Close X
Sunday, September 22, 2024
ADVT 
National

High court to hear case on overseas terror tracking by Canadian spies

Darpan News Desk The Canadian Press, 05 Feb, 2015 10:26 AM

OTTAWA — The Supreme Court of Canada will delve into the legalities of overseas spying by the Canadian Security Intelligence Service.

The federal government had urged the high court to hear the case, arguing that guidance was needed on the issue even though the Conservatives had introduced legislation to clarify foreign intelligence-gathering powers.

In its arguments, the government said recently tabled legislation didn't overtake the high-profile issue of whether CSIS needed a warrant to seek allied help in spying on Canadians abroad.

It said CSIS was left in the dark as to when a judge's approval is needed to monitor suspected Canadian extremists in other countries.

Federal lawyers also said lower courts made significant errors in dealing with the delicate matter.

As usual, the Supreme Court gave no reasons Thursday for agreeing to examine the case. No hearing date has been set.

In a central 2013 ruling, Federal Court Justice Richard Mosley chastised CSIS over a request for warrants to track two Canadians with help from the Communications Security Establishment, Canada's electronic spy agency.

Mosley said CSIS breached its duty of candour by failing to disclose that CSE's foreign counterparts in the so-called Five Eyes intelligence network — the United States, Britain, Australia and New Zealand — could be called upon to assist.

He also warned that CSIS and CSE were incurring the risk Canadian targets "may be detained or otherwise harmed" as a result of foreign agencies' use of the intercepted communications.

The Federal Court of Appeal upheld Mosley's judgment.

The appeal court declared that a warrant is required when CSIS — either directly or through the auspices of a foreign spy service — uses "intrusive" methods such as interception of telecommunications. It said such warrants could be issued when the interception "is lawful where it occurs."

The government, however, said the question of whether a warrant is required in such circumstances would remain "an important issue" even if the bill currently before Parliament becomes law.

Gordon Cameron, an Ottawa lawyer appointed to test the federal arguments, said the high court shouldn't bother with the case because the federal bill could make the key issue moot.

The legislation, introduced in late October, would explicitly allow CSIS to seek a warrant to investigate a security threat beyond Canada's borders — something the government flags as a pressing concern as a number of young Canadians travel to train and fight with terrorist groups abroad.

Cameron said in his written submission that if the high court decided to hear the case — against his advice — it should wait "a reasonable period" to gauge the bill's effect.

The Supreme Court had previously confirmed that Canada didn't need a warrant when it asked Swiss authorities to turn over banking records related to a criminal probe of alleged kickbacks in the sale of Airbus planes, the government noted in asking the high court to take on the CSIS case.

That suggests CSIS doesn't need one when asking its Five Eyes allies to spy overseas.

Still, the government added, a fresh Supreme Court ruling is needed to clear up the uncertainty.

MORE National ARTICLES

Toronto businessman and philanthropist Joseph Rotman dies at age 80

Toronto businessman and philanthropist Joseph Rotman dies at age 80
TORONTO — Canadian businessman and philanthropist Joseph Rotman is dead at the age of 80.

Toronto businessman and philanthropist Joseph Rotman dies at age 80

Court hears Gordon Stuckless lured young boys with the help of an accomplice

Court hears Gordon Stuckless lured young boys with the help of an accomplice
TORONTO — A court in Toronto is hearing that the man at the centre of the Maple Leaf Gardens sex abuse scandal had a system to lure young boys that sometimes involved working with an accomplice.

Court hears Gordon Stuckless lured young boys with the help of an accomplice

Mulcair unveils more platform planks: tax relief for small biz, manufacturers

Mulcair unveils more platform planks: tax relief for small biz, manufacturers
OTTAWA — Tom Mulcair has nailed down three more planks in the NDP election platform, unveiling promises of tax relief for small business and manufacturers.

Mulcair unveils more platform planks: tax relief for small biz, manufacturers

Solitary confinement branded cruel, inhumane as more groups challenge practice

Solitary confinement branded cruel, inhumane as more groups challenge practice
TORONTO — The federal government is facing a second court challenge to the use of solitary confinement in prisons.

Solitary confinement branded cruel, inhumane as more groups challenge practice

Federal books face deficit if oil prices stay at current levels: PBO

Federal books face deficit if oil prices stay at current levels: PBO
OTTAWA — Canada's parliamentary budget office says Ottawa will stay in a deficit in the coming fiscal year if battered oil prices stay near their current lows.

Federal books face deficit if oil prices stay at current levels: PBO

Does a family making $120K per year qualify as 'middle-class'? The feds think so

Does a family making $120K per year qualify as 'middle-class'? The feds think so
OTTAWA — Canada's finance minister insists low- and middle-income families will see two-thirds of the benefits from the Harper government's contentious multibillion-dollar tableau of family-friendly measures.

Does a family making $120K per year qualify as 'middle-class'? The feds think so