Close X
Tuesday, November 12, 2024
ADVT 
National

Firing Gun In Rural Area Not 'inherently' Dangerous, Ontario Appeal Court Rules

Colin Perkel, Darpan, 05 Sep, 2014 01:14 PM
  • Firing Gun In Rural Area Not 'inherently' Dangerous, Ontario Appeal Court Rules
TORONTO - A former American military sniper who fired his gun to scare off a stray dog in a rural area of Ontario deserves another trial on charges of careless use of a firearm, the province's top court ruled Friday.
 
In its decision, the Court of Appeal said two lower courts were wrong to convict John Batty on the basis that the simple act of firing his gun was dangerous, and noted their rulings could have serious implications for those who live outside urban areas.
 
"Absent any finding as to the manner in which the rifle was used or the trajectory of the projectile, there may have been any number of ways in which the shot could have been fired which might have posed no risk to others," the Appeal Court said.
 
"This is not a situation like a shooting in a shopping mall, which would be inherently dangerous."
 
In deciding to hear the appeal, the top provincial court noted the implications of the guilty verdict for rural residents.
 
"The generality of the findings supporting the conclusion that the use of the rifle was careless may have broader significance relating to permissible farm practices," the court said.
 
Batty, 67, who lives near St. Thomas, Ont., was convicted in January last year. The summary conviction was upheld on first appeal in December.
 
He testified he was experienced in the use of firearms and routinely shot weasels, rats and vermin to keep them from his chickens.
 
The trial judge made no findings about how Batty had fired his rifle given there were no eye witnesses. However, he still concluded that discharging the weapon beside the road and close to neighbouring homes was inherently dangerous.
 
The initial appeal judge upheld the conviction, saying the trial judge's inferences that firing the weapon posed a safety risk to anyone in the area was reasonable.
 
Batty argued the conviction should be set aside on the grounds there was no evidence to show his use of the rifle was necessarily careless and the Court of Appeal agreed.
 
"In our view, the trial judge and the summary conviction judge both erred in concluding that firing a shot in this rural environment, whatever the manner in which the shot was fired, necessarily amounted to a marked departure from the conduct of a reasonable person," the Appeal Court found.
 
"The conviction cannot be sustained."
 
Batty's lawyer, Phillip Millar, said the ruling was important for all rural residents.
 
"(Farmers) can't be at risk of being convicted because somebody heard a shot," Millar said.

MORE National ARTICLES

Man accused of stabbing 5 people to death in Calgary faces another delay

Man accused of stabbing 5 people to death in Calgary faces another delay
A psychiatric assessment for a man accused of stabbing five young people to death at a house party in Calgary has been done but the final report is not yet complete.

Man accused of stabbing 5 people to death in Calgary faces another delay

Trudeau 50 years late on shale gas, New Brunswick Premier David Alward says

Trudeau 50 years late on shale gas, New Brunswick Premier David Alward says
Federal Liberal Leader Justin Trudeau is a half century behind when he says there should be greater scientific study before the shale gas industry expands, Premier David Alward said Thursday.

Trudeau 50 years late on shale gas, New Brunswick Premier David Alward says

Christy Clark says talk about the Constitution won't happen at premiers meeting

Christy Clark says talk about the Constitution won't happen at premiers meeting
British Columbia Premier Christy Clark says there's little chance Canada's premiers will talk about bringing Quebec into the Constitution at their annual meeting in Charlottetown.

Christy Clark says talk about the Constitution won't happen at premiers meeting

Brad Wall says time to scrap 'dumb' trade rules as West launches review

Brad Wall says time to scrap 'dumb' trade rules as West launches review
The premiers of Canada's three western provinces announced Thursday they're going to review the remaining trade barriers between them as part of their New West Partnership.

Brad Wall says time to scrap 'dumb' trade rules as West launches review

Canada's jets, part of NATO mission, edge closer to Russian airspace

Canada's jets, part of NATO mission, edge closer to Russian airspace
Canadian fighter jets will be patrolling the edge of Russian airspace next week as part of NATO's response to the unravelling situation in Ukraine.

Canada's jets, part of NATO mission, edge closer to Russian airspace

Earl and countess of Wessex to tour B.C., Saskatchewan, northern Ontario

Earl and countess of Wessex to tour B.C., Saskatchewan, northern Ontario
Royalty is set to arrive in British Columbia in September before visits to Saskatchewan and Ontario.

Earl and countess of Wessex to tour B.C., Saskatchewan, northern Ontario