Close X
Sunday, September 22, 2024
ADVT 
National

'Extremely fluid': Liberals and NDP haven't yet agreed on promised pharmacare bill

Darpan News Desk The Canadian Press, 05 Oct, 2023 11:45 AM
  • 'Extremely fluid': Liberals and NDP haven't yet agreed on promised pharmacare bill

The federal New Democrats have rejected the first draft of the Liberals' pharmacare legislation, in what the health minister describes as "extremely fluid" negotiations over the highly anticipated bill.

The Liberals promised to table pharmacare legislation this fall as part of the supply-and-confidence deal the government struck with the NDP.

That deal calls for "progress toward a universal national pharmacare program" and the passage of initial legislation before the end of the year. But NDP health critic Don Davies says the first draft of the bill didn't meet expectations.

"It doesn't meet the New Democrats' red lines at this point," Davies said in an interview. "We're waiting for a next draft to come to us."

Davies said the NDP will accept nothing less than a commitment to pharmacare paid for and administered through the public single-payer system, though it doesn't have to happen all at once.

The NDP would be willing to start with essential medicines and expand from there, he said, but wants to see the timelines enshrined in the legislation.

Health Minister Mark Holland would not say whether the coming legislation would commit to any particular model, because the situation could change by the time the bill is tabled. 

Holland said he's been speaking with the NDP about what is possible, both in terms of the legislation and other promised progress on pharmacare, including a national list of drugs and the formation of a new drug agency to negotiate drug prices on behalf of Canadians. 

"That process is moving back and forth, and it's extremely fluid, and it's changing with every conversation that we have," Holland said in an interview.  

Whatever the government eventually lands on, he said the legislation will serve as a foundation for national pharmacare and will not reflect the final version of the program.

"What we announce will certainly not be the end of the story," Holland said. "When we get that work done and that foundation right, it means everything else can go up more quickly thereafter."

There's a wide spectrum of options the government could consider when drafting the legislation, from the NDP's vision for a single-payer system to a vaguely worded piece of legislation that makes no mention of how pharmacare will be achieved.

The Liberals could also consider a program that only offers coverage to people with low incomes who aren't already insured, as it has with its upcoming dental care plan. 

But when the Liberals tasked an advisory council to figure out the best option in 2019, a single-payer system was the obvious choice, said Dr. Eric Hoskins, who chaired the committee that wrote the definitive pharmacare report. 

"It's also consistent with virtually every commission or committee or expert group that has looked at this issue over the decades for Canada, in recommending a single-payer public model," Hoskins said. 

His report found that a single-payer model would give the government the bargaining power to reduce drug prices, reduce administrative costs, save money on treatments and reduce expensive hospital visits.

He said he's been in talks with the NDP, Liberals and advocates as the government puts the legislation together. 

"I felt it important that I deepen those conversations and provide whatever advice and help I can," he said in an interview. "It's an enormously complex undertaking."

That's part of the reason the committee's report recommended that as a country, "we start with essential meds," he said. 

The government is under no obligation to attach any funds to the legislation at this point, but in 2017 the parliamentary budget officer estimated that a pharmacare plan would cost $19.3 billion per year if it had been implemented in 2015, and would grow over time to cost $22.6 billion annually.

In today’s dollars, the annual cost would be between $23 billion and $27 billion.

At the same time, overall spending on drugs — between governments, insurance companies and Canadians — would be expected to drop by $4.4 billion as a result of better purchasing power.

Hoskins said starting with essential medicines would only cost roughly $3.5 to $4.5 billion per year. That would cover roughly half of all the prescriptions written each year. 

"That would be an enormous victory for Canadians," he said, with a "transformational impact."

The government must still consider the upfront costs of a new program like pharmacare, though, said Robert Asselin, senior vice-president of policy at the Business Council of Canada. He was also the director of policy for former Liberal finance minister Bill Morneau. 

