Close X
Sunday, November 24, 2024
ADVT 
National

Economists question new August job numbers after last month's botched effort

Steve Rennie, Darpan, 05 Sep, 2014 12:40 PM
    OTTAWA - Canada's economy unexpectedly shed jobs in August due to heavy losses in the private sector, raising the eyebrows of economists who widely expected a modest gain in Statistics Canada's flagship monthly report.
     
    The national statistical agency reported Friday that the economy lost 11,000 mostly part-time jobs in August, with the unemployment rate remaining unchanged from the previous month at 7.0 per cent. Economists had expected a net gain of about 10,000 jobs.
     
    A whopping loss of 112,000 jobs in the private sector was only partly offset by more people turning to self-employment and the continued delivery of jobs in the public sector.
     
    But some economists, uneasy after Statistics Canada badly botched its July job numbers, raised concerns about the latest figures.
     
    The country's national number-cruncher was forced to issue a major correction to its employment survey last month after wrongly reporting that the economy gained a paltry 200 jobs in July. That number, Canadians found out a week later, was actually supposed to be 42,000. Statistics Canada blamed a computer error.
     
    This time around, some economists were skeptical about the staggering job losses in the private sector and equally surprising gains in the number of self-employed people.
     
    "Guess what? We again advise clients to be very careful with the Canadian jobs numbers," Scotiabank economists Derek Holt and Dov Zigler wrote in a note to clients.
     
    They pointed out there has never been a bigger month-on-month rise in the number of self-employed people, or drop in private-sector jobs, since Statistics Canada started the labour force survey back in 1976. That those record-level monthly gains and losses just happened to almost cancel each other out in the August jobs' report seemed "very fishy" to the Scotiabank economists.
     
    "What an utterly fascinating pair of coincidences," wrote Holt and Zigler.
     
     
    "A data quality/sampling issue may be in play again here as I just can't believe such volatility in either number."
     
    In response, Statistics Canada said it does not comment "on the opinions or comments made by individuals outside of the agency."
     
    Finance Minister Joe Oliver replied with a terse "yes, I am" when asked Friday if he is still confident in the quality of Statistics Canada's data.
     
    Still, last month's statistical snafu has only served to amplify the concerns held by some economists about what they perceive to be a great degree of volatility from one month's job numbers to the next. Some now prefer to look at averages over three, six and 12 months, rather than at the latest monthly job numbers.
     
    The Canadian dollar was down slightly Friday in response to the weak job numbers.
     
    "After a string of solid economic reports, Canadian employment delivered yet another shocker, with no computer error to blame this time," CIBC chief economist Avery Shenfeld said.
     
    "All told, soft numbers that will at least take a bit of a shine off what has been an improving picture for Canada, particularly given softer than expected readings today out of the U.S."
     
    Employment rose in Nova Scotia and New Brunswick, but fell in Newfoundland and Labrador and Alberta — which, to one economist at least, was a sign that Canada's economy struggled to churn out jobs.
     
    "The fact that private sector payrolls are unchanged from a year ago, and now even Alberta appears to be cooling a tad,tells us all we need to know about the sluggish state of Canada's job market," said Doug Porter, chief economist with BMO Capital Markets.
     
    "The offset is that productivity is now stepping into the void, and helping keep overall economic growth on track."
     
     
    Canada's gross domestic product is still on track to grow more in 2014 than it has in the past two years, added Porter, who says "productivity is what circles that square."
     
    That puts no added pressure on Bank of Canada governor Stephen Poloz to tinker with interest rates.
     
    On Wednesday, the central bank held its key interest rate steady at one per cent, indicating it does not foresee enough of a change in Canada's economic fortunes to adjust the rate from the same level it has held for the last four years.

    MORE National ARTICLES

    Canada Post Earns Profit, Gets Boost From Parcels And Lower Pension Costs

    Canada Post Earns Profit, Gets Boost From Parcels And Lower Pension Costs
    OTTAWA - The Canada Post Group of Companies reported Wednesday a net profit of $67 million in the second quarter, boosted by growth in its parcel delivery business and lower pension costs

    Canada Post Earns Profit, Gets Boost From Parcels And Lower Pension Costs

    Missing For 8 Days: RCMP Find 1 Canoeist Dead, 1 Survivor In North Saskatchewan

    Missing For 8 Days: RCMP Find 1 Canoeist Dead, 1 Survivor In North Saskatchewan
    PINEHOUSE LAKE, Sask. - RCMP in northern Saskatchewan have rescued a woman who spent eight days in the wilderness after a canoeing accident that killed her husband.

    Missing For 8 Days: RCMP Find 1 Canoeist Dead, 1 Survivor In North Saskatchewan

    Amid Reports Of Adding Teams, NHL Remains Status Quo On Expansion

    Amid Reports Of Adding Teams, NHL Remains Status Quo On Expansion
    TORONTO - NHL expansion is likely coming in the near future, though the league hasn't committed to any official plan just yet.

    Amid Reports Of Adding Teams, NHL Remains Status Quo On Expansion

    Museum Of Vancouver Exhibit To Highlight 1940s, '50s Fashion Trends

    Museum Of Vancouver Exhibit To Highlight 1940s, '50s Fashion Trends
    VANCOUVER - The Museum of Vancouver is planning to spotlight fashion trends of the 1940s and '50s in an exhibition opening next month.

    Museum Of Vancouver Exhibit To Highlight 1940s, '50s Fashion Trends

    University Professor In Kamloops, B.C., Pleads Guilty To Assaulting Wife

    University Professor In Kamloops, B.C., Pleads Guilty To Assaulting Wife
    KAMLOOPS, B.C. - A university professor who also serves as president of the Kamloops Child Development Society has pleaded guilty to assaulting his wife.

    University Professor In Kamloops, B.C., Pleads Guilty To Assaulting Wife

    Paws Get New Posting: Slain RCMP Officer's Police Dog To Return To Work Soon

    Paws Get New Posting: Slain RCMP Officer's Police Dog To Return To Work Soon
    INNISFAIL, Alta. - A police dog who tugged at heartstrings across the country when he rose on his hind legs at his slain partner's funeral to sniff his Stetson is going back to work.

    Paws Get New Posting: Slain RCMP Officer's Police Dog To Return To Work Soon