Close X
Sunday, November 17, 2024
ADVT 
National

CSIS Operations Under C-51 With Foreign Partners Raise Accountability Concerns

Darpan News Desk The Canadian Press, 25 Oct, 2015 01:10 PM
  • CSIS Operations Under C-51 With Foreign Partners Raise Accountability Concerns
OTTAWA — Internal government notes say the Canadian Security Intelligence Service is likely to team up with "trusted allies," such as the American CIA and Britain's MI6, on overseas operations to derail threats — plans that underscore concerns about CSIS accountability under new security legislation.
 
The omnibus bill known as C-51 allows CSIS to engage in joint "disruption" efforts abroad — including covert actions that break foreign laws — something the spy service previously had no authority to do, according to the government notes.
 
"In the international context, CSIS would likely first seek avenues to work jointly with partners in the local jurisdiction or trusted allies before engaging in independent action," the notes say.
 
"In the past, CSIS has been invited to participate in joint operations abroad to disrupt threats or to provide assistance to allies, but has had no mandate to do so."
 
CSIS's new threat disruption mandate — perhaps the most contentious element of the legislation that received royal assent in June — could include surreptitious meddling with websites, cancelling airline reservations, disabling a car or myriad other schemes.
 
The spy service would be allowed to engage in disruption activities that violate the Charter of Rights and Freedoms as long as a judge sanctions them, a measure critics say perverts the role of the judiciary.
 
CSIS would co-ordinate threat disruption activity with other agencies such as the RCMP, Canada Border Services Agency and Foreign Affairs, and could use its statutory mandate to enlist the technical expertise of the Communications Security Establishment, Canada's electronic spy agency, the government notes say.
 
However, the Security Intelligence Review Committee, the watchdog known as SIRC that keeps an eye on CSIS, is limited to examining the spy service alone.
 
The notion of CSIS teaming up with foreign and domestic partners to derail threats raises concerns about SIRC's ability to "follow the thread" and look at the entire operation, said University of Ottawa law professor Craig Forcese, who obtained the government notes under the Access to Information Act.
 
"SIRC is stovepiped to CSIS — that is, it can only look at what CSIS does, not at what any partner might do," said Forcese, co-author of "False Security," a book that extensively critiques C-51, calling it a squandered opportunity.
 
As the scale and scope of joint operations expand, the prospect of "gaps in the accountability system" increases apace, he added.
 
 
Josh Paterson, executive director of the British Columbia Civil Liberties Association, said SIRC, as presently constituted and resourced, "is totally inadequate" for the task of reviewing CSIS activities abroad.  "When actions are mixed together with foreign agencies, the problem is more thorny."
 
SIRC will need to "tool up its capacity" to review foreign operations, Forcese said. "That will require more money and perhaps different skills — including language skills. SIRC is on record noting that reviews of foreign operations are particularly resource intensive."
 
The new Liberal government has indicated it will revamp "problematic elements" of C-51, for instance by ensuring all CSIS warrants respect the charter. It also plans to create a security-cleared committee of parliamentarians who could see any relevant information held by federal agencies.
 
A parliamentary committee, "while not insignificant," can't do all the work, said Paterson, whose organization has joined Canadian Journalists for Free Expression in a court challenge of C-51's constitutionality.
 
Existing intelligence watchdogs "need to be strengthened and made able to deal with inter-agency activities," he said.
 
Forcese agrees, saying he hopes "the Liberal government understands this, and won't confine its accountability reform to simply creating a special security parliamentary committee."

MORE National ARTICLES

Statistics Canada Says Wholesale Sales Unchanged In July At $55.4Billion

Economists had expected a gain of 0.7 per cent, according to Thomson Reuters.

Statistics Canada Says Wholesale Sales Unchanged In July At $55.4Billion

Darpan's 6th Annual Extraordinary Achievement Awards Winner Announced In A Glitzy Gala

Darpan's 6th Annual Extraordinary Achievement Awards Winner Announced In A Glitzy Gala
Ten amazing individuals from the South Asian community were recognized for their extraordinary achievements and for reflecting their heritage in a remarkable way.

Darpan's 6th Annual Extraordinary Achievement Awards Winner Announced In A Glitzy Gala

Saskatchewan Premier Brad Wall Urges Oil Industry To Fight Celebrity Critics With 'Facts'

Brad Wall told the Canadian Energy Pipeline Association there is a growing, vocal minority that want the industry shut down completely and they are influencing policy-makers.

Saskatchewan Premier Brad Wall Urges Oil Industry To Fight Celebrity Critics With 'Facts'

Damaged Dewdney Bridge Near Mission Closed To Traffic After Massive Crack Cause The Span To Dip

Damaged Dewdney Bridge Near Mission Closed To Traffic After Massive Crack Cause The Span To Dip
The Dewdney Slough Bridge is located about eight kilometres east of the community of Mission.

Damaged Dewdney Bridge Near Mission Closed To Traffic After Massive Crack Cause The Span To Dip

Swearing, Jabbing And Support From The Dead, All In One Strange Winnipeg Election Race

Swearing, Jabbing And Support From The Dead, All In One Strange Winnipeg Election Race
Accusations of poking and swearing, along with invocations of dead political icons and a threatened lawsuit, are making the election race in Winnipeg Centre one of the strangest in the country.

Swearing, Jabbing And Support From The Dead, All In One Strange Winnipeg Election Race

Cineplex Buying Into Future Of Esports, Forming Competitive Video-Game League

The operator of Canada's largest chain of movie theatres is moving further into the world of competitive electronic gaming, announcing some US$15 million in investments on Thursday.

Cineplex Buying Into Future Of Esports, Forming Competitive Video-Game League