Close X
Saturday, September 21, 2024
ADVT 
National

First Nations' Challenges Of Northern Gateway Pipeline To Be Heard In Court

Darpan News Desk The Canadian Press, 01 Oct, 2015 10:19 AM
    VANCOUVER — Multiple legal challenges aimed at overturning the federal government's approval of the Enbridge (TSX:ENB) Northern Gateway pipeline will be heard starting Thursday.
     
    The challenges are expected to bring new scrutiny to the government's environmental approval process and its responsibility to consult with aboriginal groups.
     
    Eight First Nations, four environmental groups and one labour union launched the legal actions, which will be heard at the Federal Court of Appeal over six days in Vancouver.
     
    Their arguments include that the federal panel that reviewed the project didn't adequately consider threats to wildlife and oceans and excluded key issues of concern to First Nations.
     
    "There was no consultation," said Terry Teegee, a tribal chief with the Carrier Sekani Tribal Council, which represents two communities that have filed litigation.
     
    "We didn't participate in the Joint Review Panel process because it didn't address the issues that we wanted, in terms of the cumulative impacts of the project as well as our title and rights."
     
    The government accepted the panel's recommendations and in June 2014 approved the $7-billion project that would carry bitumen from Alberta's oilsands to British Columbia's coast. There were 209 conditions attached to the acceptance.
     
    Canada's Attorney General, Northern Gateway Pipelines L Partnership and the National Energy Board are named as respondents to the challenges.
     
    Three organizations — Amnesty International, the Canadian Association of Petroleum Producers and British Columbia's Attorney General — will make arguments as interveners.
     
    The federal government declined to comment ahead of the hearings.
     
    Speaking for Northern Gateway, Ivan Giesbrecht said the company recognizes traditional aboriginal land use rights and believes First Nations should share in ownership and benefits.
     
    "Our ongoing priority is to continue to build trust, engage in respectful dialogues and build meaningful partnerships with First Nations and Metis communities," he said.
     
    "We know we have more work to do in this regard and we are committed to doing this work."
     
    Giesbrecht said the Joint Review Panel's examination of the Northern Gateway project was among the most exhaustive in Canadian history, spanning 180 days of hearings.
     
    But Karen Wristen of the Living Oceans Society, among the groups that filed challenges, said the panel appeared to ignore crucial evidence submitted by interveners.
     
    Her organization's evidence indicated spilled bitumen would sink beneath the ocean's surface, making it impossible to recover using conventional technology. The panel's report, however, found the environment would recover within months or years — a conclusion that Wristen said there's no evidence to support.
     
    She said she hopes the hearings draw attention to Canada's "suffering" environmental assessment process.
     
    "I think environmental assessment in this country is in deep, deep trouble at the moment," she said. "It's not providing the kind of in-depth scientific review that the government would have us believe it is."
     
    Pete Erickson, a hereditary chief with the Nak'azdli First Nation, said Enbridge was given days to present its case to the panel while he got 10 minutes to speak for his people.
     
    He said a 2014 Supreme Court decision that gave land title to the Tsilhqot'in sets a precedent that requires the government to not only consult with First Nations, but seek their approval.
     
    "We've said that under no circumstances is the pipeline ever going to be allowed in the current presentation," he said. "We've decided that there's no way we can allow it and I believe that the court will recognize that we have the right to say that."

    MORE National ARTICLES

    Toronto City Councillor Pens Rob Ford Book, Bound For Shelves In October

    Toronto City Councillor Pens Rob Ford Book, Bound For Shelves In October
    The antics of Toronto politician Rob Ford have inspired yet another book — this time written by a fellow city councillor.

    Toronto City Councillor Pens Rob Ford Book, Bound For Shelves In October

    21st Century Belongs To India, Says PM Modi As He Wows Indian Community In California

    21st Century Belongs To India, Says PM Modi As He Wows Indian Community In California
    Modi, in an over hour-long address to a "Modi, Modi” chanting crowd, also said that terrorism and climate change are the main challenges facing the world and urged all nations to unite in facing the twin threats.

    21st Century Belongs To India, Says PM Modi As He Wows Indian Community In California

    David Wynn, Officers Who Died In The Line Of Duty Are Honoured In Cross-Country Services

    David Wynn, Officers Who Died In The Line Of Duty Are Honoured In Cross-Country Services
    As memorial services across Canada recognized peace officers who have died in the line of duty, two cases in northern Alberta this past year showed just how dangerous their jobs can be

    David Wynn, Officers Who Died In The Line Of Duty Are Honoured In Cross-Country Services

    Weekend Shopping Mall Killing Brings Vancouver's Murder Count To 13 For 2015

    Weekend Shopping Mall Killing Brings Vancouver's Murder Count To 13 For 2015
    Police say they responded shortly after 2 p.m. on Sunday to multiple calls of shots fired in a mall parking lot (on King Edward Avenue near Oak Street).

    Weekend Shopping Mall Killing Brings Vancouver's Murder Count To 13 For 2015

    B.C. To Lead Country In Growth, But Job Creation Stuck In Second Gear

    Premier Christy Clark's promises to transform British Columbia into Canada's top job-creating engine appears to be stuck in second gear, even as the provincial economy is predicted to surge.

    B.C. To Lead Country In Growth, But Job Creation Stuck In Second Gear

    Brother Of Murdered Woman Shocked After Vancouver Removes Memorials

    Brother Of Murdered Woman Shocked After Vancouver Removes Memorials
    Bronze plaques bearing the names of Georgina Papin, Brenda Wolfe and Marnie Frey were installed in a sidewalk in the city's Downtown Eastside in 2012.

    Brother Of Murdered Woman Shocked After Vancouver Removes Memorials