Close X
Thursday, November 28, 2024
ADVT 
National

Judge rules against blood-sample evidence after B.C. crash that killed 2 people

Cam Fortems, Kamloops This Week, Darpan, 04 Sep, 2014 02:33 PM
    KAMLOOPS, B.C. - The alleged driver in a crash that killed two people registered a blood-alcohol reading 50 per cent higher than the legal limit about an hour after the incident but a judge has ruled against the evidence.
     
    The results obtained through a blood sample taken at a hospital can't be used by the Crown because police failed to read the man on trial his legal rights beforehand, B.C. Supreme Court Justice Deborah Kloegman said.
     
    She said those rights included the right for Wayne Fedan, 53, to speak to a lawyer without cost or delay.
     
    However, she allowed as evidence a statement Fedan gave to a paramedic, in which he admitted to driving that night and drinking three rye and cokes beginning five hours earlier.
     
    Fedan is charged with two counts each of impaired driving causing death and dangerous driving causing death.
     
    The single-vehicle wreck killed 20-year-old Brittany Plotnikoff and 38-year-old Kenneth Craigdaillie in the early hours of March 20, 2010.
     
    While the Crown had said it would not use a blood-alcohol reading taken by police following the crash, a prosecutor intended to enter as evidence the reading taken in hospital.
     
    Last year, Kloegman found RCMP breached Fedan’s rights under a section of the charter because he was not read those rights when the first blood-alcohol reading was done.
     
    That meant Fedan’s admission to police that he was the driver and had been drinking are not admissible.
     
    Kloegman said Tuesday that the police demand for a blood sample at the hospital was also not accompanied by a charter warning.
     
    Court has heard that a junior RCMP constable with little experience was placed in charge of the investigation and the scene with two people dead.
     
    Const. Donna Gillingham has testified that she was a rookie officer who'd been on the job for a year and a half and may not have noted the smell of alcohol on Fedan's breath.
     
    Court heard Gillingham found an almost-empty bottle of whisky next to the pickup. The Crown alleges the bottle was inside the vehicle prior to the crash.
     
    Dr. Todd Ring testified Tuesday that Fedan was brought to Royal Inland Hospital in serious condition.
     
    Ring said he was concerned about possible brain injury and spinal fracture.
     
    Under those circumstances, Ring said, he would not allow police or a lawyer to speak with Fedan due to possible medical complications.
     
    The trauma team was focused on completing blood work and a CT scan to determine if Fedan had brain or other internal bleeding, he said.
     
    “If someone’s on the phone (talking to a lawyer), those steps can’t happen. It takes away from his medical care,” Ring said.
     
    Kloegman ruled medical staff at the hospital had Fedan’s medical needs, not his legal rights, in mind.
     
    A CT scan found Fedan had neck fractures and there was a danger he could break his spinal cord. Four days after the accident, he had neck surgery.
     
    Defence lawyer Anthony Varesi argued police had no right to take the second blood sample, based on the earlier breach of his rights.
     
    Varesi also noted that RCMP chatted with Fedan while at the hospital, but in the care of paramedics, before he was admitted.
     
    There was nothing preventing police from reading him his rights and allowing him to speak with a lawyer before the blood sample was taken, Varesi said. (Kamloops This Week)

    MORE National ARTICLES

    Ombudsmen to look at hassles faced by wounded vets headed to civvy street

    Ombudsmen to look at hassles faced by wounded vets headed to civvy street
    Two military watchdogs are opening a joint investigation into how ill and injured soldiers are treated during their transition to civilian life.

    Ombudsmen to look at hassles faced by wounded vets headed to civvy street

    PM Trudeau's Arctic policy sparked international friction: CIA report

    PM Trudeau's Arctic policy sparked international friction: CIA report
    Pierre Trudeau's bid to enhance Canadian sovereignty and promote economic development in the Arctic created some "friction" with the United States, says a declassified CIA report.

    PM Trudeau's Arctic policy sparked international friction: CIA report

    Metis say museum censoring culture by rejecting performer for opening ceremony

    Metis say museum censoring culture by rejecting performer for opening ceremony
    The Manitoba Metis Federation is accusing the Canadian Museum for Human Rights of censorship and is threatening to boycott the institution because it is excluding a decorated Metis musician from its grand opening.

    Metis say museum censoring culture by rejecting performer for opening ceremony

    Woman files civil suit against three Mounties and City of Williams Lake, B.C.

    Woman files civil suit against three Mounties and City of Williams Lake, B.C.
    A woman who alleges she was beaten by a Mountie in Williams Lake, B.C., when she was 17 has now filed a civil suit against the city and three RCMP officers, including one who was acquitted of an assault charge.

    Woman files civil suit against three Mounties and City of Williams Lake, B.C.

    Cooler weather helps snuff another campfire ban in B.C.'s backcountry

    Cooler weather helps snuff another campfire ban in B.C.'s backcountry
    Campers on the south coast of British Columbia will be able to spark up a campfire by the end of the week.  

    Cooler weather helps snuff another campfire ban in B.C.'s backcountry

    ICBC Seeks 5.2% Raise in Basic Insurance Rates

    ICBC Seeks 5.2% Raise in Basic Insurance Rates
    The Insurance Corporation of British Columbia is aiming to hike basic insurance rates by 5.2 per cent.

    ICBC Seeks 5.2% Raise in Basic Insurance Rates