Close X
Monday, February 17, 2025
ADVT 
National

Environmentalists Reactivate Pesticide Lawsuit Against Federal Government

Darpan News Desk The Canadian Press, 16 Apr, 2015 12:01 PM
  • Environmentalists Reactivate Pesticide Lawsuit Against Federal Government
Environmental groups have revived a lawsuit against the federal government because the Health Department changed its mind about reviewing a pesticide that is banned in Norway but is increasingly common in Canada.
 
The decision to stop the review of a fungicide used on cereal, oilseed and vegetable crops violates the government's own legislation, said Lara Tessoro, a lawyer for Ecojustice, the firm acting for several groups behind the lawsuit.
 
"The duty on the government is to assess all the products containing the ingredient."
 
The lawsuit is over difenoconazole, which is known to be toxic to fish and believed by some scientists to accumulate in increasing amounts in the food chain. The suit was originally filed in 2013 in an attempt to force the government to review 23 different pesticides.
 
The action was put on hold after Ottawa agreed to the reviews. But the Pest Management Regulatory Agency has now pulled back.
 
"The special review ... is no longer required," said a letter from the agency to Ecojustice.
 
Canadian law requires a review for any pesticide banned in a member country of the Organization for Economic Co-operation and Development. Norway, which is a member, has banned difenoconazole.
 
But it is legal to import seeds that have been treated with the pesticide. That's enough, says the government, to remove the requirement for the review.
 
"In Norway, the use of difenoconazole is permitted on treated seeds," a department spokesman wrote in an email. "As Norway permits the use of difenoconazole, it does not 'prohibit all uses' of this product."
 
Tessoro said that's not how the Norwegians see it.
 
"Please note that this does not mean that we still have uses of difenoconazole allowed in Norway," says a letter to Health Canada from Norwegian officials. "It is prohibited to sell, stock, store or use difenoconazole in Norway."
 
Tessoro said Canada has ignored Norway's interpretation of its own law.
 
"Here's Norway telling Canada, 'No, no, don't be misguided here. We do not allow this pesticide to be used in this country.' Canada turned around and said, 'Thanks very much, Norway, but we're going to disagree with how you interpret your own laws.'"
 
She pointed out Canada's position is similar to one urged by the pesticide's manufacturer in a letter to the pest management agency after the review was promised. 
 
Health Canada said it was unable to comment further on a matter before the courts.
 
The Norwegians say their decision was taken as a result of the chemical's "worrisome" toxicology. They say it tends to persist in the environment, concentrate in the food chain and is toxic to aquatic life.
 
Canadian assessments are similar. But in a letter to Ecojustice, the agency says the chemical's risks are well-managed through warnings.
 
"With the existing risk mitigation measures in place on the registered labels, the risks to aquatic species are not expected to be a concern," it says.
 
Ecojustice scientist Elaine MacDonald said difenoconazole is increasingly added to pesticides which some say are behind large die-offs in bee populations. She said the review her group is asking for would force Health Canada to examine all such combined products.
 
"I think it's worthwhile to have another look, evaluate the risk and evaluate the mitigation. That's all we're asking."

MORE National ARTICLES

New Westminster Teen Who Died In Vernon While Rock-Climbing With Friends Identified As Taylor Archer

New Westminster Teen Who Died In Vernon While Rock-Climbing With Friends Identified As Taylor Archer
The BC Coroners Service says Taylor Archer of New Westminster, B.C., was climbing near the King Edward access logging area with some friends.

New Westminster Teen Who Died In Vernon While Rock-Climbing With Friends Identified As Taylor Archer

2 Pilots From Missing B.C. Plane Found Dead Amid Wreckage Near Mt. Seymour: Official

2 Pilots From Missing B.C. Plane Found Dead Amid Wreckage Near Mt. Seymour: Official
VANCOUVER — Search and rescue crews have found the bodies of two pilots in and around the wreckage of a cargo plane that crashed in heavily treed mountains north of Vancouver. 

2 Pilots From Missing B.C. Plane Found Dead Amid Wreckage Near Mt. Seymour: Official

B.C. Man Alleging 'false Imprisonment' In China To Get Day In Canadian Court

B.C. Man Alleging 'false Imprisonment' In China To Get Day In Canadian Court
VANCOUVER — A British Columbia man has won the right to sue a company in a Canadian court that he alleges conspired with Chinese authorities to force him to spend years behind bars in China.

B.C. Man Alleging 'false Imprisonment' In China To Get Day In Canadian Court

Conservatives Fuel Opposition To Ontario's Sex-Ed Curriculum: Liberal Minister

Conservatives Fuel Opposition To Ontario's Sex-Ed Curriculum: Liberal Minister
TORONTO — Conservative groups are fuelling the vocal opposition to Ontario's new sex-education curriculum, Liberal Education Minister Liz Sandals said Tuesday as thousands of people protested outside the legislature.

Conservatives Fuel Opposition To Ontario's Sex-Ed Curriculum: Liberal Minister

Justin Trudeau Might Be Open To Forming Coalition With NDP, But Not With Mulcair As Leader

Justin Trudeau Might Be Open To Forming Coalition With NDP, But Not With Mulcair As Leader
OTTAWA — Liberal Leader Justin Trudeau says he would "maybe" be more open to the idea of forming a coalition with the NDP if Tom Mulcair was not running the party.

Justin Trudeau Might Be Open To Forming Coalition With NDP, But Not With Mulcair As Leader

B.C. 'Hosed' In Coquitlam Land Sale To Liberal Donor

B.C. 'Hosed' In Coquitlam Land Sale To Liberal Donor
NDP justice critic Mike Farnworth said British Columbians were "hosed" when the government sold about 150 hectares of property in Coquitlam for $85 million when the land was appraised at $128 million.

B.C. 'Hosed' In Coquitlam Land Sale To Liberal Donor