Close X
Monday, October 14, 2024
ADVT 
National

Edmonton Judge To Decide On Mistrial In Travis Vader Murder Case Oct. 31.

The Canadian Press, 03 Oct, 2016 12:15 PM
    EDMONTON — An Edmonton judge says he will decide at the end of the month whether to declare a mistrial for a man he found guilty of murdering two seniors.
     
    Two weeks ago, Justice Denny Thomas found Travis Vader guilty of second-degree murder in the deaths of Lyle and Marie McCann whose bodies have never been found.
     
    But he used an unconstitutional section of the Criminal Code to reach his verdict.
     
    Vader's defence lawyer applied for a mistrial, something the Crown says it opposes.
     
    Thomas has instructed both sides to submit written arguments by Oct. 19 so that he can make a decision on Oct. 31. 
     
    The McCanns, both in their late 70s, disappeared in 2010 after setting out on a camping trip to British Columbia.
     
    Thomas said in his verdict that Vader was a desperate drug addict who came across the couple in their motorhome and shot them during a robbery.
     
    Law professors say the verdict isn't likely to stand and the trial could be reopened.
     
    "I think no matter which road you go down, it ends up in a manslaughter verdict," says Peter Sankoff, a law professor at the University of Alberta.
     
    "It just seems to me to be the most likely option."
     
    Section 230 of the Criminal Code, declared unconstitutional in 1990 by the Supreme Court, allowed for a second-degree murder verdict if a killing occurred during the commission of another crime, such as robbery. Otherwise, the killing must be intentional for that verdict to be reached.
     
    Thomas said in his ruling that he found no evidence Vader intended to kill the McCanns.
     
    David Tanovich, a law professor at the University of Windsor, says a new trial wouldn't be "in the interest of justice" since there is a valid finding for manslaughter in the case.
     
    The judge's use of Section 230 came as a "shocker", Tanovich adds, saying no judge has used the section before in a verdict.

    MORE National ARTICLES

    Canadians Frustrated Over Senate Amendments To Assisted Dying Bill, Says Ambrose

    Senators voted 41-30 on Wednesday to amend Bill C-14, to allow suffering patients who are not near death to seek medical help to end their lives.

    Canadians Frustrated Over Senate Amendments To Assisted Dying Bill, Says Ambrose

    Ontario Petting Zoo Under Investigation Says Its Kangaroo Is Healthy

    An Ontario petting zoo under investigation by animal welfare authorities for leaving a kangaroo and other animals in the sun without shade at a recent festival north of Toronto says it takes exceptional care of all its animals.

    Ontario Petting Zoo Under Investigation Says Its Kangaroo Is Healthy

    Gender Diversity Proposal Rejected By Shareholders Of Tim Hortons Parent Company

    Gender Diversity Proposal Rejected By Shareholders Of Tim Hortons Parent Company
    OAKVILLE, Ont. — A proposal to create a formal diversity policy at the parent company of Tim Hortons and Burger King aimed at increasing the number of women on its all-male board of directors has been rejected.

    Gender Diversity Proposal Rejected By Shareholders Of Tim Hortons Parent Company

    Supreme Court Won't Hear Appeal Over A Will Leaving Money To Hate Group

    Supreme Court Won't Hear Appeal Over A Will Leaving Money To Hate Group
    When he died in 2004, Harry Robert McCorkill left valuable possessions to the National Alliance, a West Virginia-based racist organization.

    Supreme Court Won't Hear Appeal Over A Will Leaving Money To Hate Group

    U.S. Production Rise Expected To Dent Canadian Natural Gas Growth

    U.S. Production Rise Expected To Dent Canadian Natural Gas Growth
    CALGARY — The National Energy Board predicts that conditions will worsen for Canada's struggling natural gas producers. It says Canadian natural gas output will decline through 2018 as production rises in the United States.

    U.S. Production Rise Expected To Dent Canadian Natural Gas Growth

    No Decision Given: Gay Rodeo Cancelled In Southern Alberta

    No Decision Given: Gay Rodeo Cancelled In Southern Alberta
    STRATHMORE, Alta. — What's billed as Canada's largest gay rodeo has been cancelled in southern Alberta.

    No Decision Given: Gay Rodeo Cancelled In Southern Alberta