutical firm says holding a single trial in British Columbia to determine damages for each province and territory related to opioid health-care costs would be a "monster of complexity."

Gordon McKee, a lawyer for Janssen Inc. and Johnson & Johnson, told the B.C. Supreme Court that certifying Canadian governments as a class in their pursuit of damages against opioid makers isn't manageable or preferable compared with separate trials. 

McKee says the judge should not certify Canadian governments as a class in the case because it would "burden" B.C.'s justice system and have a negative affect on access to justice for other potential litigants. 

He says other courts in the past have recognized that some class-action lawsuits are "too big to certify," and there are enough separate issues in each province or territory that make a single trial unmanageable.

McKee says individual trials specific to each jurisdiction would be more suited and "appropriately spreads the burden" of the complex issues among provincial and territorial justice systems. 

A lawyer for the B.C. government asked the court this week to certify the class allowing provinces and territories to join their claims against the dozens of defendant companies, saying the actions are nearly identical claiming health care costs related to the opioid crisis that has killed or injured thousands of Canadians. 

MORE National ARTICLES

COVID19 activity slumping in BC

COVID19 activity slumping in BC
The sharp uptick in B-C's COVID-19 activity may be waning, according to the latest data from the province's Centre for Disease Control. Numbers show new hospitalizations dropped to 144 in the week ending November 4th, down from 296 three weeks earlier.

COVID19 activity slumping in BC

Heavy rain, wind and snow expected for portions of B.C. over next several days

Heavy rain, wind and snow expected for portions of B.C. over next several days
The agency has issued multiple warnings for Metro Vancouver, saying 50 to 70 millimetres of rain is expected to hit the Fraser Valley and the Northshore and northeast regions beginning tonight. Forecasters say the rain should taper off over parts of Metro Vancouver on Saturday morning but persist in the Fraser Valley until the evening.  

Heavy rain, wind and snow expected for portions of B.C. over next several days

Canada investigating 'threats' to Air India, say transport minister and RCMP

Canada investigating 'threats' to Air India, say transport minister and RCMP
Canada's transport minister and the RCMP say an investigation is underway into what they call "threats" against Air India, after an online video warned people not to fly on the airline on Nov. 19. Pablo Rodriguez says in a social media post that the government takes any threat to aviation "extremely seriously."

Canada investigating 'threats' to Air India, say transport minister and RCMP

Kamloops man sentenced for murder

Kamloops man sentenced for murder
A B-C Supreme Court judge has sentenced a 35-year-old man from Kamloops to four years in prison for fatally stabbing another man outside a city centre motel more than three years ago. A jury had convicted James Sanford of manslaughter for the 2020 killing of a 34-year-old man.

Kamloops man sentenced for murder

B.C. shifts ambulance staffing for rural communities in bid to boost emergency care

B.C. shifts ambulance staffing for rural communities in bid to boost emergency care
British Columbia is shifting its ambulance paramedics staffing model for 60 rural and remote communities in what Health Minister Adrian Dix says is an "unprecedented" investment in emergency health care. Dix says three new staffing models for paramedics would increase the number of on-duty ambulance workers during nights and other off-peak times.

B.C. shifts ambulance staffing for rural communities in bid to boost emergency care

Feds, mayors don't want to 'slow things down' after premiers criticize housing deals

Feds, mayors don't want to 'slow things down' after premiers criticize housing deals
Federal Housing Minister Sean Fraser, who has been travelling across Canada to highlight such agreements made directly with cities, says he was also surprised by the backlash — but is not planning to back down.  

Feds, mayors don't want to 'slow things down' after premiers criticize housing deals