Close X
Thursday, November 14, 2024
ADVT 
National

Keystone Pipeline-Maker Braces For Obama Rejection, Already Planning Next Move

The Canadian Press, 09 Aug, 2015 12:40 PM
    WASHINGTON — The Canadian company involved in the controversy-plagued Keystone XL pipeline project has begun planning its response to an anticipated rejection of the project by U.S. President Barack Obama.
     
    In its public statements, TransCanada Corp. is expressing hope Obama might still approve the pipeline, which over the course of its years-long delay has become an irritant between the U.S. and Canadian governments.
     
    But people close to the project say the company has become all but convinced a rejection is imminent based on signals the White House is sending publicly and privately — and it's now considering the next move.
     
    One possible response is a challenge under the North American Free Trade Agreement to recoup damages from the U.S. government. Another is immediately re-filing a permit application with the U.S. State Department before the 2016 presidential election.
     
    One source involved in the project said the company is consulting lawyers on the mechanics of a NAFTA challenge, and weighing the legal and political implications.
     
    He said the main suspense now is how Obama will make his big announcement — quietly, in a mid-summer Friday afternoon statement, or boldly from a platform like his upcoming Aug. 31 trip to a climate-change conference in Alaska.
     
    "There's a broad acceptance that the decision's been made," he said, adding that different White House employees had suggested a rejection's coming.
     
    "The rumour is that the decision to deny has been made, and they're just waiting for the right time and venue."
     
    He said the company would not likely reveal its next move on the day of the Obama announcement: "I think the most likely scenario is we'll let it cool for a while. And then we'd have this more vigorous discussion."
     
    One aspect of that internal discussion is the political calculus — and whether fanning the flames during the 2016 American election would help the project, or harm it.
     
    Keystone could easily become a 2016 issue, with Republicans already accusing Democratic stalling of hurting the economy, energy security, and relations with next-door neighbour Canada. Meanwhile, Democrats have been pushing their party frontrunner Hillary Clinton to state her position on the US$8 billion project.
     
    One expert said he'd advise the company to hold off, and hope a more pipeline-friendly administration takes office in 2017. The U.S. government has a 13-0 record in NAFTA cases. A suit would likely fail, cost the company a few million dollars, and possibly antagonize the U.S. government, said David Gantz, who was been a panelist on NAFTA cases and who teaches trade law at the University of Arizona.
     
    "I think it's a fairly long shot, it's an expensive way to do a long shot, and it doesn't seem to me to be something they're very likely to do," said Gantz.
     
    "They can talk about doing it but my guess is once they have consulted with counsel... they will decide it's — if not a long shot, then well under a 50-50 chance."
     
    He said the company could try filing under NAFTA's articles 1102, 1105 or 1110 — which deal with discrimination, unfair or arbitrary treatment and expropriation.
     
    But another expert said the company might as well try. She said a recent decision against the Canadian government in the Bilcon case involving a Nova Scotia quarry could give TransCanada some hope.
     
    "Why not? And see where it goes," said Debra Steger, who was the first director of the World Trade Organization's appellate body, and now teaches law at the University of Ottawa.
     
    The White House hasn't said when it will make a Keystone announcement, or what that announcement might be. However, it hasn't denied a claim by U.S. Sen. John Hoeven that a rejection is coming this month.
     
    The pipeline is also being fought in court in Nebraska. One opponent there said TransCanada should just let it go.
     
    ''No matter what they try, not an ounce of TransCanada's toxic pipeline will touch Nebraska's soil,'' said Jane Kleeb. ''At some point, TransCanada's investors are going to fire the CEO for wasting billions of dollars and years on a pipeline going nowhere.''
     
    TransCanada CEO Russ Girling hasn't speculated publicly on next steps. He recently said TransCanada will employ whatever means necessary to protect its shareholders and its shareholder value, but for now is focusing on getting a permit approved by Obama.

    MORE National ARTICLES

    Police Issued More Than 1,700 Tickets Over Improper Use Of Pan Am HOV Lanes

    Police Issued More Than 1,700 Tickets Over Improper Use Of Pan Am HOV Lanes
    TORONTO — Officers patrolling Toronto-area highways handed out 1,735 tickets for improper use of the controversial temporary high-occupancy lanes set up on for the Pan Am Games, police said Thursday.

    Police Issued More Than 1,700 Tickets Over Improper Use Of Pan Am HOV Lanes

    U.S. Hunter Who Killed African Lion In Alberta Records For A Mule Deer

    U.S. Hunter Who Killed African Lion In Alberta Records For A Mule Deer
    EDMONTON — There appears to be a Canadian connection to a U.S. hunter at the centre of a social media storm for killing a protected lion in Africa.

    U.S. Hunter Who Killed African Lion In Alberta Records For A Mule Deer

    Drought Prompts B.C. First Nations Group To Close Central Interior Fishery

    Drought Prompts B.C. First Nations Group To Close Central Interior Fishery
    KELOWNA, B.C. — Drought conditions in British Columbia have forced the closure of another fishery in the province's southern Interior.

    Drought Prompts B.C. First Nations Group To Close Central Interior Fishery

    Indian Home Minister Rajnath Singh Holds Pakistan Responsible For Dinanagar Attack

      Holding Pakistan responsible for the July 27 Dinanagar terror attack, union Home Minister Rajnath Singh on Thursday said any attack by enemies will meet an effective and forceful response from the Indian security forces.

    Indian Home Minister Rajnath Singh Holds Pakistan Responsible For Dinanagar Attack

    Dutch Police Release Edmonton Murder Suspect Omar. J. Elkadry From Caribbean Island Jail

    Dutch Police Release Edmonton Murder Suspect Omar. J. Elkadry From Caribbean Island Jail
    In early June, Dutch authorities on the island of Saba arrested the man as a suspect in the death of the woman, whose body was found in April.

    Dutch Police Release Edmonton Murder Suspect Omar. J. Elkadry From Caribbean Island Jail

    Trial Off Until Next May For Man Charged In 2012 Quebec Election-night Shooting

    Trial Off Until Next May For Man Charged In 2012 Quebec Election-night Shooting
    MONTREAL — There has been yet another delay in the trial for the man charged in Quebec's 2012 election-night shooting.

    Trial Off Until Next May For Man Charged In 2012 Quebec Election-night Shooting