Close X
Monday, November 11, 2024
ADVT 
National

James Moore Vows To Tackle Canada-U.S. Price Gap With Bill

The Canadian Press, 09 Dec, 2014 01:25 PM
  • James Moore Vows To Tackle Canada-U.S. Price Gap With Bill
TORONTO - Companies would be forced to justify why their prices are higher in Canada than in the United States or face naming and shaming under federal legislation introduced Tuesday — a move some critics called misguided.
 
Industry Minister James Moore said the aim is to protect Canadian consumers, not regulate prices.
 
"This unexplained difference in price between American and Canadian prices for the exact same product is frustrating," Moore said at a toy store.
 
"It's called geographic price discrimination. A more blunt way of putting it is to call it price gouging of consumers."
 
Under the Price Transparency Act, Canada's Competition Bureau would have the power to compel companies to explain their strategies and how they come by their Canadian prices.
 
The bureau would then publicize its findings but could not impose sanctions unless anti-competitive practices were uncovered.
 
Numerous studies have shown prices in Canada to be between 10 and 25 per cent higher on average than in the U.S.
 
Moore himself rhymed off a list of articles — shampoo, a television, running shoes — he said cost as much as double this side of the border.
 
Last year, a Senate committee cited "country pricing" by manufacturers as one reason for the difference, while a study by the American Economic Review journal also blamed distributors and wholesalers.
 
Experts often cite a complex set of volatile variables for Canada-U.S. price differences, including the exchange rate, transportation costs, tariffs, and different regulations.
 
"Those factors do explain some of the price differences but it's certainly not the only story," Moore said.
 
In 2009, the Conservative government scrapped price discrimination as a longstanding but rarely enforced criminal offence with punishment of up to two years.
 
Moore said the potential for public fallout should result in companies cutting unfair prices.
 
Finn Poschmann, vice-president with the C.D. Howe Institute, said the legislation will do nothing to bring Canadian prices down.
 
"It would be odd if businesses charge anything other than what consumers are willing to pay," Poschmann said.
 
"(The bill) is a misguided direction of government resources that can only prove costly to businesses and costly to consumers to little good end."
 
Competition Commissioner John Pecman said in an interview the bureau, which will receive no extra funding, will now start developing forensic pricing expertise.
 
He said the bureau would take consumer complaints but intended to be proactive in identifying and publicly naming price gougers.
 
"Hopefully, the parties involved will voluntarily decide to change their conduct," Pecman said.
 
The price gap has been particularly hard on smaller retailers who have lost sales to cross-border shopping.
 
As a result, the 45,000-member Retail Council of Canada said it supports the legislation.
 
"For the consumer it's simple," said council CEO Diane Brisebois. "They want transparency on why prices are higher in Canada."
 
George Addy, a lawyer with competition expertise, said cross-border pricing is a highly complex issue dependent on "almost an infinite number of factors."
 
It remains to be seen what would happen if price gouging was publicly identified but it would likely fall to consumers to take action, perhaps via social media, to shame offenders, Addy said.
 
Prentice puts a number on cost of low oil prices

MORE National ARTICLES

B.C. Premier Clark says Petronas LNG project still has hurdles to overcome

B.C. Premier Clark says Petronas LNG project still has hurdles to overcome
TORONTO — British Columbia's premier said Monday the province's multibillion-dollar agreement with Petronas to build a liquefied natural gas terminal is "done," while acknowledging the Malaysian energy giant still has hurdles to overcome before the project can go ahead.

B.C. Premier Clark says Petronas LNG project still has hurdles to overcome

Obama 'Colbert' show appearance won't have Canada's oilpatch laughing

Obama 'Colbert' show appearance won't have Canada's oilpatch laughing
WASHINGTON — In the Monday night episode of "The Colbert Report," the joke was on Canada's oil industry.

Obama 'Colbert' show appearance won't have Canada's oilpatch laughing

Prince George Mountie Stabbed During Arrest, IIO Investigating: RCMP

Prince George Mountie Stabbed During Arrest, IIO Investigating: RCMP
RCMP say two officers stopped three people on foot at about 11 p.m. Monday, and found one man had several outstanding warrants for his arrest.

Prince George Mountie Stabbed During Arrest, IIO Investigating: RCMP

Vancouver-born actress-dancer Stephanie Moseley found dead in Los Angeles

Vancouver-born actress-dancer Stephanie Moseley found dead in Los Angeles
TORONTO — A Canadian star of the VH1 drama series "Hit the Floor" about NBA cheerleaders has died in what Los Angeles police say was an apparent murder-suicide.

Vancouver-born actress-dancer Stephanie Moseley found dead in Los Angeles

Windy Weather Cancelled Over Two Dozen Morning Sailings: BC Ferries

Windy Weather Cancelled Over Two Dozen Morning Sailings: BC Ferries
VICTORIA — BC Ferries says it has cancelled more than two dozen sailings on seven different routes because of adverse weather.

Windy Weather Cancelled Over Two Dozen Morning Sailings: BC Ferries

Competition bureau to get new powers to probe Canada-US price gap: Moore

Competition bureau to get new powers to probe Canada-US price gap: Moore
TORONTO — Canada's competition bureau is getting new powers to investigate why many items cost less in the United States.

Competition bureau to get new powers to probe Canada-US price gap: Moore