Close X
Monday, November 11, 2024
ADVT 
National

Documents: PM warned about 'build back better'

Darpan News Desk The Canadian Press, 25 Feb, 2022 11:16 AM
  • Documents: PM warned about 'build back better'

OTTAWA - Newly released documents show Prime Minister Justin Trudeau was given warnings about the complexity of plans to "build back better" from the pandemic that could lead to economic uncertainty.

The idea of strengthening economic shortfalls unearthed by the pandemic has become a rallying cry for Canada and many of its allies, such as the United States.

While there is a heavy focus on strengthening battered supply chains and building domestic capacity to produce essential goods, "build back better" also aims to address digital and green economic shifts accelerated by the pandemic.

The prime minister's briefing binder notes that governments looking to "build back better" could create "uncertainty about rule and standards, create market distortions, and generate less of an even playing field."

The document also highlights the combined effect of higher government debt loads, inflation and rising interest rates that could hinder "build back better" efforts.

The documents were released to The Canadian Press under the Access to Information Act, just ahead of Friday's closure of consultations on this year's federal budget.

Finance Minister Chrystia Freeland is being asked to spend on all manner of requests laid out in some 500 submissions to the House of Commons finance committee, that show at least over $300 billion in specific asks.

Billions more are hinted at in submissions that ask for significant, though not specific, funding for various initiatives.

Several submissions ask the government to rein in the deficit, which the Finance Department projects to be $58.4 billion for the fiscal year that starts in April before any new spending promise in the budget.

There are also requests to cut billions in spending on things like a national child care system, or increase corporate tax rates to boost revenues and to deal with a debt forecasted to hit $1.2 trillion this fiscal year.

Trudeau was told higher debt levels will generally constrain governments' ability in "addressing social priorities and responding to future crises."

The Business Council of Canada, which represents the country's largest employers, is among the groups urging caution on spending plans, saying anything that doesn't help with long-term growth could hurt Canadians by fuelling already high inflation.

When it comes to "build back better," the council suggested working in even closer lockstep with the United States to prevent protectionist policies that have percolated with greater intensity after protesters blockaded key border crossings.

The economy, by most metrics, is also running at capacity. Too much spending in the near-term could add fuel to headline inflation rates that are at three-decade highs.

"Fiscal actions — real or perceived — that stoke inflationary pressures could make matters worse," said Rebekah Young, Scotiabank's director of fiscal and provincial economics.

"Lower income households tend to feel the effects more so than higher income households, so caution is warranted in cloaking further stimulus measures in 'affordability' terms."

When Trudeau received his briefing binder from the Privy Council Office, the Bank of Canada was expected to start raising its trendsetting interest rate this year to combat inflation rates that had steadily risen.

"The potential for higher inflation and interest rates would also be unfavourable to large-scale investments, perhaps especially in the type of projects envisioned in a green energy transition," officials wrote in the document.

A plan to prod large-scale investments and long-term growth is not easy to craft because of how comprehensive and reliant it must be on businesses and allies like the United States, said Robert Asselin, the Business Council of Canada's senior vice-president of policy.

He said the government needs to consider more long-term spending ideas, lest it focus too much on the near-term and fuel inflationary pressures.

"It could put the electorate in a place where this government would not be seen as being responsive, either on inflation or on growth coming out of the pandemic, which I think would put this government in a very difficult situation," said Asselin, Trudeau's former budget chief.

Young said there are other actions the government could take in the budget that don't require new spending, such as tax and regulatory reforms that sprinkle the pre-budget submissions to the Commons finance committee.

A broad spending review, also asked for by several groups, could better prioritize public funds and prod business investment needed to meet the government's goals to build back better, Young said.

"It is now up to policy-makers to foster a credible and growth-friendly policy landscape ahead," she said, adding there is no shortage of uncertainty at present and government actions shouldn't be part of that.

 

MORE National ARTICLES

Canada to match Red Cross donations for Ukraine

Canada to match Red Cross donations for Ukraine
The campaign, which is to begin today and run until March 18, will see the government match donations by Canadians dollar for dollar to a maximum of $10 million, says a senior government official who spoke on the condition of anonymity to discuss matters not yet public.    

Canada to match Red Cross donations for Ukraine

Canada's pandemic future still uncertain, Tam says

Canada's pandemic future still uncertain, Tam says
Dr. Theresa Tam says she hopes Canada is past the pandemic crisis and is now in a transition phase, headed toward recovery. She says Canada must still be ready to bring some public health measures back if cases begin to shoot up again.

Canada's pandemic future still uncertain, Tam says

B.C. premier to make swearing-in announcement

B.C. premier to make swearing-in announcement
A statement from the premier's office provides few details about the nature of the announcement other than to confirm Horgan will be available to answer questions after the swearing-in.

B.C. premier to make swearing-in announcement

Suspect enters fast food restaurant in Surrey and takes off with cash register

Suspect enters fast food restaurant in Surrey and takes off with cash register
Staff from the restaurant immediately called 911, as they observed the suspect depart and noted his direction of travel. The suspect allegedly stopped and threatened the staff members with a weapon.

Suspect enters fast food restaurant in Surrey and takes off with cash register

Coquitlam stabbing victim identified

Coquitlam stabbing victim identified
To further the investigation, the victim has been identified as 66-year-old Terry Miller of Coquitlam. There was a second victim, also stabbed, but is recovering. 

Coquitlam stabbing victim identified

B.C. cabinet in line for 'pay raise': Opposition

B.C. cabinet in line for 'pay raise': Opposition
Horgan's annual salary is about $211,000 a year, while cabinet ministers are paid about $167,000, but the 10 per cent that is withheld is only on the portion of their incomes that relate to their cabinet positions.

B.C. cabinet in line for 'pay raise': Opposition

PrevNext