Close X
Wednesday, January 15, 2025
ADVT 
National

Judge rapped for visiting dating website, chatting up sex assault detective

Darpan News Desk The Canadian Press, 16 Feb, 2015 11:38 AM

    TORONTO — A judge who created a bogus online dating profile and told a detective that information from the website could have been used to "hang" a female complainant has had his knuckles rapped by Ontario's top court.

    In ordering a new trial for a man acquitted of sexual assault, the Ontario Court of Appeal found Superior Court Justice Timothy Ray had violated basic legal principles.

    "The conduct of the trial judge while his decision was under reserve as well as his statements to the officer about that conduct were improper and created a reasonable apprehension of bias," the Appeal Court said.

    "(This) taints the verdicts of acquittal."

    The situation arose in December 2013, when the Ottawa judge retired to consider an appropriate sentence for a man he had just convicted of simple assault — but had acquitted of sexual assault.

    Documents show he sent a note to the lead detective, Erin Lehman, saying he wanted to see her in his chambers.

    On her arrival, Ray asked if she had gone on Match.com — the dating website on which the complainant and accused had met.

    According to court documents, Ray told the officer he had created a fake online profile the previous night before he delivered his verdict, pretending to be a gay man.

    "He then told me that if defence had done the same thing, she would have been able to 'hang' the victim with all of the information available,'' Lehman said in an affidavit.

    Lehman said Ray had asked the bailiff to summon her "discreetly." She also said Ray had suggested they have lunch or grab a coffee one day.

    Crown lawyer Vikki Bair wrote in an Appeal Court filing she was "shocked" by Lehman's account, calling the incident "very disturbing."

    Ray later declared a mistrial on the convictions, admitting to an "error in judgment." However, he insisted he had based his verdicts only on the evidence, and had gone online "out of curiosity," court documents show.

    "I was faced with a great number of very personal questions," the judge said. "I then logged out."

    Ray also said he was only trying to point out to Lehman that people using the website have to disclose information that could be useful to investigators or defence lawyers.

    Either way, the Appeal Court was not impressed.

    "He conducted his own research into a website that had been the subject of evidence at trial while his decision was under reserve — contrary to the basic principle that judges and jurors must make their judicial decisions based only on the evidence presented in court on the record," the Appeal Court said.

    The court also criticized Ray's views about using website information to "hang" the complainant as well as comments he made in his reasons for judgment. Among other things, he used "irrelevant stereotypes" to judge the complainant, the Appeal Court said in its decision released Friday.

    Those comments included his opinion that the complainant did not appear to be an abused or insecure woman.

    MORE National ARTICLES

    What Could Canada Do To Mute U.S. Opposition To Keystone? Nothing, Opponents Say

    What Could Canada Do To Mute U.S. Opposition To Keystone? Nothing, Opponents Say
    WASHINGTON — The American environmental organizations fighting the Keystone XL pipeline say there's no climate-change plan Canada could possibly adopt that would make them back down.

    What Could Canada Do To Mute U.S. Opposition To Keystone? Nothing, Opponents Say

    Bank CEOs Say Their Caribbean Operations Stand To Benefit From Cheaper Oil

    Bank CEOs Say Their Caribbean Operations Stand To Benefit From Cheaper Oil
    TORONTO — A combination of lower oil prices and cost-cutting is poised to help improve the Caribbean operations of some of Canada's biggest banks, a region where they have struggled for years.

    Bank CEOs Say Their Caribbean Operations Stand To Benefit From Cheaper Oil

    Harsh Weather, Heavy Winds Lead To Power Outages Across British Columbia

    Harsh Weather, Heavy Winds Lead To Power Outages Across British Columbia
    VANCOUVER — Harsh weather and strong winds knocked out power in thousands of homes across British Columbia on Sunday.

    Harsh Weather, Heavy Winds Lead To Power Outages Across British Columbia

    Canadian Tourist Under Arrest In Nepal On Child Sex Abuse Charges

    Canadian Tourist Under Arrest In Nepal On Child Sex Abuse Charges
    KATHMANDU, Nepal — A Canadian tourist has been arrested in Nepal on charges he lured a 9-year-old boy to his hotel room and had sex with him, a police official said Saturday.

    Canadian Tourist Under Arrest In Nepal On Child Sex Abuse Charges

    'Unprecedented' Crowding, Multiple Infections At Surrey Memorial Hospital

    'Unprecedented' Crowding, Multiple Infections At Surrey Memorial Hospital
    SURREY, B.C. — Surrey Memorial Hospital is experiencing one of its highest patient volumes ever, as well as multiple infections across the busy facility.

    'Unprecedented' Crowding, Multiple Infections At Surrey Memorial Hospital

    Alberta RCMP Say Suspect Wanted In Shooting Of Two Officers Is Dead

    Alberta RCMP Say Suspect Wanted In Shooting Of Two Officers Is Dead
    ST. ALBERT, Alta. — RCMP say the suspect wanted in the shooting of two officers at a casino just outside of Edmonton is dead.

    Alberta RCMP Say Suspect Wanted In Shooting Of Two Officers Is Dead