Close X
Wednesday, September 25, 2024
ADVT 
National

DND to review policy forcing wounded out of military before collecting pension

The Canadian Press , 14 Oct, 2014 02:24 PM
    OTTAWA - Almost a year after facing a barrage of bad publicity, National Defence is having another look at a policy that ended the careers of gravely injured soldiers who wanted to remain in uniform.
     
    Defence Minister Rob Nicholson has told a House of Commons committee that a working group was set up last summer to study the military's universality of service rule, which has been used as a pretext to release wounded combat veterans, many of them with post-traumatic stress.
     
    At stake is the delicate balance between an individual's desire to serve and the need for troops to be fit enough to deploy for operations both at home and abroad, Nicholson said in a seven-page letter to Commons defence committee.
     
    "This working group is examining how the policy can be best applied to retain individuals who are willing and able to serve, while also ensuring the necessary availability of all Canadian Armed Forces personnel to perform their lawful military service," he said. 
     
    "Once this work is complete, the working group will provide recommendations to the chief of military personnel."
     
    The defence committee conducted a study of care for ill and injured soldiers, and recommended last June that the policy be examined in light of complaints from soldiers who were summarily dismissed after pleading to remain.
     
    Nicholson's response to the committee's overall report was quietly tabled in Parliament late last week.
     
    He said the working group carrying out the study will also examine the impact of the policy on the military pension system. Many ex-soldiers told The Canadian Press last year that they were being released before they qualified for an unrestricted pension.
     
    At the time, Nicholson told the Commons that no one was being forced out and that the department worked with every individual to prepare them for the transition to civilian life.
     
    But he was contradicted by troops, who said despite the minister's assurances, they had been shown the door on a medical release even though they had begged to retrain for other jobs within the military. 
     
    Some were let go just shy of hitting the 10-year mark, when they would qualify for a fully-indexed pension. Prior to that, soldiers are only eligible for a return of their contributions.
     
    Many said the medical release, especially with a PTSD designation, limited their career prospects in the civilian world.
     
    Retired corporal David Hawkins, one of the soldiers who took on the government last year, said he was pleased to hear about the review, but wondered what took so long.
     
    Hawkins said the policy needn't be completely overhauled. Instead, it should be made flexible enough to accommodate individuals, the way the military did following both world wars when the wounded, including amputees, were allowed to keep serving.
     
    "There's always work and they don't have to go overseas," Hawkins said.
     
    "We don't send 100 per cent of our people overseas at the same time. There's always people back home who have to do the administrative (work). When they say (the wounded) would be useless, that's untrue."
     
    The threat of being kicked out is preventing some of his friends with post-traumatic stress from coming forward to seek treatment, he added.
     
    That backs up observations from former military ombudsman Pierre Daigle, who warned that the inflexibility of the policy may actually be causing harm.
     
    Given the exceptions made following previous, much larger wars, it's difficult to fathom why the policy is so strict and unforgiving, said NDP defence critic Jack Harris.
     
    "There's a rigidity there that just seems unnecessary and they can't accept the fact that not everybody is necessary to be put into battle," he said.
     
    Harris said he's skeptical the working group will actually recommend changes.

    MORE National ARTICLES

    Dozens Sleep Outside Manitoba Legislature To Press For Missing Women Inquiry

    Dozens Sleep Outside Manitoba Legislature To Press For Missing Women Inquiry
    WINNIPEG - The death of a 15-year-old girl has prompted dozens of people to camp in the shadow of Manitoba's legislature for days, calling for an inquiry into missing and murdered aboriginal women.

    Dozens Sleep Outside Manitoba Legislature To Press For Missing Women Inquiry

    Ottawa Announces $10.8m To Continue Red Cross Rapid Emergency Response

    VANCOUVER - The federal government has announced $10.8 million to continue a program that allows the Canadian Red Cross to quickly distribute emergency supplies abroad.

    Ottawa Announces $10.8m To Continue Red Cross Rapid Emergency Response

    Parties Struggle For Power, Support in Unprecedented B.C. Teachers' Strike

    Parties Struggle For Power, Support in Unprecedented B.C. Teachers' Strike
    Labour experts say the B.C. teachers' strike is sailing into uncharted waters with no resolution on the horizon for the dispute that has delayed the start of the school year for the first time in provincial history.

    Parties Struggle For Power, Support in Unprecedented B.C. Teachers' Strike

    Bus carrying wedding guests swept away in Kashmir; 50 missing

    Bus carrying wedding guests swept away in Kashmir; 50 missing
    SRINAGAR, India - A bus carrying more than 50 wedding guests was swept away by a flooded stream Thursday in the Indian portion of Kashmir, and all but five of the passengers were missing, officials said.

    Bus carrying wedding guests swept away in Kashmir; 50 missing

    RIP: Comedian Joan Rivers Dead At 81

    RIP: Comedian Joan Rivers Dead At 81
    Joan Rivers, the raucous, acid-tongued comedian who crashed the male-dominated realm of late-night talk shows and turned Hollywood red carpets into danger zones for badly dressed celebrities, died Thursday. She was 81.

    RIP: Comedian Joan Rivers Dead At 81

    Long Road Back: Lulay set to start at quarterback for Lions against Redblacks

    Long Road Back: Lulay set to start at quarterback for Lions against Redblacks
    SURREY, B.C. - Travis Lulay always knew he would be back under centre for the B.C. Lions.

    Long Road Back: Lulay set to start at quarterback for Lions against Redblacks