Close X
Wednesday, December 4, 2024
ADVT 
National

Jennifer Pawluck Instagram Harassment Case A Reminder To Show Caution With Online Posts: Experts

Darpan News Desk The Canadian Press, 26 Apr, 2015 01:20 AM
    MONTREAL — The guilty verdict against a woman who posted a photo of graffiti depicting a Montreal police officer with a bullet in his head should remind users of social media to be cautious about what they publish, experts said Friday.
     
    Jennifer Pawluck, 22, snapped a shot of someone else's graffiti work and uploaded it with anti-police hashtags to Instagram, a photo-sharing site.
     
    Cmdr. Ian Lafreniere, who was depicted in the graffiti, told Pawluck's criminal-harassment trial the image shook him and upset his wife and children.
     
    Experts echoed the judge's warning that online actions can have major consequences.
     
    "Just because it's on social media, it doesn't mean there aren't laws — criminal or civil — that wouldn't apply to that conduct," said Teresa Scassa, a law professor at the University of Ottawa.
     
    Pawluck's arrest in 2013 was criticized in some circles as unnecessary. Following Thursday's verdict, that feeling was rekindled as supporters called it outlandish and suppression of political dissent.
     
    Quebec court Judge Marie-Josee Di Lallo ruled Pawluck was guilty of harassment, that the Crown had demonstrated Lafreniere felt harassed and that it was reasonable for the senior police officer to feel his safety was threatened.
     
    Neither Pawluck nor her lawyer have said whether they'll appeal.
     
     
    Prof. Robert Currie, a law professor at the Schulich School of Law in Halifax, said the Criminal Code provides protection, to a point, for people who voice dissent.
     
    "The Criminal Code explicitly says it has to be a reasonable perception, not just 'someone said something vague and I felt threatened by it'," Currie said. "The judge found that not only had he (Lafreniere) subjectively felt that, but it was reasonable for him to feel that."
     
    Di Lallo noted that a single keystroke can have consequences and Currie agreed there's a level of carelessness about online activity as people tend to lose sight of propriety and the law.
     
    "I think there is a kind of psychological disconnect between the things people do online and their expectation of what the real world consequences will be," he said. "People are not careful enough."
     
    Scassa said another problem with social media is the brevity of the medium — photos and few characters leave little room to explain context and meaning. That leaves a lot of room for interpretation, in particular by a judge, she added.
     
    Constitutional rights lawyer Julius Grey, commenting in general terms, said restrictions of freedom of expression are becoming more prevalent.
     
    He believes youth should be careful about their online activities as the musings can have a long-lasting effect.
     
    "I think it is part of the education of every young person that they should be very careful about social media, stay off it, and not say controversial things," Grey said.
     
    "I'm not happy this is so, but it's certain, without even talking about the case itself, that anyone that goes on social media takes a risk."

    MORE National ARTICLES

    B.C. 'Hosed' In Port Coquitlam Land Sale To Liberal Donor

    B.C. 'Hosed' In Port Coquitlam Land Sale To Liberal Donor
    VICTORIA — The Opposition New Democrats say British Columbians were "hosed" in a Crown land sale that was snapped up by a Liberal donor at $43 million below the appraised value.

    B.C. 'Hosed' In Port Coquitlam Land Sale To Liberal Donor

    Indian P.M. Narendra Modi Arrives In Ottawa Today For Three-day Canadian Visit

    Indian P.M. Narendra Modi Arrives In Ottawa Today For Three-day Canadian Visit
    Modi's three-day trip is being billed by Prime Minister Stephen Harper's office as a chance to broaden trade involving education, energy and science and technology.

    Indian P.M. Narendra Modi Arrives In Ottawa Today For Three-day Canadian Visit

    Three Suspects In Custody Over Alleged Bank Fraud In B.C. And Alberta: RCMP

    Three Suspects In Custody Over Alleged Bank Fraud In B.C. And Alberta: RCMP
    VANCOUVER — RCMP say a woman and two men are in custody after several fraudulent bank transactions in B.C. and Alberta.

    Three Suspects In Custody Over Alleged Bank Fraud In B.C. And Alberta: RCMP

    Oil Spill 90 Per Cent Cleared But Slick Reaches Beaches North Of City: Officials

    Oil Spill 90 Per Cent Cleared But Slick Reaches Beaches North Of City: Officials
    VANCOUVER — The federal coast guard is defending its response to an oil spill in Vancouver's harbour amid questions about how the slick washed up on beaches to the north.

    Oil Spill 90 Per Cent Cleared But Slick Reaches Beaches North Of City: Officials

    Veterans Mount 11,000-Kilometre Horse Ride Across Canada To Create Awareness

    Veterans Mount 11,000-Kilometre Horse Ride Across Canada To Create Awareness
    VICTORIA — Canadian Forces veterans saddled up for an epic cross-country trail ride that aims to include Canadians in the fight against post-traumatic stress, suicide and family strife within the military.

    Veterans Mount 11,000-Kilometre Horse Ride Across Canada To Create Awareness

    B.C. treaty process too slow, but what's next for governments, First Nations?

    B.C. treaty process too slow, but what's next for governments, First Nations?
    VICTORIA — There is easy agreement between First Nations and the British Columbia and federal governments that treaty negotiations are languishing, expensive and fraught with obstacles, but all sides have completely different views on how to solve the trouble.

    B.C. treaty process too slow, but what's next for governments, First Nations?