Close X
Wednesday, December 25, 2024
ADVT 
National

High court upholds B.C. man's voyeurism conviction

Darpan News Desk The Canadian Press, 10 Mar, 2023 11:38 AM
  • High court upholds B.C. man's voyeurism conviction

OTTAWA - The Supreme Court of Canada has overturned a British Columbia court ruling and restored two voyeurism convictions against a former Metro Vancouver minor hockey coach.

Randy Downes had coached minor hockey and children's baseball in Burnaby and Coquitlam for 30 years when he was charged in 2016 after border agents found images on his phone as he returned to Canada from Washington state.

All the images involved youths who were clothed and none were deemed pornographic, but Downes was convicted of two counts of voyeurism in 2019 for separate events where surreptitious cellphone photos were taken of two youths in their underwear in hockey changing rooms.

He was 62-years old when he was handed a suspended sentence in 2020 and placed on six months of probation.

The B.C. Court of Appeal rejected the lower court ruling in a split decision last year, finding that a conviction of voyeurism requires the subject of the photo to be in a place where it "can reasonably be expected" nudity will occur at the time the photo is taken.

In the unanimous Supreme Court of Canada decision, Justice Mahmud Jamal says the Criminal Code section used to convict Downes does not include a "temporal component," so the Crown did not need to prove the photos were taken in a place where nudity is reasonably expected at that time.

Downes violated a law that protects the sexual integrity of persons in specific places, writes Jamal.

"It does not require the person to be actually nude, exposing intimate parts of his or her body, or engaged in sexual activity; it suffices if they are in a place where a person may reasonably be expected to be in such a state, such as a changing room, toilet, shower stall, or bedroom," he writes.

Observation or recording in such "safe places" violates trust, says Jamal, noting that the result can be "emotional and psychological harm, even if the person is not observed or recorded when nude."

Lawyers for Downes also challenged the constitutionality of the voyeurism laws during the case in the B.C. Court of Appeal, but Jamal says questions about the law being "unconstitutionally overbroad" were not addressed by B.C.'s highest court.

The same questions were raised during the appeal to the Supreme Court of Canada, but Jamal declined to rule on them, writing that the issue "has not been properly raised in the courts below" and would "require the Court to address an important Charter issue in a factual vacuum."

MORE National ARTICLES

Tom Clark to be Canada's envoy in New York City

Tom Clark to be Canada's envoy in New York City
Clark will be Canada's consul general in New York, putting him in charge of Ottawa's efforts to sow cultural and economic ties in the Big Apple, as well as in neighboring American states and in Bermuda.

Tom Clark to be Canada's envoy in New York City

Test requirement extended for travel from China

Test requirement extended for travel from China
The government says it's concerned about reports of a dramatic increase in COVID-19 cases in China, and the lack of data available from China about potential variants that could be spreading through the country.

Test requirement extended for travel from China

Jan. home sales down 55% from year earlier: REBGV

Jan. home sales down 55% from year earlier: REBGV
The board says sales for the month totalled 1,022, a 55 per cent drop from the prior January. The number of homes that changed hands last month was also 42.9 per cent below the 10-year January sales average.    

Jan. home sales down 55% from year earlier: REBGV

Man acquitted over 'automatism' stabbing of wife

Man acquitted over 'automatism' stabbing of wife
In his decision, Justice Warren Milman outlines Perignon's difficulties with extreme pain from two separate motor vehicle accidents, leading to an opioid prescription described in the judgment as "dangerously high" and above a level that would be "fatal for someone naive to opioids."    

Man acquitted over 'automatism' stabbing of wife

Groundhog Day: Fred la Marmotte dead

Groundhog Day: Fred la Marmotte dead
According to folklore, if a groundhog sees its shadow on Groundhog Day, winter will drag on. However, if it doesn't spot its shadow, spring-like weather will soon arrive. Folklorists say the Groundhog Day ritual may have something to do with Feb. 2 landing midway between winter solstice and spring equinox, but no one knows for sure.   

Groundhog Day: Fred la Marmotte dead

Family reacts as Mounties face Manslaughter charge

Family reacts as Mounties face Manslaughter charge
The civil liberties association statement says although the independent review in 2019 found "reasonable grounds" to believe two officers may have committed offences related to use of force, and three others may have obstructed justice, the Crown was not handed a final report until 2020, and charge approval took nearly three more years.

Family reacts as Mounties face Manslaughter charge