Close X
Thursday, December 26, 2024
ADVT 
National

High court upholds B.C. man's voyeurism conviction

Darpan News Desk The Canadian Press, 10 Mar, 2023 11:38 AM
  • High court upholds B.C. man's voyeurism conviction

OTTAWA - The Supreme Court of Canada has overturned a British Columbia court ruling and restored two voyeurism convictions against a former Metro Vancouver minor hockey coach.

Randy Downes had coached minor hockey and children's baseball in Burnaby and Coquitlam for 30 years when he was charged in 2016 after border agents found images on his phone as he returned to Canada from Washington state.

All the images involved youths who were clothed and none were deemed pornographic, but Downes was convicted of two counts of voyeurism in 2019 for separate events where surreptitious cellphone photos were taken of two youths in their underwear in hockey changing rooms.

He was 62-years old when he was handed a suspended sentence in 2020 and placed on six months of probation.

The B.C. Court of Appeal rejected the lower court ruling in a split decision last year, finding that a conviction of voyeurism requires the subject of the photo to be in a place where it "can reasonably be expected" nudity will occur at the time the photo is taken.

In the unanimous Supreme Court of Canada decision, Justice Mahmud Jamal says the Criminal Code section used to convict Downes does not include a "temporal component," so the Crown did not need to prove the photos were taken in a place where nudity is reasonably expected at that time.

Downes violated a law that protects the sexual integrity of persons in specific places, writes Jamal.

"It does not require the person to be actually nude, exposing intimate parts of his or her body, or engaged in sexual activity; it suffices if they are in a place where a person may reasonably be expected to be in such a state, such as a changing room, toilet, shower stall, or bedroom," he writes.

Observation or recording in such "safe places" violates trust, says Jamal, noting that the result can be "emotional and psychological harm, even if the person is not observed or recorded when nude."

Lawyers for Downes also challenged the constitutionality of the voyeurism laws during the case in the B.C. Court of Appeal, but Jamal says questions about the law being "unconstitutionally overbroad" were not addressed by B.C.'s highest court.

The same questions were raised during the appeal to the Supreme Court of Canada, but Jamal declined to rule on them, writing that the issue "has not been properly raised in the courts below" and would "require the Court to address an important Charter issue in a factual vacuum."

MORE National ARTICLES

Darpan 10 with Premier David Eby

Darpan 10 with Premier David Eby
I did not always want this job. But I am glad to be doing it now. As for challenges, politics is about finding the right balance. Our government is working hard to create affordable housing, to protect healthcare, to foster safer streets by addressing the root causes of crime and poverty.

Darpan 10 with Premier David Eby

Delta man charged in last year's Coquitlam homicide

Delta man charged in last year's Coquitlam homicide
On arrival, first responders found a 66-year old man suffering from stab wounds. The victim, later identified as Terry Miller, was taken to hospital with life-threatening injuries. On January 27, 2023, IHIT investigators arrested 24-year old Chalice Slavik of Delta, in relation to the homicide of Miller.

Delta man charged in last year's Coquitlam homicide

Every toxic chemical doesn't need pollution plan

Every toxic chemical doesn't need pollution plan
Liberals and Conservatives on the House of Commons environment committee voted down May's proposed amendment this morning. The Canadian Environmental Law Association says only one-sixth of the chemicals designated as toxic under the act have a pollution prevention plan.

Every toxic chemical doesn't need pollution plan

Nicole Chan feared she'd lose job: VPD sergeant

Nicole Chan feared she'd lose job: VPD sergeant
A civil lawsuit filed on behalf of Chan's family last year claims she died by suicide in January 2019 during a severe mental health crisis after being "extorted" by Sgt. David Van Patten to continue their sexual relationship.

Nicole Chan feared she'd lose job: VPD sergeant

Drug decriminalization data to be made public

Drug decriminalization data to be made public
Over 11,000 people have fatally overdosed in the province from toxic street drugs since it was declared a public health emergency in 2016. The new policy means people who carry drugs up to the permitted threshold for their own use will no longer be arrested or charged, and their illegal substances will no longer be seized.

Drug decriminalization data to be made public

NDP want emergency debate on private health care

NDP want emergency debate on private health care
It’s a top priority for the leader as members of Parliament return to the House Monday following a holiday break. Singh spent some of that time away holding round table discussions on health care in British Columbia to discuss emergency room overcrowding and worker shortages.

NDP want emergency debate on private health care