Close X
Saturday, November 23, 2024
ADVT 
National

Crown Corporation Immune From Taxation, But Still Might Have To Pay GST: Court

Darpan News Desk The Canadian Press, 13 Dec, 2019 10:10 PM

    OTTAWA - The B.C. agency responsible for managing public-sector pension plan investments is constitutionally immune from remitting goods-and-services taxes related to those portfolios, the Supreme Court of Canada has decided.

     

    However, the top court ruled Friday the British Columbia Investment Management Corporation, a Crown agency, still might be on the hook for GST payments to the federal government due to taxation agreements between B.C. and Ottawa.

     

    The management corporation had been ordered to pay almost $40.5 million in GST, plus interest and penalties, for delivering investment-management services for pooled portfolios.

     

    The corporation then sought a declaration from the Supreme Court of British Columbia that it was immune from federal excise taxes.

     

    A B.C. judge ruled in 2016 that the federal government could not order the corporation to remit the GST on the basis that, as an agent of the provincial Crown, it enjoyed the same immunity from federal taxes as the province.

     

    However, the judge also found the corporation was bound by two taxation agreements between B.C. and the federal government that may require the Crown agency to collect and remit certain taxes.

     

    The ruling was upheld last year by the B.C. Court of Appeal.

     

    In its 6-1 decision Friday, the Supreme Court of Canada affirmed the lower-court decisions.

     

    In writing for the majority, Justice Andromache Karakatsanis noted intergovernmental immunity from taxation grants each level of government "operational space" to govern without interference. "It also prevents one group of elected representatives from dictating how another legislative body should allocate the financial resources under its control."

     

    She added that by entering into the agreements with Ottawa, "the provincial Crown chose to pay taxes for which it would not otherwise have been liable."

     

    But even after the high court ruling the nature of any specific obligations the corporation might have under the taxation agreements remained unclear, since those questions went beyond the scope of the decision.

     

    MORE National ARTICLES

    New Health Sciences Centre Breaks Ground At BCIT

    New Health Sciences Centre Breaks Ground At BCIT
    The centre will provide the simulated health-care environments that are a critical component of health-sciences education.

    New Health Sciences Centre Breaks Ground At BCIT

    VIDEO: Reindeer Bus Lights Up Metro Vancouver Streets

    The Reindeer Bus rolls into service today, continuing a beloved holiday tradition in Metro Vancouver.

    VIDEO: Reindeer Bus Lights Up Metro Vancouver Streets

    Delta Police Recover $140,000 Worth Of Stolen Property From Ladner Home

    Delta Police Recover $140,000 Worth Of Stolen Property From Ladner Home
    Police executed a search warrant at a residence in the 4600 block of 51st street, with the assistance of the Lower Mainland District Emergency Response Team. Two adults were taken into custody and later released on a promise to appear in February 2020.  

    Delta Police Recover $140,000 Worth Of Stolen Property From Ladner Home

    Abbotsford Police Arrest 19-Year-Old Tanner Sithigarn Fox For Stabbing Male Teen During Altercation

    Tanner FOX has been remanded in custody. His next court appearance is December 9, 2019.

    Abbotsford Police Arrest 19-Year-Old Tanner Sithigarn Fox For Stabbing Male Teen During Altercation

    Transport 2050: Public Proposes 4,000 Big Ideas For Next 30 Years Of Metro Vancouver Transportation

    Transport 2050: Public Proposes 4,000 Big Ideas For Next 30 Years Of Metro Vancouver Transportation
    With input from every jurisdiction in the region, the engagement results will help shape the priorities identified in Transport 2050 when released later next year. This round of engagement had a record-breaking 31,700 responses and over 4,000 ideas submitted.  

    Transport 2050: Public Proposes 4,000 Big Ideas For Next 30 Years Of Metro Vancouver Transportation

    Man Killed In Shooting Near Playground In Surrey Identified As 21-Year-Old VERRON NAND

    A man shot and killed in a residential area of north Surrey has been identified by Mounties as 21-year-old Verron Nand.

    Man Killed In Shooting Near Playground In Surrey Identified As 21-Year-Old VERRON NAND