Close X
Saturday, November 30, 2024
ADVT 
National

G20 Officer Committed Battery, Violated Rights Of Protester, Court Rules

Darpan News Desk The Canadian Press, 31 Mar, 2015 12:10 PM
  • G20 Officer Committed Battery, Violated Rights Of Protester, Court Rules

TORONTO — A police officer who gained widespread notoriety for telling a protester at the infamous G20 summit that "this ain't Canada right now" committed battery when he manhandled him, Ontario's top court has concluded.

The ruling by the Ontario Court of Appeal overturns a lower court finding that Sgt. Mark Charlebois had only touched Paul Figueiras at the June 2010 event in downtown Toronto.

"Even if Sgt. Charlebois was authorized to stop Mr. Figueiras and demand that he submit to a search, I do not accept that the grabbing and pushing that occurred here were 'necessary' to achieve this purpose," the Appeal Court found.

"Sgt. Charlebois committed the tort of battery."

The weekend G20 summit was marred by vandalism and the largest mass detention and violation of civil rights in Canadian peacetime history.

The particular incident occurred when a group of York Regional police officers brought in for the summit stopped Figueiras and his friends — who wanted to demonstrate in favour of animal rights — and told them to submit to a search if they wished to carry on walking down the street.

Figueiras refused, arguing the request violated his rights.

Charlebois's response — caught on widely viewed video — was to grab Figueiras, push him away and tell him to "get moving."

"There's no civil rights here in this area," Charlebois told him. "This ain’t Canada right now."

The protester turned to the courts, seeking only a declaration that the officers had violated his constitutional rights and that Charlebois had committed battery by grabbing and pushing him.

In the lower court ruling, Ontario Superior Court Justice Frederick Myers found police had acted lawfully and that any force Charlebois used was minimal and justified.

The Appeal Court disagreed on both counts.

"Rule of law is a fundamental principle of the Canadian constitution," the court said. 

"The actions taken by Sgt. Charlebois and his team were not reasonably necessary and had little, if any, impact in reducing threats to public safety, imminent or otherwise."

The officers, the court found, were not simply controlling access to an area as might happen at an airport or courthouse where they have specific authority to screen everyone. Instead they were targeting some people and forcing them to submit to a search — without any authority to do so.

"The intention motivating the police conduct was therefore to stop everyone who appeared to be exercising their freedom of expression, and to impose an onerous condition upon them," the court ruled. 

"The officers' remarks further undermine the reasonableness of their conduct, and aggravate the harm to Mr. Figueiras’s liberty."

Police, the court concluded, violated Figueiras's constitutional right to freedom of expression, peaceful assembly, and liberty.

It ordered police to pay him $10,000 in legal costs.

MORE National ARTICLES

B.C. Introduces New Legal Centre For Parents In Child Protection System

VANCOUVER — The B.C. government is hoping to reduce the number of child-protection cases going to court by opening a new legal centre for parents.

B.C. Introduces New Legal Centre For Parents In Child Protection System

B.C. Court Of Appeal Sides With Provincial Court Judges On Pay And Pension

B.C. Court Of Appeal Sides With Provincial Court Judges On Pay And Pension
VANCOUVER — Provincial court judges in British Columbia have won a round in a long-standing battle against the government over pay and pension.

B.C. Court Of Appeal Sides With Provincial Court Judges On Pay And Pension

Surrey Sting: 13 Arrested For Drugs And Weapons Offences

Surrey Sting: 13 Arrested For Drugs And Weapons Offences
SURREY, B.C. — Over a dozen people face a total of 66 drug and firearm charges after months-long investigation by RCMP in Surrey, B.C.

Surrey Sting: 13 Arrested For Drugs And Weapons Offences

Two Men Fined $30 Million, Banned From Markets For B.C. Investor Fraud

Two Men Fined $30 Million, Banned From Markets For B.C. Investor Fraud
VANCOUVER — The B.C. Securities Commission has permanently banned two men from the province's capital markets over what it says was one of the largest cases of fraud in British Columbia history.

Two Men Fined $30 Million, Banned From Markets For B.C. Investor Fraud

Charges Stayed Against Semi Driver Harjit Lotay In Surrey Crash That Killed Const. Adrian Oliver

Charges Stayed Against Semi Driver Harjit Lotay In Surrey Crash That Killed Const. Adrian Oliver
Const. Adrian Oliver died in November 2012 when his police cruiser slammed into the truck driven by Harjit Lotay. His lawyer, Brij Mohan, says the Crown has now stayed all charges but his client is still facing a federal lawsuit seeking special damages and expenses

Charges Stayed Against Semi Driver Harjit Lotay In Surrey Crash That Killed Const. Adrian Oliver

Man Under Arrest, Victim Hurt After Samaritan Stops Vancouver Sex Attack

Man Under Arrest, Victim Hurt After Samaritan Stops Vancouver Sex Attack
Police say a man armed with a weapon entered a home shortly after noon Thursday, attacked and tied up the woman and then sexually assaulted her. A witness who heard the woman screaming went into the home and struggled with the attacker.

Man Under Arrest, Victim Hurt After Samaritan Stops Vancouver Sex Attack