Close X
Wednesday, November 13, 2024
ADVT 
National

Kilt Ban For Ontario Bus Driver Was Not Discriminatory, Rights Tribunal Rules

Darpan News Desk The Canadian Press, 18 Dec, 2019 09:31 PM

    TORONTO - A bus driver sent home to change out of the kilt he wore to work on a casual Friday was not a victim of anti-Scottish discrimination, Ontario's human rights tribunal has ruled.

     

    In its decision, the tribunal decided that Tracy Macdonnell had provided no evidence the directive from Grand River Transit in the Region of Waterloo, Ont., was improper.

     

    "The applicant is proud of his ancestry and wears a kilt on special occasions. I find that he has not pointed to any evidence in his testimony to establish that he had the right, protected under the code, to wear a kilt at work or while on duty," adjudicator Josee Bouchard wrote in her decision. Macdonnell "has pointed to no evidence in his testimony to establish that he was harassed because of his ancestry," Bouchard wrote.

     

    The incident arose on a charity-fundraising Friday in October 2017, when a supervisor told the 14-year driver to change out of his rented kilt into a proper uniform. Macdonnell alleged discrimination because of his Scottish ancestry.

     

    Evidence at a hearing last month showed the bus line had previously made it clear to employees that kilts were off-limits on casual Fridays, despite the relaxed dress code in which some drivers wore jeans or "different coloured shirts." Kilts, the company said, were "not aligned with the typical bus operator uniform."

     

    Macdonnell testified the ban, in response to another driver who had previously shown up to work in a kilt, upset him and he wanted to make a point. He said he was proud of his Scottish ancestry, listened to Scottish music and ate haggis. He also said he was married wearing a kilt, although he did not own one.

     

    Macdonnell argued what he wore was akin to wearing a turban for religious reasons or clothing from other countries. He admitted to deliberately defying the no-kilt order so he could press his case.

     

    "He explained that on casual Fridays, employees wear all sorts of attire, such as shorts and ball caps, and he did not see what was wrong with wearing a kilt," Bouchard said. "In his view, forbidding employees to wear a kilt while on duty on casual Fridays is clearly discriminatory."

     

    Among other things, Macdonnell wanted the tribunal to order transit supervisors to undergo sensitivity training, accept cultural dress as appropriate attire on casual Fridays, and pay him $25,000 to cover the cost of his kilt rental and hurt feelings.

     

    In dismissing the application, Bouchard noted that Macdonnell complied with the order to change and returned to work that day. He was not disciplined and suffered no adverse employment consequences as a result of his initial defiance.

     

    "I believe that wearing a kilt has a special significance for the applicant and it is important for him to wear a kilt for special occasions," Bouchard said. However, "the applicant has not established that wearing a kilt, and more specifically wearing a kilt at work, is intricately linked to his ancestry."

     

    MORE National ARTICLES

    Twice As Nice: Construction Begins For Two Childcare Centres On Gastown Parkade Rooftop

    Twice As Nice: Construction Begins For Two Childcare Centres On Gastown Parkade Rooftop
    Construction is underway for two childcare centres which will provide 74 much-needed childcare spaces.

    Twice As Nice: Construction Begins For Two Childcare Centres On Gastown Parkade Rooftop

    How To Do Christmas Tree Recycling In Delta

    If your household decorates a real tree over the holiday season, there are plenty of convenient, sustainable ways that you can recycle after the holidays are done.

    How To Do Christmas Tree Recycling In Delta

    Kids: Join Coquitlam RCMP for Operation Tracking Santa on Christmas Eve

    A recent radio upgrade has given Coquitlam Mounties an unexpected side-benefit; a new-found ability to talk to Santa at Christmas.

    Kids: Join Coquitlam RCMP for Operation Tracking Santa on Christmas Eve

    Dipesh Patel, 34, Arrested In Toronto’s Multi-Jurisdictional Sexual Assault Investigation, Faces 20 Charges In Relation To Four Incidents

    Police Make Arrest After Allegedly Linking DNA From 4 Sex Assaults To Same Suspect

    Dipesh Patel, 34, Arrested In Toronto’s Multi-Jurisdictional Sexual Assault Investigation, Faces 20 Charges In Relation To Four Incidents

    Perminder Chohan Foundation Making The Holiday Season Better

    As the holiday season comes to an end with the arrival of 2020, everyone should be able to find some food and warmth in the upcoming winter months of the new year. 

    Perminder Chohan Foundation Making The Holiday Season Better

    Vancouver Council Approves Its First Moderate Income Rental Homes

    Vancouver Council has approved the first two rental projects under its Moderate Income Rental Pilot Program (MIRHPP), which will provide much needed below-market housing for individuals, couples, and families.

    Vancouver Council Approves Its First Moderate Income Rental Homes