Wednesday, May 27, 2020
ADVT 
National

Ex-Toronto Bar Owner Gets Bail Pending Appeal Of Gang Sexual Assault Conviction

The Canadian Press, 20 Feb, 2020

    TORONTO - A former downtown bar owner has been granted bail pending his appeal of a conviction for the gang sexual assault of a barely conscious woman.

     

    In his decision, a Court of Appeal justice ruled that Gavin MacMillan had strong grounds to challenge his conviction and nine-year sentence given problems with how his jury was selected.

     

    "This argument is far removed from being frivolous," Justice James MacPherson said in granting bail. "Indeed, it is almost the opposite; it is almost certain to succeed."

     

    MacMillan and his bar manager, Enzo De Jesus Carrasco, were convicted in November of sexually assaulting and administering a noxious substance to the 24-year-old victim. The trial judge called the hours-long, videotaped attack violent and degrading.

     

    Even before sentence was imposed earlier this month, MacMillan had indicated he planned an appeal related to the selection of the jury — an issue that potentially affects dozens of other jury trials.

     

    The appeal turns on federal legislation that took effect in September and removed peremptory juror challenges, which allowed either defence lawyers or prosecutors to veto prospective jurors without explanation. Ontario's top court has already ordered a new trial in one such case in which it found the new jury rules were improperly applied.

     

    "Barring something unforeseen arising, the appeal in this case will almost certainly be allowed and a new trial will be ordered," MacPherson said. "Accordingly, this factor counts strongly in the applicant's favour."

     

    MacPherson also noted that MacMillan complied with his bail conditions — including house arrest — before and during his trial, and imposed a similar condition. Carrasco had remained behind bars throughout.

     

    The prosecution opposed bail for MacMillan, arguing a successful appeal is far from a certainty given that the Crown is hoping to fight the Appeal Court decision that threw dozens of jury trials into doubt. The Supreme Court of Canada, the prosecution said, may yet overturn the earlier ruling or find that a new trial is not the answer.

     

    On Thursday, the Supreme Court did agree to hear a prosecution appeal of a case involving convicted terrorists Chiheb Esseghaier and Raed Jaser, whose case also turns on the technicalities of jury selection.

     

    MacPherson, however, called the prosecution's arguments speculative. He called the offences of which MacMillan was convicted "grave" and their circumstances "appalling," but said releasing him would not harm confidence in the administration of justice.

     

    MORE National ARTICLES

    Ex-Quebec Media Star Eric Salvail Tells Trial Sex Assault Accusations 'Bizarre'

    MONTREAL - Former Quebec talk show host Eric Salvail is categorically denying the accusations made against him by a one-time co-worker.

     

     

    Ex-Quebec Media Star Eric Salvail Tells Trial Sex Assault Accusations 'Bizarre'

    The Latest On Protests Across Canada In Support Of Anti-Pipeline Demonstrators

    Here is the latest news on protests across Canada over a natural gas pipeline project in British Columbia:

     

     

    The Latest On Protests Across Canada In Support Of Anti-Pipeline Demonstrators

    Supreme Court Of Canada To Hear Federal Appeal In Via Rail Terror Case

    Supreme Court Of Canada To Hear Federal Appeal In Via Rail Terror Case

    OTTAWA - The Supreme Court of Canada will review a lower-court decision to grant a new trial to two men accused of plotting to crash a Via Rail train.

     

     

    Supreme Court Of Canada To Hear Federal Appeal In Via Rail Terror Case

    Canada Hosts Lima Group, Appeals For World's Help On Venezuela Crisis

    Canada Hosts Lima Group, Appeals For World's Help On Venezuela Crisis

    Canada and its Western Hemisphere allies are calling on the rest of the democratic world to help bring stability to Venezuela, hobbled by a refugee crisis and economic collapse under a dictator they deem illegitimate.

     

     

    Canada Hosts Lima Group, Appeals For World's Help On Venezuela Crisis

    Protests Put Pressure On Trudeau

    The federal Crown-Indigenous relations minister is offering to meet today with Wet'suwet'en hereditary chiefs in northwestern British Columbia.

    Protests Put Pressure On Trudeau

    Babies Frequently Exposed To Cleaning Products At Higher Risk Of Asthma: Study

    Babies Frequently Exposed To Cleaning Products At Higher Risk Of Asthma: Study

    New research suggests frequent exposure to common household cleaning products can increase a child's risk of developing asthma.

    Babies Frequently Exposed To Cleaning Products At Higher Risk Of Asthma: Study

    PrevNext