Canada is heading into an economic slowdown, which means less revenue for the government. The cost of servicing the government's debt is expected to be higher than what was predicted in the last budget. 

"It's not a question of whether these programs are good or bad for the country. It's a matter of: can we afford them with the fiscal outlook that we have?" Asselin said. 

Asselin said it's clear to him that the government can't currently afford the full-fledged program, even if it is more efficient in the long run.

"If growth is back, and the outlook looks better, maybe we could reconsider some of these programs. But right now, I think, would be really a bad time to introduce such a big program," he said. 

Whatever is tabled in the final legislation will likely be very broad and similar to the Canada Health Act, said Simon Fraser University health policy adjunct professor Steven Lewis.

That means many important details, such as the roles of provinces and of private insurance companies, will likely come later — and will presumably be dictated by how much the government is willing to spend, he said. 

"Provinces will be wary of committing unless the feds come through with the money," he added. 

Holland would not say when the legislation is expected to be tabled, but has committed to meeting the end-of-year deadline in the supply-and-confidence agreement. 

 

MORE National ARTICLES

Bank of Canada may need to raise rates again, despite this week's hold: Macklem

Bank of Canada may need to raise rates again, despite this week's hold: Macklem
The Bank of Canada may have to raise interest rates further, given that inflation may stay high for some time, said governor Tiff Macklem Thursday. His speech at the Calgary Chamber of Commerce came one day after the central bank decided to hold its key interest rate steady at five per cent as signs of an economic slowdown grow.

Bank of Canada may need to raise rates again, despite this week's hold: Macklem

Trudeau eyes Indo-Pacific trade deals to avoid China aim to 'play us off each other'

Trudeau eyes Indo-Pacific trade deals to avoid China aim to 'play us off each other'
Prime Minister Justin Trudeau says Canada's rocky relations with China have stabilized, while telling business leaders in Singapore that Ottawa has committed to a timeline for trade deals with the region. Trudeau is undertaking a weeklong visit to Indonesia, Singapore and India with a focus on shoring up trade in a region Ottawa sees as key to counteracting coercive economic moves by China. 

Trudeau eyes Indo-Pacific trade deals to avoid China aim to 'play us off each other'

Changes to minimum tax to add $2.6 billion over five years for feds: PBO

Changes to minimum tax to add $2.6 billion over five years for feds: PBO
The parliamentary budget officer says the federal government's proposed changes to the alternative minimum tax will generate an additional $2.6 billion in revenue over five years. The tax aims to ensure high-income earners and trusts don't pay disproportionately less in taxes than other taxpayers. 

Changes to minimum tax to add $2.6 billion over five years for feds: PBO

Federal prediction says parts of Canada could see wildfires through winter

Federal prediction says parts of Canada could see wildfires through winter
The latest federal government forecast says Canada's already unprecedented 2023 wildfire season could continue late into the fall or winter. Energy and Natural Resources Minister Jonathan Wilkinson says there is potential for increased wildland fire activity from eastern Alberta through to central Ontario at least until the end of this month, while fires in B.C. and the Northwest Territories will continue to smoulder.

Federal prediction says parts of Canada could see wildfires through winter

Derelict boats removal in Surrey

Derelict boats removal in Surrey
The City of Surrey says it will be removing derelict boats from the Nicomekl River this month. The city says boats have been illegally mooring on a narrow section of the river, dumping raw sewage and garbage into the water, and creating hazards for other boaters.

Derelict boats removal in Surrey

Police return emotional support rabbit that ran loose in Vancouver SkyTrain station

Police return emotional support rabbit that ran loose in Vancouver SkyTrain station
A rabbit that hopped the tracks at a downtown Vancouver transit station was reunited with its owner after efforts by passengers and police. Metro Vancouver Transit Police say the bunny was running loose last Thursday at the Granville SkyTrain station when a passenger picked it up and handed it to officers patrolling the underground stop.

Police return emotional support rabbit that ran loose in Vancouver SkyTrain station