Close X
Sunday, December 15, 2024
ADVT 
National

Judge Nearly Declared Mistrial In Terror Case Over Crown's 'American' TV Closing

Darpan News Desk The Canadian Press, 01 Jun, 2015 07:16 PM
    VANCOUVER — The trial of a husband and wife accused of plotting to blow up the B.C. legislature came close to being declared a mistrial over the Crown's closing address, which the judge said was so inflammatory and inappropriate it took her breath away.
     
    With the jury out of earshot and before members began deliberating on the fate of John Nuttall and Amanda Korody on terror charges, B.C. Supreme Court Justice Catherine Bruce said she would have called a mistrial had the proceedings not been so protracted and difficult.
     
    The information can be released now that the judge has lifted a publication ban and the jury is sequestered.
     
    The couple is accused of planning to set off pressure-cooker bombs at the provincial legislature on behalf of a terrorist group during Canada Day festivities two years ago.
     
    In his closing submissions, Crown lawyer Peter Eccles played a 45-minute highlight reel for the jury of what the Crown considered the most important video and audio evidence shown throughout the four-month trial.
     
    The compilation closed with footage of an actual pressure-cooker explosion demolishing a surrounding ring of plywood boards in a controlled detonation staged and filmed by police.
     
    "That dramatic video production ... took my breath away with its impropriety," Bruce told Eccles.
     
    "I don't know how I can bring the jury from a state of inflammatory to a state of neutral after you have created this American-television view of this trial."
     
    Bruce said she marvelled at the Crown's decision to repeatedly refer to a defence that hadn't been raised by either Nuttall's or Korody's lawyers after she had specifically ordered Eccles to avoid the argument.
     
    Eccles included in his closing statement an explanation and counter-argument for the defences of duress and entrapment, neither of which were brought up during the trial.
     
    "(This) is unspeakable," said Bruce, about Eccles disobeying her instructions. "I've never experienced this before. Ever."
     
    Asked to respond to her concerns, Eccles argued that the defence's closing arguments left the  jury with the suggestion that the police manipulated the accused and enticed them to commit the offence, even though the words duress and entrapment were never explicitly used.
     
    "The jury are laypeople," Eccles said. "They know the same thing the press knows, who print day after day after day that ... (Nuttall and Korody) were manipulated and entrapped — that they were made to do it."
     
    Bruce said the defence had the right to bring up those points to answer the question of motive and that duress and entrapment were only brought up by Eccles.
     
    Despite considering declaring a mistrial, Bruce ultimately opted to carry forward, saying she would do her best to bring the jury back to neutrality by reminding them to consider the whole of the evidence and not pick out parts of it.
     
    After the jury had returned to the courtroom to hear her directions, Bruce warned them to be cautious when considering the Crown's "dramatic ending."
     
    "This trial is not a drama. It is a real-life situation in which the guilt or the innocence of these two people are in your hands," she said.
     
    "You must put aside the drama and focus on the evidence that you saw and you heard in this trial," Bruce told the jury.

    MORE National ARTICLES

    Police Discover Ontario Man Used Identity Of BC Boy Who Died In 1970s

    Police Discover Ontario Man Used Identity Of BC Boy Who Died In 1970s
    Police say a Caledonia, Ont., man who disappeared in 1992 took the name of a dead boy and lived under the assumed name until his death 10 years later.

    Police Discover Ontario Man Used Identity Of BC Boy Who Died In 1970s

    Supreme Court Orders New Trial For Alberta Men Who Made Sex Tapes Of 14-Year-Old Runaway Girls

    Supreme Court Orders New Trial For Alberta Men Who Made Sex Tapes Of 14-Year-Old Runaway Girls
    The Supreme Court of Canada has ordered a new trial in the case of two Edmonton men who made child pornography after videotaping two 14-year-old girls performing sex acts.

    Supreme Court Orders New Trial For Alberta Men Who Made Sex Tapes Of 14-Year-Old Runaway Girls

    Decades-Long Citizenship Battle Ends For Yukon Man Donovan McGlaughlin Who's Now Officially Canadian

    Decades-Long Citizenship Battle Ends For Yukon Man Donovan McGlaughlin Who's Now Officially Canadian
    The video showing Donovan McGlaughlin's Canadian citizenship ceremony in Dawson City, Yukon, is just two minutes and 11 seconds long but the elaborate script was decades in the making.

    Decades-Long Citizenship Battle Ends For Yukon Man Donovan McGlaughlin Who's Now Officially Canadian

    Shrinking Demand For Blood Products Behind Closure Of Blood Donor Clinics

    Shrinking Demand For Blood Products Behind Closure Of Blood Donor Clinics
    Ian Mumford, the agency's chief supply chain officer, says advances in medicine have prompted Canada's hospitals to reduce their demand for blood products.

    Shrinking Demand For Blood Products Behind Closure Of Blood Donor Clinics

    P.E.I. Man Signs Peace Bond Over Ricin Allegations Made By The RCMP

    P.E.I. Man Signs Peace Bond Over Ricin Allegations Made By The RCMP
    CHARLOTTETOWN — A man accused of having enough castor beans to produce a "substantial quantity" of the deadly toxin ricin signed a 12-month peace bond Friday in Charlottetown.

    P.E.I. Man Signs Peace Bond Over Ricin Allegations Made By The RCMP

    Wal-Mart Makes Public Guidelines To Suppliers On Animal Treatment, Use Of Antibiotics

    Wal-Mart Makes Public Guidelines To Suppliers On Animal Treatment, Use Of Antibiotics
    NEW YORK — Wal-Mart, the nation's largest food retailer, is urging its thousands of U.S. suppliers to curb the use of antibiotics in farm animals and improve treatment of them.

    Wal-Mart Makes Public Guidelines To Suppliers On Animal Treatment, Use Of Antibiotics