Close X
Friday, November 29, 2024
ADVT 
National

Insurer Must Pay $237,000 In Legal Costs To Elderly Woman Awarded $20,000

The Canadian Press, 31 Jan, 2018 11:51 AM
    TORONTO — An insurance company that played litigation hardball with an elderly car-accident victim has been ordered to pay $237,000 to cover the legal costs she incurred in winning a $20,000 settlement.
     
     
    In her decision, Ontario Superior Court Justice Mary Sanderson said it would be contrary to public policy to reward the insurance company's uncompromising behaviour by assessing minimal costs against it.
     
     
    "Insurers can, of course, pursue whatever strategy options they deem fit," Sanderson wrote. "But especially where such strategies may have wide ranging and adverse implications involving widespread denial of access to justice, the use of such strategies should not be encouraged by the giving of cost breaks on foreseeable costs consequences."
     
     
    The case arose in February 2009, when the car Maria Persampieri, 84, was in was rear-ended. Persampieri initially sued for $1 million.
     
     
    In response, the defendants' insurance company, Aviva Canada, said it would never pay her any damages. According to court records, Aviva said through its lawyers it would not offer a single loonie to settle. The company said it did not believe Persampieri had suffered any significant injuries and would fight her tooth and nail.
     
     
    The only acceptable outcome was a zero dollar settlement, Aviva maintained. If Persampieri agreed to take no money, Aviva said it would not pursue legal costs against her. She refused.
     
     
    However, following pretrial talks and mediation, Persampieri offered in March 2017 to settle for damages of $20,000, plus legal fees. Two months later, and just two weeks before trial, Persampieri said she would accept just $10,000.
     
     
    "The parties all understood that to possibly succeed at trial, plaintiff's counsel would need to call sufficient medical and other evidence to convince a jury that her injuries had been caused by the accident, that they were real, to prove the quantum of her damages and to satisfy this court that the threshold had been met," Sanderson wrote.
     
     
    Aviva opted for a trial that was held in May and June last year at which the company mounted a "vigorous defence," Sanderson noted. In turn, Persampieri's lawyer called extensive medical and other evidence.
     
     
    The jury came back and awarded her a total of $67,500 in general damages and for housekeeping, medical and other costs. Following various deductibles mandated by law, Persampieri was left with a net total award of $20,414.83 — more than the $10,000 she had agreed to accept before trial, documents show.
     
     
    In arguing for substantial legal costs — $268,000 — Persampieri's lawyer argued Aviva was fully entitled to adopt its take-no-prisoners approach, but would have "appreciated the obvious risks of so doing." Aviva countered that the demand was unreasonable and should be proportional to what Persampieri was actually awarded at trial.
     
     
    "The costs she is seeking are all out of proportion to the amount recovered and for that reason should be reduced," Aviva maintained.
     
     
    Sanderson rejected Aviva's argument.
     
     
    "For this court to let proportionality be the overriding, or even the predominant factor, would be grossly unfair to (Persampieri) and would be to reward the uncompromising, and — in the light of the jury verdict — unreasonable behaviour of the insurer," Sanderson said.
     
     
    Aviva had made it clear from the outset it would never pay Persampieri anything and the decision would not change, the judge noted, a position that she found would "render meaningless and make a mockery of" the pretrial resolution process.
     
     
    Aviva took one last kick at the can, arguing that Persampieri should have pursued her case in small claims court given the $20,000 she was awarded — which would have been far cheaper legally speaking. Sanderson rejected that argument, too, saying that approach would not have been practical.
     
     
    After sifting through all the legal bills, she ordered Aviva to pay Persampieri a total of $237,017.50.

    MORE National ARTICLES

    Former Hostage Joshua Boyle Awaits Bail Hearing

    Former Hostage Joshua Boyle Awaits Bail Hearing
    OTTAWA — A bail hearing for former Afghanistan hostage Joshua Boyle could be weeks away after a brief court appearance by video link today relating to assault charges.

    Former Hostage Joshua Boyle Awaits Bail Hearing

    Chronic Pain Patients Need Services Beyond Just Opioids: B.C. Advocate

    Chronic Pain Patients Need Services Beyond Just Opioids: B.C. Advocate
    People who live with chronic pain need options beyond prescription opioids, and it's up to the British Columbia government to provide more services such as physiotherapy, says the head of a group that supports patients and their families.

    Chronic Pain Patients Need Services Beyond Just Opioids: B.C. Advocate

    Crown Wants Convictions For B.C. Pair Earlier Accused Of Terror-Related Crimes

    Crown Wants Convictions For B.C. Pair Earlier Accused Of Terror-Related Crimes
    VANCOUVER — A British Columbia judge was wrong to throw out findings of guilt against a pair of accused terrorist sympathizers who planted what they thought were pressure-cooker bombs on the lawn of the provincial legislature, the Crown says.

    Crown Wants Convictions For B.C. Pair Earlier Accused Of Terror-Related Crimes

    Price Of Average Canadian Home Rose To $496,500 In December, Up 5.7% In 2017

    Price Of Average Canadian Home Rose To $496,500 In December, Up 5.7% In 2017
    Prices Cooling Off, But Pace Of Sales Is Increasing, Canadian Real Estate Association Says

    Price Of Average Canadian Home Rose To $496,500 In December, Up 5.7% In 2017

    Some Canadian Media Organizations Ready To Cope With Facebook's Changes To Feeds

    Some Canadian Media Organizations Ready To Cope With Facebook's Changes To Feeds
    Some members of Canada's media industry say they expect to be able to weather the potential setback created by the latest change to Facebook's content sharing priorities.

    Some Canadian Media Organizations Ready To Cope With Facebook's Changes To Feeds

    First-Degree Murder Charges Against 3 Men After Alberta Man Found Dead In B.C.

    First-Degree Murder Charges Against 3 Men After Alberta Man Found Dead In B.C.
    The Integrated Homicide Investigation Team says 20-year-old Michael Bonin's body was found on a rural forest service road north of Hope on April 20, 2017.

    First-Degree Murder Charges Against 3 Men After Alberta Man Found Dead In B.C.