Close X
Wednesday, November 27, 2024
ADVT 
National

High court won't hear private health challenge

Darpan News Desk The Canadian Press, 06 Apr, 2023 04:38 PM
  • High court won't hear private health challenge

VANCOUVER - The doctor who led a legal challenge over a patient’s right to pay for private medical care says a decision by Canada's top court not to hear an appeal means long wait times have been "forcibly embedded" into the medicare system.

Dr. Brian Day is CEO of the Cambie Surgery Centre, which, along with a handful of patients, has spent more than a decade in court challenging the British Columbia Medicare Protection Act, which bans extra-billing and private insurance for medically necessary procedures.

They argued long wait times in B.C.'s publicly funded system amounted to a breach of the patients' rights to life, liberty and security of the person under the Charter of Rights and Freedoms.

Others applauded the decision, with an advocacy group involved in the case saying it was relieved fundamental principles about access to health care regardless of someone's ability to pay had been protected.

The Supreme Court of B.C. dismissed the constitutional challenge three years ago and the provincial Court of Appeal upheld the ruling last year. On Thursday, the Supreme Court of Canada said it would not hear an appeal.

Day said in a statement that Canada needed to bring its system in line with other better-performing publicly funded systems in the world with complementary health care available through legal private insurance.

"As a result of the Supreme Court’s failure to even consider the rights of Canadians suffering on wait lists, Canadians, such as the patient plaintiffs in our case who suffered such outcomes as permanent paralysis and death as they waited for care and justice, are being denied access to both," he said.

"It’s now clear to all that medically unacceptable wait times have become forcibly embedded and represent government policy in the publicly funded medicare system. The courts have endorsed this approach."

Katie Arnup, executive director of Canadian Doctors for Medicare, said she was relieved the court fights had come to an end.

She said what Day and others sought was "striking at the heart of the foundations of publicly funded health care in Canada," particularly regarding access to care based on need, and not the ability to pay.

"From the very beginning, it was important to us to defend that principle. And I think that … at the end of the day that's what's won out."

Justice John Steeves said in the original B.C. Supreme Court ruling that while long waits for care might increase the risk to some patients, the provisions were justified by the overall objective of supporting a system where access to health care is based on need.

The Supreme Court of Canada does not release reasons why it chooses not to hear cases. In 2022, only seven per cent of cases that applied for an appeal were granted one.

Canadian Doctors for Medicare was an intervener in both previous court challenges.

Arnup said this was not the end of the fight to improve the health-care system.

"It just means that this one legal battle is over and we can get back to focusing on innovations within the public system that will improve access to care for everyone," she said.

B.C. Health Minister Adrian Dix said at an unrelated press conference Thursday that the decision by the Supreme Court of Canada puts an end to the matter.

"I just want to say it is an exceptional victory for public health care in B.C., for the people of B.C., for the Medicare Protection Act, for our public health-care system," he said.

"It supports public health care, and has us do what we need to do, which to provide continually better service under the public health-care system. And that's exactly what we're going to do."

In an earlier statement, Dix said the province is moving to cut wait times, despite the upheavals caused by the COVID-19 pandemic, and 99 per cent of patients whose services were postponed during the pandemic have since had their procedures.

The statement said B.C. now ranks "first nationally for the percentage of patients meeting clinical benchmarks for cataract surgeries and second for both hip and knee replacements."

MORE National ARTICLES

Strike halts bus service in B.C.'s Fraser Valley

Strike halts bus service in B.C.'s Fraser Valley
The union says its members, who work for a company that contracts service to BC Transit, have no pension and make 32 per cent less than bus drivers and other staff elsewhere in Metro Vancouver's transit system.

Strike halts bus service in B.C.'s Fraser Valley

Class-action lawsuit launched against game maker

Class-action lawsuit launched against game maker
The statement says Fortnite creator Epic Games enriches itself by making content and customization options purchasable via an in-game currency, which are purchased with real cash. The class-action lawsuit would still need approval from the court and none of the allegations have been proven in court.

Class-action lawsuit launched against game maker

New Westminster Police officers appeal for witnesses to come forward following stabbing

New Westminster Police officers appeal for witnesses to come forward following stabbing
Officers searched the area but were unable to locate any suspects. Officers have been actively interviewing witnesses and canvassing the area for CCTV footage. Due to the serious nature of the injuries the Major Crime Unit has assumed conduct of the investigation. At this time, officers believe this to be an isolated incident.

New Westminster Police officers appeal for witnesses to come forward following stabbing

Turban ripped, Sikh student dragged by hair in Canada: Report

Turban ripped, Sikh student dragged by hair in Canada: Report
Gagandeep Singh, 21, was swarmed and beaten near Highway 97 and McCurdy Road in Kelowna after he got off a transit bus on March 17, CTV News reported. Gagandeep was heading home after grocery shopping when he encountered a group of young boys, between 12 and 15 years-old on the bus.

Turban ripped, Sikh student dragged by hair in Canada: Report

One-click citizenship oath temporary: Fraser

One-click citizenship oath temporary: Fraser
The immigration minister anticipates the one-click option would only be in effect as long as the government is swamped with backlogged citizenship applications. But the Conservative party's immigration critic worries it would "cheapen" an otherwise special moment for newcomers.

One-click citizenship oath temporary: Fraser

Man who stormed PM residence loses sentence appeal

Man who stormed PM residence loses sentence appeal
A decision dated Thursday says the six-year sentence handed to Corey Hurren in March 2021, less a year for the time he spent in custody before his sentencing, was "entirely fit." Hurren, a sausage-maker who served with the military's Canadian Rangers, had pleaded guilty to seven weapons charges and one mischief charge for his actions on the morning of July 2, 2020.

Man who stormed PM residence loses sentence appeal