Close X
Friday, November 15, 2024
ADVT 
National

ID Of Doctors Who Might Help Terminally Ill Ontario Man Die To Stay Secret

The Canadian Press, 07 Mar, 2016 12:24 PM
    TORONTO — The identities of any doctors who might help a terminally ill man kill himself can be kept secret, an Ontario court ruled Monday.
     
    In agreeing to the man's request for anonymity, Superior Court Justice Thomas McEwen said confidentiality orders in this case were needed to avoid unwanted publicity and media attention for the man, his family and the doctors involved.
     
    The man, 80, identified only as A.B., will be seeking a constitutional exemption later this month for a doctor-assisted suicide in the first such request in Ontario.
     
    A.B. and his family did not ask for the hearing itself to be held in secret. They only wanted anonymity for themselves and the doctors.
     
    "Cases involving physician-assisted suicide warrant such restrictions," McEwen said in his written ruling. "The (man's) proposal is a reasonable compromise."
     
    At a hearing last week, a group of news outlets agreed the identities of the man and his relatives should remain private but opposed secrecy for the doctors who help him die.
     
    McEwen said the man's position struck a balance between the open-court principle and the right of the man and his family to maintain their privacy and dignity.
     
    There are also good reasons to black out the names of the physicians as well, the justice said.
     
     
    "The physicians wish to maintain anonymity because of personal and professional implications," McEwen said. "Their wish and concerns are entirely reasonable, in my opinion, given the publicity and controversy surrounding physician-assisted death."
     
    McEwen said adverse publicity might dissuade doctors from helping others. He also said he was not concerned doctors might become "rubber-stamps" for assisted deaths given the role the courts must still play in approving requests for such help.
     
    The decision calls for an unredacted court record — along with explanations as to why any information was blacked out — to be put to the judge hearing the case. It will be up to that judge to make any changes. Media will also be able to make submissions at that time if they want.
     
    According to his affidavit, the man was diagnosed with advanced aggressive lymphoma in 2012, a terminal condition that has left him in 'intolerable pain and distress that cannot be alleviated."
     
    He argued he could only "die with dignity" away from a blaze of unwanted publicity. He and his family also worried about unwanted harassment from those opposed to assisted suicide.
     
    Last year, the Supreme Court of Canada struck down laws that made it a criminal offence for doctors to help someone die.
     
     
    The court gave the government a year to rewrite the laws. However, unable to meet the deadline, the government asked the court for an extension. The courts granted another four months, but said the terminally ill could apply to superior courts for an exemption to the ban during that period.

    MORE National ARTICLES

    Growth In Canadian Oil Production Could Come To 'Complete Standstill,' Says Report

    Growth In Canadian Oil Production Could Come To 'Complete Standstill,' Says Report
    Since mid-2014, crude prices have plunged by 70 per cent. On Monday, oil was trading above US$33 a barrel.

    Growth In Canadian Oil Production Could Come To 'Complete Standstill,' Says Report

    13 People Involved In Avalanche Near Area Where Fatal Slide Happened Saturday

    Pamela Gole with the BC Ambulance Service says 13 people were involved in an avalanche on Sunday in the Chatter Creek area northwest of Golden.

    13 People Involved In Avalanche Near Area Where Fatal Slide Happened Saturday

    Winnipeg Police Believe Body In Bin Is 17-Year-Old Cooper Nemeth Missing Since Hockey Party

    Winnipeg Police Believe Body In Bin Is 17-Year-Old Cooper Nemeth Missing Since Hockey Party
    Police in Winnipeg say they believe the body of a missing Winnipeg teen has been found in a bin not far from where he was last seen, an a man now faces a murder charge.

    Winnipeg Police Believe Body In Bin Is 17-Year-Old Cooper Nemeth Missing Since Hockey Party

    RCMP Association Calls For Overhaul After Latest Sexual Harassment Allegations

    RCMP Association Calls For Overhaul After Latest Sexual Harassment Allegations
    A group vying to become the Mounties' first bargaining unit is using new allegations of sex harassment and bullying to try to make its case for a group to represent rank and file officers.

    RCMP Association Calls For Overhaul After Latest Sexual Harassment Allegations

    Ontario Teacher Charges With 36 Sex Crimes, Making Pornography Involving Youths Aged 12 To 15

    Ontario Teacher Charges With 36 Sex Crimes, Making Pornography Involving Youths Aged 12 To 15
    Police say Jaclyn McLaren, 36, also known as Jaclyn Jones, was initially charged on Monday in connection with allegations involving young people between the ages of 12 and 15

    Ontario Teacher Charges With 36 Sex Crimes, Making Pornography Involving Youths Aged 12 To 15

    Online Puppy Scam Won't Lead To Happy Tales, Warns Better Business Bureau

    Online Puppy Scam Won't Lead To Happy Tales, Warns Better Business Bureau
    The British Columbia Better Business Bureau is warning people about an online puppy scam that is anything but cute and cuddly.

    Online Puppy Scam Won't Lead To Happy Tales, Warns Better Business Bureau