Close X
Saturday, November 16, 2024
ADVT 
National

Ivan Henry's Wrongful-imprisonment Trial Wraps, Judge Says He'll Mull Decision

The Canadian Press, 18 Dec, 2015 12:53 PM
    VANCOUVER — The compensation trial of a British Columbia man wrongfully imprisoned for 27 years is over, with Ivan Henry's lawyers saying he deserves millions and provincial counsel insisting he sealed his own fate by representing himself.
     
    B.C. Supreme Court Justice Christopher Hinkson reserved his decision Thursday on whether Henry should receive up to $43 million for his time behind bars.
     
    Henry, 69, is suing the province after he was acquitted in 2010 of 10 sexual-assault convictions. The federal government and the City of Vancouver settled with Henry earlier this year for undisclosed amounts.
     
    Crown lawyer John Hunter said the case boils down to Henry's ill-informed decision to represent himself in court in 1982 and that awarding him millions of dollars in damages would send the wrong message.
     
    "It should not be the case that if you decide to self-represent and things go badly that you're going to get a chance years later to have an autopsy of the whole case ... and at the end of the day there could be a big payday for you."
     
    Henry should bear some responsibility for his conviction after he repeatedly refused legal counsel during his sexual-assault trial, Hunter said.
     
    "The message that should go out is that, 'Yes, we'll all try to make sure the trial is fair. But you need a lawyer. You need a lawyer if you're charged with a serious criminal offence.'" 
     
    Henry fired three of his lawyers and refused two more made available to him through legal aid during his original trial and sentencing hearing, insisting that he would speak on his own behalf.
     
    Provincial prosecutors shouldn't be liable for mistakes made by Vancouver police even if they were aware of officer misconduct, he said during closing arguments Thursday.
     
     
    Henry isn't entitled to damages from the province for police errors because he's already settled with the City of Vancouver and, by extension, the police department, Hunter said.
     
    "If we (the province) are being criticized for not disclosing something that the police did or didn't do, we're being criticized in respect of acts attributable to police, and the plaintiff has waived damages with respect to acts attributable to police," Hunter told court.
     
    "But whatever the police did or didn't do the Crown knew about it," countered Justice Hinkson.
     
    "The fact that the Crown may or may not have known about it is beside the point, because of the waiver," Hunter replied.
     
    Henry's acquittal focused on potentially useful evidence Crown or police withheld, including sperm samples that didn't match Henry's blood type, contradictory victim statements and a compromising letter sent from a victim to an investigating officer.
     
    The Crown argued Henry's decision to rebuff legal counsel means he wouldn't have known what to do with the additional evidence even if it had been provided to him, despite his repeated requests.
     
    Henry's lawyer John Laxton skewered that assertion.
     
    "At its lowest level this amounts to saying: "It doesn't matter that we refused to disclose information, he's too dumb and stupid to have been able to do anything about it," Laxton said.
     
    "This is a very sad comment on our judicial system."

    MORE National ARTICLES

    Military Investigative Unit Joins In Search For Missing Nova Scotia Sailor Benoit Bilodeau

    Military Investigative Unit Joins In Search For Missing Nova Scotia Sailor Benoit Bilodeau
    Leading seaman Benoit Bilodeau, 48, was last seen walking near a bus stop in front of 12 Wing Shearwater on Nov. 21.

    Military Investigative Unit Joins In Search For Missing Nova Scotia Sailor Benoit Bilodeau

    $34.88 Billion In Profits And Other Key Numbers For Canada's Big Banks

    $34.88 Billion In Profits And Other Key Numbers For Canada's Big Banks
    Despite concerns that the sluggish economy, tapped out borrowers and low interest rates could dampen the profitability of Canadian banks

    $34.88 Billion In Profits And Other Key Numbers For Canada's Big Banks

    Manitoba Children's Advocate Will Have New Power To Monitor Kids

    Manitoba Children's Advocate Will Have New Power To Monitor Kids
    WINNIPEG — The Manitoba government is following through on a promise to give the children's advocate more power.

    Manitoba Children's Advocate Will Have New Power To Monitor Kids

    Rising Estimated Costs For 15 Canadian Warships No Surprise: Naval Expert

    Rising Estimated Costs For 15 Canadian Warships No Surprise: Naval Expert
    Ken Hansen, a research fellow with the Centre for Foreign Policy Studies at Halifax's Dalhousie University, is responding to a media report on the price tag.

    Rising Estimated Costs For 15 Canadian Warships No Surprise: Naval Expert

    New Certified Guide-dog Rules Protect Rights Of Handlers: B.C. Government

    New Certified Guide-dog Rules Protect Rights Of Handlers: B.C. Government
    British Columbia has introduced new rules to increase fines for restaurants, transit and other businesses that violate the rights of people who use certified guide-dogs.

    New Certified Guide-dog Rules Protect Rights Of Handlers: B.C. Government

    B.C. Oyster Growers Take Steps To Shuck Problems With Shellfish Bacterium

    The two groups are organizing a workshop to help oyster farmers develop strategies to reduce chances of a dangerous bacterium in the shellfish.

    B.C. Oyster Growers Take Steps To Shuck Problems With Shellfish Bacterium