Close X
Wednesday, December 11, 2024
ADVT 
National

Federal Court Dismisses Bid To Stop Feds Revoking Citizenship Without A Hearing

Darpan News Desk, 08 Nov, 2016 12:59 PM
    OTTAWA — A bid to stop the federal government from revoking Canadians' citizenship without a hearing has failed.
     
    Federal Court Justice Russell Zinn has dismissed a case brought by the Canadian Association of Refugee Lawyers and the British Columbia Civil Liberties Association.
     
    The two advocacy groups had sought a stay of a section of the Citizenship Act which allows the government to revoke the citizenship of anyone deemed to have misrepresented themselves — a provision which they argued could potentially ensnare Democratic Institutions Minister Maryam Monsef.
     
    Monsef last month discovered that she was born in Iran, not Afghanistan as she'd always believed.
     
    The law is being challenged as unconstitutional but until that case is settled, the Federal Court has since January been systematically granting stays to individuals who apply for them.
     
    The advocacy groups had argued that not everyone is aware or can afford a lawyer to seek a court-ordered stay of proceedings; they asked Zinn to impose a blanket stay for everyone who receives a notice of citizenship revocation.
     
    But Zinn ruled Monday that a blanket stay can only be ordered if the harm caused by the law is unavoidable.
     
    In this case, he said it is avoidable because any individual can apply to the court for a stay.
     
    "The failure of a person, for whatever reason, to take advantage of the de facto stay available, does not change the fact that it is available to them and that it will avoid the harm," he wrote.
     
    The advocacy groups said they are disappointed with the ruling.
     
    "We brought this application to prevent people from falling through the cracks and finding themselves stripped of their citizenship without due process. We're disappointed the court did not see the urgency of the situation," Lorne Waldman, who represents the refugee lawyers, said in a statement. 
     
    "However, we will continue to fight for fairness in revocation proceedings and we’ll be back in court again next week to argue that the process is unconstitutional."
     
    The Liberals had denounced the law when they were in opposition and, since forming government, have promised to change it to provide for a proper hearing and appeal process for those believed to have misrepresented themselves to gain citizenship.
     
    However, the government has so far refused to stop enforcing the law in the meantime.

    MORE National ARTICLES

    Christy Clark Rallies B.C. Liberals Months Ahead Of 2017 Election

    Christy Clark Rallies B.C. Liberals Months Ahead Of 2017 Election
    Christy Clark spoke at the B.C. Liberal party's convention Sunday, saying members must prove to the province that the party is one residents can believe in.

    Christy Clark Rallies B.C. Liberals Months Ahead Of 2017 Election

    Abbotsford Students Say 'It's Scary' To Return To School After Teen Fatally Stabbed There

    Abbotsford Students Say 'It's Scary' To Return To School After Teen Fatally Stabbed There
    Letisha Reimer was killed and her friend was injured last Tuesday at a school in Abbotsford, B.C., in what police say was a random knife attack by a homeless man.

    Abbotsford Students Say 'It's Scary' To Return To School After Teen Fatally Stabbed There

    American Man In Toronto Beaten To Death After Bachelor Party, Two Male Suspects Wanted

    American Man In Toronto Beaten To Death After Bachelor Party, Two Male Suspects Wanted
      Investigators say the incident started early Saturday morning when a group of men from the United States was at a bar to celebrate a friend's upcoming wedding.

    American Man In Toronto Beaten To Death After Bachelor Party, Two Male Suspects Wanted

    New Homes For Low-Income Renters, People With Disabilities In Surrey

    Individuals and families with low-to moderate-incomes and people with disabilities are benefiting from 71 new units of affordable rental housing at Chorus Apartments, which officially opened in Surrey today.

    New Homes For Low-Income Renters, People With Disabilities In Surrey

    Teen Who Attacked Two Winnipeg Women Has Very Low IQ, FASD: Psychiatrist

    The man, who cannot be named because he was 17 at the time of the attacks two years ago, pleaded guilty earlier this year to two counts of aggravated sexual assault.

    Teen Who Attacked Two Winnipeg Women Has Very Low IQ, FASD: Psychiatrist

    Heavy Rain, Swelling Rivers Threaten Vancouver Island First Nation

    Heavy Rain, Swelling Rivers Threaten Vancouver Island First Nation
    PORT ALBERNI, B.C. — A First Nation near Port Alberni, B.C., expects to evacuate some homes as heavy rains cause rivers to flood.

    Heavy Rain, Swelling Rivers Threaten Vancouver Island First Nation