Close X
Sunday, January 26, 2025
ADVT 
National

Ex-Pastor Convicted In Wife's Death Secretly Drugged Her, Crown Argues

Darpan News Desk The Canadian Press, 04 Sep, 2019 07:24 PM

    TORONTO - Prosecutors are asking an Ontario judge to rule that a former pastor convicted in the death of his pregnant wife was the one who gave her a sedative before she drowned.

     

    The Crown is making submissions on what the court should deem as a fact in sentencing Philip Grandine, who was found guilty of manslaughter in February in the death of his wife Anna Grandine.

     

    Jurors were told they could convict Philip Grandine if they found he secretly drugged his wife with the anti-anxiety drug lorazepam or provided it to her; or he knew she had taken it and did nothing to stop her from getting in the bath while under its influence.

     

    Now prosecutors say the judge should rule that Philip Grandine surreptitiously administered the medication better known as Ativan to his wife, having stolen it from his workplace with the intention of incapacitating her.

     

    They are also asking the court to find that Anna Grandine, who went by Karissa, did not knowingly consume the drug.

     

    Anna Grandine was 20 weeks pregnant when she died in October 2011, and tests later revealed she had lorazepam in her blood despite never being prescribed it.

     

    Defence lawyers had argued she took the medication herself and either slipped and drowned in the tub or took her own life.

     

    Court heard at trial that Philip Grandine had recently stepped down as pastor after his affair with a parishioner, who was also his wife's friend, was uncovered.

     

    He then began working at a nursing home where he was responsible for distributing and disposing of medication, court heard.

     

    Superior Court Justice Faye McWatt will rule on the facts of the case at a later date, allowing the Crown and defence to make submissions on an appropriate sentence.

     

    This is Philip Grandine's second trial in connection with his wife's death.

     

    In the first trial, on a charge of first-degree murder, he was found guilty of manslaughter and sentenced to 15 years in prison.

     

    The conviction was overturned on appeal, however, after Ontario's highest court found the trial judge had made an error in answering a question from the jury.

     

    A new trial was ordered on the manslaughter charge, precluding prosecutors from arguing Philip Grandine intended to kill his wife.

    MORE National ARTICLES

    Vancouver Police Seek Video Of Early Saturday Morning Stabbing

    Vancouver Police Seek Video Of Early Saturday Morning Stabbing
    An early morning downtown stabbing has sent a 25-year-old man to hospital with serious life-threatening injuries. Police are seeking witnesses, and video from cell phones and dash cams.

    Vancouver Police Seek Video Of Early Saturday Morning Stabbing

    Langley Police Investigating Stabbing Of 32-Yr-Old Man

    Langley Police Investigating Stabbing Of 32-Yr-Old Man
    Shortly after 2:35 am on July 13, 2019, the Langley RCMP received a call from a man reporting he had been stabbed.

    Langley Police Investigating Stabbing Of 32-Yr-Old Man

    Chuckwagon Race Safety Up For Review After Six Horses Die During Stampede Event

    Stampede officials say in a website statement that the horses went down Sunday evening in the eighth race when the right lead horse on the wagon driven by Evan Salmond broke a bone in a hind leg.

    Chuckwagon Race Safety Up For Review After Six Horses Die During Stampede Event

    Search For Missing Quebec Businessman, Son Stretches Into Fifth Day

    Search For Missing Quebec Businessman, Son Stretches Into Fifth Day
    The search stretched into a fifth day for Stephane Roy and his 14-year-old son, who never reached their hometown of Ste-Sophie, Que., last Thursday. They were reported missing the next day.    

    Search For Missing Quebec Businessman, Son Stretches Into Fifth Day

    Evidence Erased By Police Would Have Freed Wrongfully Convicted Man: Defence Lawyer

    Evidence Erased By Police Would Have Freed Wrongfully Convicted Man: Defence Lawyer
    A defence lawyer who fought to free Glen Assoun from a wrongful murder conviction says evidence erased by the Mounties would have helped him win his appeal.    

    Evidence Erased By Police Would Have Freed Wrongfully Convicted Man: Defence Lawyer

    Canadian Is Detained In China On Drug Allegations: Chinese Government

    China's foreign ministry says the recent detention of a Canadian citizen by Chinese authorities is linked to drug allegations against foreign teachers.    

    Canadian Is Detained In China On Drug Allegations: Chinese Government