Close X
Saturday, December 14, 2024
ADVT 
National

Ex-Quebec Doctor Guy Turcotte Who Killed His Kids Wants To Appeal Parole Eligibility Ruling

Darpan News Desk The Canadian Press, 13 Feb, 2016 12:32 PM
    MONTREAL — A Quebec man sentenced to life for fatally stabbing his two young children is seeking permission to appeal the minimum length of time he must serve before he can make a request to be released.
     
    Guy Turcotte's lawyers filed a motion before the Quebec Court of Appeal on Friday, hoping to challenge the trial judge's ruling he must spend at least 17 years behind bars before being able to apply for parole.
     
    It is scheduled to be heard in Montreal on Feb. 23.
     
    In December, the former doctor was found guilty of second-degree murder in the February 2009 deaths of Olivier, 5, and Anne-Sophie, 3, who were stabbed a total of 46 times.
     
    In mid-January, Quebec Superior Court Justice Andre Vincent ruled that Turcotte, 43, must serve at least 17 years before he can apply to be released.
     
    The judge said it reflected the "heinous and horrible crimes.''
     
    In a five-page motion, Turcotte's attorneys contend Vincent didn't consider jurisprudence that an inadmissibility period of more than 15 years is justified only when the accused is considered a danger to society.
     
    The defence also alleges the judge did not take into account Turcotte's mental state at the time of the slayings.
     
    The document says while the jury concluded the appellant did not demonstrate he was suffering from mental troubles that made it impossible for him to appreciate the acts, the evidence presented during the trial suggested the important role played by mental illness could not be dismissed outright.
     
     
    The Crown asked for 20 years while the defence had countered with a 10-to-15 year suggestion. The jury did not recommend a minimum number of years to be served.
     
    Vincent called the Crown's suggestion "exaggerated" and said it didn't reflect the character of an offender with no previous criminal record and not deemed a high risk to society. He also said the defence's request didn't fully reflect the moral transgressions of the crime.
     
    Last year's trial was the second for Turcotte, who in 2011 was found not criminally responsible for mental health reasons.
     
    His lawyers have already appealed the second verdict, saying the judge erred in law on more than one occasion in his instructions to the jurors.
     
    They are seeking a third trial.
     
    Turcotte's lawyers are asking for the judge's eligibility ruling to be thrown out and substituted with another minimum deemed fit by the appeals court.
     
    If permitted, the appeal would go ahead only after the verdict appeal is heard.

    MORE National ARTICLES

    Manufacturing's Rebound Faces 'Significant' Structural Hurdles: Federal Memo

    Manufacturing's Rebound Faces 'Significant' Structural Hurdles: Federal Memo
    In a recent memo addressed to Economic Development Minister Navdeep Bains, advisers point to industry hurdles that include low productivity, poor innovation, a failure to scale up and weak participation in global value chains.

    Manufacturing's Rebound Faces 'Significant' Structural Hurdles: Federal Memo

    Manitoba Changes How It Counts Kids In Care To Exclude Cases Like Tina Fontaine

    WINNIPEG — Manitoba is changing how it counts the number of children in its care to exclude hundreds of cases such as Tina Fontaine's amid concerns it is being unfairly compared to other provinces.

    Manitoba Changes How It Counts Kids In Care To Exclude Cases Like Tina Fontaine

    CPP Fund Delivers 4.5% Return On Investments In Quarter Ended Dec. 31

    CPP Fund Delivers 4.5% Return On Investments In Quarter Ended Dec. 31
    The CPP Investment Board says the funds it manages for the Canada Pension Plan delivered a 4.5 per cent return, after costs, in the final three months of 2015.

    CPP Fund Delivers 4.5% Return On Investments In Quarter Ended Dec. 31

    Taxi Drivers In Montreal Protest Against Uber By Blockading Airport

    Taxi Drivers In Montreal Protest Against Uber By Blockading Airport
    A statement by the taxi industry said 800 cab drivers and owners were headed to Pierre Elliott Trudeau International Airport.

    Taxi Drivers In Montreal Protest Against Uber By Blockading Airport

    Federal Shortfalls Could Total $90b Over Liberals' First Mandate: Bank Study

    Federal Shortfalls Could Total $90b Over Liberals' First Mandate: Bank Study
    Since coming to power, however, the Liberals have shied away from their election vow to keep annual deficits under $10 billion as the economy continues to falter amid falling commodity prices.

    Federal Shortfalls Could Total $90b Over Liberals' First Mandate: Bank Study

    Alberta Auditor Criticizes Work On Disaster Recovery After 2013 Floods

    Merwan Saher says the government put too great a strain on its resources when it took over all handling of disaster recovery programs last March.

    Alberta Auditor Criticizes Work On Disaster Recovery After 2013 Floods