Close X
Thursday, December 12, 2024
ADVT 
National

Experts say not to rush nixing vaccine passports

Darpan News Desk The Canadian Press, 04 Feb, 2022 03:45 PM
  • Experts say not to rush nixing vaccine passports

As several provinces toy with scrapping their COVID-19 vaccine mandates, medical experts allow it may be time to start reconsidering the policy  but caution against dropping the measure too soon.

Prevalence of cases among both vaccinated and unvaccinated Canadians has led to calls to nix the vaccine passport system by some who question whether the shots make a difference in transmission.

However, Dr. Fahad Razak, an epidemiologist and health policy expert with the University of Toronto, said discarding the policy while hospitalizations are just starting to ease in parts of the country is "premature."

He suggested a "buffer" of several weeks before tossing vaccine passports to help ensure the Omicron variant doesn't cause another rapid spike that could overwhelm a health-care system still precariously dealing with elevated hospital and intensive care admissions, cancelled surgeries and staffing shortages.

"There may be a future time where relaxation is reasonable but ... we're not exactly sure what will happen when you change these policies," Razak said, adding that Ontario is currently seeing peak levels of daily COVID-19 deaths.

"Do it at a time when there is capacity for the system to respond appropriately if there is a rise in cases."

Ontario's top doctor Kieran Moore said Thursday the province needs to "reassess the value" of its vaccine passport system, noting two doses no longer seem to significantly limit the spread of Omicron.

Saskatchewan Premier Scott Moe said earlier this week the vaccination requirement there had "run its course" while Alberta Premier Jason Kenney is expected to announce a firm date next week to scrap his province's passport system, a move he said is likely to happen in the "very near future."

Razak said vaccine passports were implemented with two main goals: to prevent transmission and to keep people out of hospital.

Canada's National Advisory Committee on Immunization has said two doses of mRNA vaccines offer 75 to 80 per cent protection against severe Omicron disease, and a third dose increases that further.

Vaccinated people remain less likely to spread the virus to others because they're less likely to become sick in the first place, experts say. But if protection against infection with two doses has waned substantially, some could argue the two-jab passport does little to stop spread.

Preliminary, pre-print data from Ontario suggests vaccines lose substantial effectiveness against infection from Omicron — dropping from 36 per cent two months after a second dose to zero four months later — but protection increased to more than 60 per cent with a booster. The paper also notes that protection against severe Omicron disease jumps to 95 per cent seven days after a third dose.

Dr. Jeff Kwong, a co-author of the study and an epidemiologist with Public Health Ontario and the Institute for Clinical Evaluation Sciences (ICES), said the findings mirror research from other scientists, but PCR testing limitations made it more difficult for his team to properly evaluate vaccine effectiveness.

Kwong said vaccines are still likely to "reduce transmission, but they can't eliminate (it)."

"If you have 20,000 (vaccinated) people in an arena, even if there's reduced transmission, there still could be significant numbers of transmission events," he said.

The study has not been peer reviewed, but Razak said the findings add to ongoing debate over whether three doses should be the standard for vaccine certificates.

He said that could be "a reasonable way forward," given the third dose's boost in preventing both infection and serious outcomes.

"But people could also say that if they have protection against severe disease (with two doses), should they be compelled to take a third dose to prevent mild illness?" he asked. "I think that is a reasonable question.... It's just not as clear."

Dr. Theresa Tam, Canada's chief public officer of health, said in a news conference Friday she's actively discussing "a whole range of public health measures," including vaccine mandates, with provincial and territorial medical officers.

She said any changes would come from provinces and territories, which know their own epidemiological situations.

"I think what we do need to do going forward as we emerge (from) the Omicron wave is to recognize that this virus is not going to disappear.... We do need to have more longer-term sustained approaches and capacity-building so that we're not in crisis mode all the time as we fight this virus," Tam said.

She added that vaccines remain "extremely important" in reducing serious disease, even though the protection they provide against Omicron infection has decreased.

Dr. Howard Njoo, Canada's deputy chief public health officer, said Friday that booster doses work well to "decrease your risk of infection which in turn, reduce the likelihood of spreading the virus to others."

He added that timing will be an important consideration as provinces start relaxing restrictions.

"Everyone wants public health measures to be loosened, but we've seen with previous waves that there is a balance that needs to be struck," he said. "If you do away with public health measures too quickly, then there's always the risk of creating more hospitalizations, more potential deaths ...

"It's difficult to predict what will happen if we loosen some of the rules at this point."

MORE National ARTICLES

Opening schools a priority, but safety matters

Opening schools a priority, but safety matters
Provincial health officer for British Columbia Dr. Bonnie Henry said in a news conference Tuesday that schools are "not a major source of transmission." But other experts say schools need to take extra care against the highly transmissible Omicron variant.

Opening schools a priority, but safety matters

Eight Prince Rupert, B.C., firefighters isolating

Eight Prince Rupert, B.C., firefighters isolating
B.C.'s provincial health officer Dr. Bonnie Henry warned earlier this week that businesses, schools and health facilities could lose up to a third of their staff due to the rapid spread of the Omicron variant.

Eight Prince Rupert, B.C., firefighters isolating

NDP Leader Jagmeet Singh announces he has become a father of a baby girl

NDP Leader Jagmeet Singh announces he has become a father of a baby girl
NDP Leader Jagmeet Singh says he has become a father for the first time, to a baby daughter. Singh announced today that he and his wife Gurkiran Kaur Sidhu welcomed a baby girl into the world on Monday.

NDP Leader Jagmeet Singh announces he has become a father of a baby girl

O'Toole says unvaccinated must be accommodated

O'Toole says unvaccinated must be accommodated
Trudeau on Wednesday said Canadians are angry at those who refuse to be vaccinated because they are filling up hospital beds, causing cancer treatments and elective surgeries to be put off.    

O'Toole says unvaccinated must be accommodated

Surrey shooting lands female in hospital with serious injuries

Surrey shooting lands female in hospital with serious injuries
Police located the residence where the shooting is believed to have occurred and multiple persons have been detained. The investigation is very early stages however, this appears to be an isolated incident, with no active threat to public safety.

Surrey shooting lands female in hospital with serious injuries

Omicron could boost waning immunity: scientists

Omicron could boost waning immunity: scientists
Tests on around 9,000 donated blood samples from across Canada show that antibodies in the blood which fight the virus declined in October among all age groups, with experts saying the waning immunity is likely to have continued in November and December.

Omicron could boost waning immunity: scientists