Close X
Thursday, November 14, 2024
ADVT 
National

Hiding Bankrupt Toronto Property Flip 'Fraudulent Misrepresentation,' Ontario Court Rules

Darpan News Desk The Canadian Press, 25 Feb, 2016 11:44 AM
    TORONTO — A businessman who bought a downtown Toronto property in a bankruptcy sale but secretly flipped it for almost $3 million more before the deal went through is liable for fraudulent misrepresentation, Ontario's top court ruled Thursday.
     
    In upholding a lower court decision, the Court of Appeal found Ahmed Baig had deliberately misled the company handling the bankruptcy by failing to alert them to the resale.
     
    "In certain circumstances, silence and half-truths can amount to a misrepresentation," the Appeal Court ruled.
     
    Baig bought the property at 984 Bay Street from the bankruptcy receiver with court approval for $6.2 million in August 2006. The receiver, however, had no idea Baig had already agreed to resell the property to another company, Yellowstone Property Consultants, for $9 million.
     
    On the advice of Baig's lawyer, Peter Kiborn, the deal was structured so that the property would go directly to Yellowstone to avoid transfer taxes, court documents show.
     
    "Both the appellant and his counsel wanted to prevent the receiver from discovering the sale to Yellowstone, because the $2.8 million differential in the price would jeopardize court approval," the Appeal Court said.
     
    As a result, the receiver assumed Yellowstone was Baig's company and neither he nor his lawyer corrected that misunderstanding, according to court documents.
     
    "Both the appellant and his counsel actively hid the agreement," the Appeal Court found.
     
    Meridian Credit Union, which was the top creditor at the time of the sale to Yellowstone, discovered the resale in 2009 and sued Baig for the difference. The receiver, obliged to maximize the return on assets of any sales, argued it would never have recommended court approval had it known about the flip.
     
    In 2014, Superior Court Justice Frederick Myers found Baig liable for fraudulent misrepresentation.
     
    Myers concluded Baig was responsible for the misrepresentations made by Kiborn, who knew documents given to the receiver were false. While Baig had no obligation to disclose the resale agreement, Myers decided, his failure to correct the misunderstanding that Yellowstone was his company amounted to fraudulent misrepresentation.
     
    The Appeal Court also dismissed a claim by Kiborn and his firm, Miller Thomson, that they were denied natural justice when Myers made findings about them that could damage their reputations in their absence.
     
    "Non-parties should not be able to lurk in the shadows and then spring up to challenge a decision whenever the outcome — or findings of fact — may affect them in some manner they do not like," the Appeal Court said.
     
    It found Myers' findings reasonable and "amply supported by the evidence."
     
    Baig launched a suit against Kiborn and Miller Thomson in 2012 in hopes of being shielded from having to pay Meridian any money.

    MORE National ARTICLES

    Winnipeg Police Believe Body In Bin Is 17-Year-Old Cooper Nemeth Missing Since Hockey Party

    Winnipeg Police Believe Body In Bin Is 17-Year-Old Cooper Nemeth Missing Since Hockey Party
    Police in Winnipeg say they believe the body of a missing Winnipeg teen has been found in a bin not far from where he was last seen, an a man now faces a murder charge.

    Winnipeg Police Believe Body In Bin Is 17-Year-Old Cooper Nemeth Missing Since Hockey Party

    RCMP Association Calls For Overhaul After Latest Sexual Harassment Allegations

    RCMP Association Calls For Overhaul After Latest Sexual Harassment Allegations
    A group vying to become the Mounties' first bargaining unit is using new allegations of sex harassment and bullying to try to make its case for a group to represent rank and file officers.

    RCMP Association Calls For Overhaul After Latest Sexual Harassment Allegations

    Ontario Teacher Charges With 36 Sex Crimes, Making Pornography Involving Youths Aged 12 To 15

    Ontario Teacher Charges With 36 Sex Crimes, Making Pornography Involving Youths Aged 12 To 15
    Police say Jaclyn McLaren, 36, also known as Jaclyn Jones, was initially charged on Monday in connection with allegations involving young people between the ages of 12 and 15

    Ontario Teacher Charges With 36 Sex Crimes, Making Pornography Involving Youths Aged 12 To 15

    Online Puppy Scam Won't Lead To Happy Tales, Warns Better Business Bureau

    Online Puppy Scam Won't Lead To Happy Tales, Warns Better Business Bureau
    The British Columbia Better Business Bureau is warning people about an online puppy scam that is anything but cute and cuddly.

    Online Puppy Scam Won't Lead To Happy Tales, Warns Better Business Bureau

    From Military To Mainstream: Experts Say Drones Taking Off In Many Industries

    From Military To Mainstream: Experts Say Drones Taking Off In Many Industries
     A vast smile breaks out across Wyatt Travis' face as the machine he's operating tilts slightly and whirrs upwards, an omnipresent buzz echoing from the four dizzying propellers.

    From Military To Mainstream: Experts Say Drones Taking Off In Many Industries

    Closing Of Duffy Trial Takes Proceedings From The Whos And Whats To Why And How

    Closing Of Duffy Trial Takes Proceedings From The Whos And Whats To Why And How
    OTTAWA — As a former journalist, Sen. Mike Duffy knows the components of a story — you need the who, the what, the where, the when, the why and the how.

    Closing Of Duffy Trial Takes Proceedings From The Whos And Whats To Why And How