Close X
Monday, November 11, 2024
ADVT 
National

Jury weighs fate of Toronto-area woman accused of ordering hit on her parents

Darpan News Desk The Canadian Press, 10 Dec, 2014 11:01 AM

    NEWMARKET, Ont. — A Toronto-area jury is now weighing the fate of a woman accused of plotting to have her parents killed in a phoney home invasion because they disapproved of her boyfriend.

    Jennifer Pan, 28, is charged with first-degree murder and attempted murder in the attack that killed her mother, 53-year-old Bieh Ha Pan, and left her father, 60-year-old Hann Pan, on the brink of death.

    Three others — Lenford Crawford, David Mylvaganam and her on-again, off-again boyfriend Daniel Wong — are also facing the same charges in the Nov. 8, 2010 slaying at the Pan's Markham, Ont. home.

    A fifth co-accused, Eric Carty, is now to be tried separately after his lawyer fell ill during the 10-month trial.

    In his final instructions before deliberations began, Judge Cary Boswell told the jury they must first decide whether they believe beyond a reasonable doubt there was a plan to commit murder and attempted murder that night.

    If they believe such a plan existed, the judge said, they must then determine whether each defendant participated in the plan, and knew that another accomplice meant to commit murder and attempted murder, and intended to aid and abet them. That would lead to a conviction of first-degree murder and attempted murder, he said.

    Should they conclude there was no murder plan, they must consider whether there was an agreement to commit a robbery — which would make Pan a victim along with her parents, he said. Pan's lawyer has argued that the attack was a robbery gone wrong, and that his client had no role in organizing it.

    In that case, the jury should decide whether each of the other accused took part in that agreement, and whether they knew that someone would probably commit murder and attempted murder during the robbery, Boswell said. If yes, then the accused in question would be guilty of second-degree murder and attempted murder, he said.

    Jurors can also find that a defendant didn't know murder or attempted murder were likely to happen, but that a reasonable person could have foreseen there was a "risk of harm" to the Pans in carrying out the robbery, the judge said, noting that all three intruders had guns.

    If so, that would lead to a manslaughter conviction, he said.

    Prosecutors allege Pan came up with the murder plan after receiving an ultimatum from her parents, forcing her to choose between Wong and her family.

    The couple had recently discovered that much of what their daughter had told them about her life — including that she had graduated university and was living with a friend — was part of an elaborate deception built over roughly 10 years, court heard. Finding out she was in fact living with Wong was the final straw, the jury heard.

    Pan and Wong secretly stayed in touch but their relationship grew strained, prosecutors said during trial. She nonetheless asked him for help in planning the hit, the Crown alleges, painting Wong and Crawford as middle-men between Pan and the intruders.

    Exactly who shot her parents remains unclear, with Pan saying on the stand that she didn't recognize the intruders among the accused.

    The defence suggested Carty was behind the robbery because he was desperate for money and knew Pan would be an easy target. Court has heard Carty is currently serving a life sentence in a 2009 murder.

    Pan, meanwhile, testified she knew nothing about the attack and never wanted her mother to die.

    Months earlier, bristling under her parents' strict rules and expectations, Pan tried to have her father killed, she admitted on the stand. But the plan fell through when the man she hired took off with her money, and Pan gave up on the idea, she said.

    It was her own death she was trying to arrange, Pan said, saying she had fallen into a deep depression as her family life crumbled. She abandoned that plan, too, when her relationship with her parents appeared to be on the mend in the fall of 2010, she testified.

    Calling off her suicide plan meant paying the would-be hit man — a man she knew only as Homeboy — $8,500 in cancellation fees, Pan told the court. She had been collecting the money the day of the attack, she said. Prosecutors allege Homeboy is a nickname for Crawford.

    Pan initially appeared to be a victim in the home invasion, telling police three men broke into the house and tied her up before shooting her parents.

    Her story started to fall apart once it became clear her father would survive, the Crown said. She was arrested Nov. 22, 2010, shortly after he was well enough to speak with investigators.

    Wong's lawyer said there is no direct evidence his client played a role in the attack, which happened while Wong was at work.

    Crawford was also at work, and in no way involved in planning or carrying out the events of that night, his defence lawyer said.

    Mylvaganam has admitted he was at the home to help commit a robbery and that a reasonable person could have known there was a chance the Pans would get hurt. But his lawyer said Mylvaganam didn't shoot anyone, nor did he expect anyone to die.

    MORE National ARTICLES

    Four Arrested After Five People Shot In Toronto: Police

    Four Arrested After Five People Shot In Toronto: Police
    TORONTO — Four people have been arrested in a shooting in northwest Toronto that sent five people to hospital, one with life-threatening injuries, police said Thursday.

    Four Arrested After Five People Shot In Toronto: Police

    Nearly Half Of Canadian Web Users Now Streaming Music, Most Using Mobile: Poll

    Nearly Half Of Canadian Web Users Now Streaming Music, Most Using Mobile: Poll
    TORONTO — Almost half of all Canadian Internet users say they now stream music online, according to the results of a newly released survey.

    Nearly Half Of Canadian Web Users Now Streaming Music, Most Using Mobile: Poll

    High household debt still a key risk to Canadian economy: Bank of Canada

    High household debt still a key risk to Canadian economy: Bank of Canada
    OTTAWA — The Bank of Canada is once again pointing a finger at mounting household debt as one of the biggest weak spots in the country's economic armour.

    High household debt still a key risk to Canadian economy: Bank of Canada

    Slumping oil prices to impact home prices in Calgary in 2015: Re/Max report

    Slumping oil prices to impact home prices in Calgary in 2015: Re/Max report
    TORONTO — Slumping oil prices are likely to impact Calgary's real estate market in the coming year, causing home prices to slow their rapid acceleration in Alberta's largest city, according to a report by realtor group Re/Max.

    Slumping oil prices to impact home prices in Calgary in 2015: Re/Max report

    Today on the Hill: Supreme Court briefs media on coming privacy decision

    Today on the Hill: Supreme Court briefs media on coming privacy decision
    OTTAWA — A decision that could have a major impact on the digital privacy rights of Canadians comes down this week at the Supreme Court of Canada.

    Today on the Hill: Supreme Court briefs media on coming privacy decision

    Lawyers who challenged Nadon appointment to high court get only $5K in costs

    Lawyers who challenged Nadon appointment to high court get only $5K in costs
    OTTAWA — The lawyers who set out to challenge Marc Nadon's nomination to the Supreme Court of Canada have been rebuffed in a bid to recoup their costs.

    Lawyers who challenged Nadon appointment to high court get only $5K in costs

    PrevNext