Close X
Monday, November 11, 2024
ADVT 
National

External review found military's COVID-19 vaccine policy violated Charter of Rights

Darpan News Desk The Canadian Press, 01 Aug, 2023 04:42 PM
  • External review found military's COVID-19 vaccine policy violated Charter of Rights

A tribunal that is part of the military grievance process has found that the Canadian Armed Forces COVID-19 vaccine policy violated its members' Charter rights. 

The Military Grievances External Review Committee reviews grievances that are referred to it by the chief of defence staff, and provides the chief with non-binding findings and recommendations. 

In all, 157 grievances have been filed with the independent tribunal over the military's vaccination policy, which took effect in the fall of 2021 and remained in place for nearly a year before being updated to apply more narrowly. 

Because dozens of similar grievances are being considered at the same time, the committee took the step of releasing three annexes in mid-July that laid out its analysis in order to streamline future cases. 

The vaccine policy required Canadian Armed Forces members to be vaccinated against COVID-19 or face release.

By the time the requirement ended last October, 299 people had been released and another 108 left on their own. 

The initial vaccine mandate in October 2021 came after a similar policy was put in place for the core public administration, including the RCMP and employees of the Department of National Defence. 

The chief of the defence staff's first directive stated that 91 per cent of Armed Forces members had already chosen to get the vaccine, and it gave members until November 2021 to declare whether they were fully vaccinated or if they were unwilling or unable to get the shot. 

Those who could not get vaccinated were to be accommodated under human-rights legislation, but those who chose not to were warned they could lose promotion, training and deployment opportunities or be released altogether.

Anyone who did not disclose their status or who refused a vaccine could face remedial administrative measures, or they could choose to be released or transferred to the supplemental reserve. 

Another directive from December 2021 stated that unvaccinated members could be released under a provision stating that they were unsuitable for service.  

Last October, that was updated to say that vaccines are not required for all those serving in uniform, but are instead based on the roles and responsibilities of individual service members.

In an interview with The Canadian Press at the time, Gen. Wayne Eyre, chief of the defence staff, said service members are expected to follow legal orders — and that a repeated refusal by some troops to get their shots "raises questions about your suitability to serve in uniform."

"It's dangerous in the military to have legal orders disobeyed," he said. "It's a very slippery slope."

The external review committee made findings in three grievance cases at the end of May. 

The committee concluded that the policy infringed the rights protected under Section 7 of the Charter, which guarantees life, liberty and security of the person. It found the limitations on these rights were not in accordance with the principles of fundamental justice.

The tribunal also determined that the limitations were not justified under Section 1 of the Charter, which states that rights and freedoms are subject to reasonable limits.  

Committee member Nina Frid, who wrote the analysis, found that while there was justification for a vaccine mandate because "the science shows that the COVID-19 vaccines are effective at reducing the likelihood of becoming seriously ill or dying from this disease," the policy arbitrarily distinguished between those who could not get the vaccine and those who chose not to get jabbed. 

Frid also wrote that the policy was "overly broad" and its implementation was "disproportionate."

"The characterization that members who are 'unwilling' to get vaccinated are displaying misconduct is in contradiction with the CAF's own pre-existing policies and statements that also guarantee their members' choice towards medical treatment," she wrote.

The committee is recommending that all administrative actions taken against members who refused to get a vaccine be rescinded, and in one case, it is calling for a griever to be allowed to re-enrol in the military.

Eyre will make final decisions in the cases, and as defence chief he does not have to follow the recommendations. He has previously said he would consider requests to re-enrol on a case-by-case basis.

In a written statement, the Defence Department said it is important to note that the process is not finished until Eyre's review is done. 

"The CAF forms its decisions on vaccination by considering the most up-to-date medical evidence and advice, the current federal posture and the need to be operationally ready in terms of both force health and ability to act in an environment where any vaccine-preventable illness is a hazard to individuals and the mission," said spokesperson Jessica Lamirande.

She pointed out that more than 96 per cent of Armed Forces members are vaccinated against COVID-19.

"CAF members routinely get vaccinated as required for a number of diseases — from cholera to yellow fever — before their deployment," the statement said. 

Retired Lt.-Col. Rory Fowler, a lawyer who specializes in military cases, said the public release of the committee's analysis demands a response from Eyre, though he does not expect a decision to come soon. "What it does is it puts in the public domain their views and it forces the issue."

The way the military has gone about releasing members — characterizing their choice not to get vaccinated as a disciplinary matter, rather than pursuing charges — is cowardly, Fowler said. 

He added he does not expect Eyre's office will accept the committee's recommendations, and that eventually these grievances will result in judicial reviews.

"They're going to reject, at least in part, elements of the findings and recommendations that they find unpalatable, and there will then be litigation arising from the eventual determinations."

MORE National ARTICLES

Canada welcomes largest number of immigrants in first quarter since at least 1972

Canada welcomes largest number of immigrants in first quarter since at least 1972
Statistics Canada says the country welcomed more than 145,000 immigrants during the first three months of the year. That's the highest number for a single quarter on record, since comparable data became available in 1972.

Canada welcomes largest number of immigrants in first quarter since at least 1972

B.C. port union issues 72-hour strike notice affecting 7,400 workers

B.C. port union issues 72-hour strike notice affecting 7,400 workers
The union representing port workers in British Columbia says it has issued 72-hour strike notice and its members are ready to walk off the job on Saturday. The strike notice affects about 7,400 terminal cargo loaders and 49 of the province's waterfront employers in more than 30 B.C. ports.

B.C. port union issues 72-hour strike notice affecting 7,400 workers

Surrey RCMP need the public's help in locating missing female Navjot Baring

Surrey RCMP need the public's help in locating missing female Navjot Baring
UPDATE: The Surrey RCMP is pleased to confirm that the 22-year-old female who was reported missing on June 27, 2023 has been located.  

Surrey RCMP need the public's help in locating missing female Navjot Baring

B.C. agrees to delay ending immigration detention in correctional centres

B.C. agrees to delay ending immigration detention in correctional centres
Farnworth has now approved a "one-time" three-month extension of the deal until the end of October at the request of federal Public Safety Minister Marco Mendicino, on the condition that no new detainees will be accepted after July 31. 

B.C. agrees to delay ending immigration detention in correctional centres

Armed robbery in New Westminster

Armed robbery in New Westminster
Police flooded the area and soon located someone matching the suspect description at 6th Avenue and 8th Street. The suspect fled from police and after a foot pursuit, he was arrested. An officer was transported to local hospital after sustaining an injury during the foot pursuit.

Armed robbery in New Westminster

Canada bans testing of cosmetics on animals, in line with dozens of other countries

Canada bans testing of cosmetics on animals, in line with dozens of other countries
In addition to barring companies from testing their cosmetic products on animals in Canada, the regulations prevent new products that rely on animal testing data to establish product safety from being sold in this country.

Canada bans testing of cosmetics on animals, in line with dozens of other countries