Close X
Tuesday, November 19, 2024
ADVT 
National

Doctor Fights Finding She Sexually Abused Woman, And Loss Of Medical Licence

Darpan News Desk The Canadian Press, 08 Dec, 2016 01:36 PM
    TORONTO — Stripping a doctor of her medical licence for sexually abusing a female patient was unfair, an Ontario court heard Thursday.
     
    In making its decision, the disciplinary committee ignored evidence that the relationship between Dr. Mary McIntyre and the woman was over when the sexual conduct occurred, court heard.
     
    Defence lawyer Eli Lederman made much of the fact that the committee of the College of Physicians and Surgeons of Ontario had refused to allow a letter written by the patient to be entered as evidence.
     
    The letter, apparently, had been written before McIntyre and the patient had a "romantic kiss" in November or December 2010, the crux of the sexual abuse finding.
     
    "I am informing you that you are no longer to be my physician," Lederman quoted the letter as saying.
     
    However, neither the patient nor McIntyre testified and there was nothing to show what became of the letter.
     
    McIntyre, now 57, who practised in Chatham, Ont., admitted in July last year to numerous acts of professional misconduct related, among other things, to improper record keeping, not responding to patient-care concerns, and being rude to them.
     
    The committee also faulted McIntyre for having a close friendship with a vulnerable man that became sexual after their doctor-patient relationship ended.
     
    McIntyre is now only fighting the finding she sexually abused the woman, known as Patient Y, and her licence revocation.
     
    Lederman took issue with the prosecutor's closing submission that there had been no evidence the doctor-patient relationship with Patient Y was over when the kiss occurred given the letter.
     
    "They either needed to abandon their claim that this amounted to sexual abuse with the kissing, or, at the very least, they should have said nothing at all," Lederman said.
     
    In addition, the refusal by the panel to allow the letter as evidence at the last minute led to a miscarriage of justice, he said.
     
    The justices, who reserved their decision, clearly had difficulty swallowing the defence contention.
     
    "Let's assume we don't think the prosecutor did anything improper, would you pack your bags and leave now?" Justice Anne Malloy asked at one point.
     
    In her submissions, college lawyer Amy Block said the case didn't turn on a single kiss or when it occurred. McIntyre had a long-term "intimate" relationship with a patient who had been hospitalized involuntarily several times for mental-health issues, Block said.
     
    Other evidence — in part from a close relative of the doctor's — was that Patient Y was immersed in McIntyre's family, the pair socialized and travelled together, and had a joint bank account.
     
    "They shared a bed together, with evidence of one of them wearing nothing but a towel," Block said. "Sitting naked on a bed with a patient is enough."
     
    The letter by itself would not have changed the disciplinary finding, Block said. For one thing, it was not determinative that the doctor-patient relationship had ended. The letter also referenced McIntyre's threat to commit Patient Y to hospital, court heard.
     
    "There's some kind of serious manipulation of a patient happening," Block said.
     
    While the panel found a licence suspension might otherwise have been appropriate, the relationship with Patient Y changed the situation.
     
    "The kiss was only one aspect of this abusive relationship," the committee found. "Dr. McIntyre took advantage of the power imbalance in her physician-patient relationship to become involved with Patient Y socially, financially and sexually."
     
    Lederman's co-counsel, Robert Trenker, said even if the sexual-abuse allegation stood, revocation of McIntyre's licence was far too harsh.

    MORE National ARTICLES

    Spill Response Base Planned For Vancouver Harbour If Trans Mountain Proceeds

    The federal government is set to make a decision on the $6.8-billion Alberta-to-B.C. pipeline expansion in December, but Kinder Morgan Canada's proposal already faces several court challenges, including one filed by the City of Vancouver.-

    Spill Response Base Planned For Vancouver Harbour If Trans Mountain Proceeds

    Calgary Neighbourhood Tells Tree Planters To Make Like A Tree And Leaf

    Calgary Neighbourhood Tells Tree Planters To Make Like A Tree And Leaf
    CALGARY — Protests over trees usually happen when they're being cut down, but some Calgary residents are upset the city has planted saplings in a park across from their homes.

    Calgary Neighbourhood Tells Tree Planters To Make Like A Tree And Leaf

    Surrey Business Robbery Suspect Arrested And Charged Following Tips

    Surrey Business Robbery Suspect Arrested And Charged Following Tips
    Surrey RCMP advises that a female suspect has now been arrested and charged for robbery on May 28th thanks to help from the public and media.

    Surrey Business Robbery Suspect Arrested And Charged Following Tips

    Winnipeg Woman Accused Of Concealing Infant Remains Has Fraud Charge Dropped

    Winnipeg Woman Accused Of Concealing Infant Remains Has Fraud Charge Dropped
    WINNIPEG — A Winnipeg woman accused of hiding the remains of six infants in a storage locker has had an unrelated charge against her stayed.

    Winnipeg Woman Accused Of Concealing Infant Remains Has Fraud Charge Dropped

    'She's Our Child:' Family's Tearful Plea For Help To Find Missing Manitoba Woman

    'She's Our Child:' Family's Tearful Plea For Help To Find Missing Manitoba Woman
    Christine Wood, who is 21, was with her mother and father in Winnipeg on Aug. 19 to accompany a relative to a medical appointment.

    'She's Our Child:' Family's Tearful Plea For Help To Find Missing Manitoba Woman

    Montreal Taxi Drivers Planning To Sue City For The Right To Wear Black Jeans

    Montreal Taxi Drivers Planning To Sue City For The Right To Wear Black Jeans
    A group of Montreal taxi drivers is taking the city to court over the right to wear black jeans on the job.

    Montreal Taxi Drivers Planning To Sue City For The Right To Wear Black Jeans