Tuesday, October 27, 2020
ADVT 
National

Crown argues to limit hearing in stabbing case

Darpan News Desk The Canadian Press, 16 Oct, 2020
  • Crown argues to limit hearing in stabbing case

A Crown attorney says the B.C. Supreme Court should limit arguments in a hearing next month about whether a man who stabbed two high school students in Abbotsford, B.C., was criminally responsible for the crime.

Gabriel Klein has already been convicted of second-degree murder and aggravated assault in the stabbing death of 13-year-old Letisha Reimer and injuring her friend in an attack in the rotunda of Abbotsford Secondary School in 2016.

His sentencing hearing was set to begin last month but defence lawyer Martin Peters said Klein changed his mind and wanted to exercise his right to argue that he is not criminally responsible because of a mental disorder.

At a hearing Friday in New Westminster, Crown attorney Rob Macgowan told the court that the only issue that could reasonably be raised after the verdict is whether the accused was incapable of appreciating the moral wrongfulness of his action.

However, Macgowan said that by raising the issue of criminal responsibility after the verdict has been delivered, the defence is asking the court to reconsider its findings on Klein's intent.

He said the judge already decided that Klein had the intent to commit the crime.

"The court should not be asked to receive evidence or hear arguments that Mr. Klein did not appreciate the nature or quality of his acts because, if accepted now, that can only serve to contradict the verdict your ladyship has rendered in this case," Macgowan told the judge.

Macgowan said Klein is asking the court to look at essentially the same body of evidence that was reviewed at trial and reach a different conclusion.

He pointed out the defence unsuccessfully argued that Klein was guilty of the lesser charge of manslaughter because he lacked criminal intent.

Peters responded, saying the Crown didn't make clear what evidence it wanted to exclude.

"Is the Crown saying Mr. Klein can't come to this court and for the first time give evidence as to what he thought he was stabbing?" Peters asked.

A finding of not criminally responsible after the verdict doesn't contradict the verdict, but flows from it, Peter said.

"You simply find an exception to criminal responsibility and find not criminally responsible by reason of mental disorder. That doesn't contradict the earlier finding it is the ... exception that flows from the subsequent evidence."

A finding of not criminally responsible will almost always challenge the finding of criminal intent, Peters said.

Any restriction on evidence regarding a person's possible mental disorder would limit their right to a fair trial, he said.

Associate Chief Justice Heather Holmes reserved her decision but said she would deliver it before the hearing begins Nov. 9.

MORE National ARTICLES

Basant Motors continues tradition of giving away scholarships to 10 students including a front line worker

Basant Motors continues tradition of giving away scholarships to 10 students including a front line worker

On the dealership's 29th anniversary it generoulsy handed out $29,000 in scholarships to the best and the brightest students in the lower mainland.

Basant Motors continues tradition of giving away scholarships to 10 students including a front line worker

Stolen playground slide found in a backyard in Burnaby: RCMP

Stolen playground slide found in a backyard in Burnaby: RCMP

A groundskeeper had noticed that the slide, estimated to be valued at $5,000, was missing and reported it to police.

Stolen playground slide found in a backyard in Burnaby: RCMP

Provinces need to fight racism in health care: PM

Provinces need to fight racism in health care: PM

The issue of anti-Indigenous racism in health care gained new attention from outrage over the treatment of Joyce Echaquan, who used her phone to livestream hospital staff using racist slurs against her as she lay dying in a Quebec hospital last month.

Provinces need to fight racism in health care: PM

Vancouver Taxi Association is all for the BCNDP this election

Vancouver Taxi Association is all for the BCNDP this election

"In the view of the VTA members, the NDP is best able to protect the interests of working people and small businesses in the province, as well as the disadvantaged and minority members of our society" added Bauer. 

Vancouver Taxi Association is all for the BCNDP this election

Liberals propose pandemic-spending committee

Liberals propose pandemic-spending committee

The Conservative motion is slated for debate and a vote next week and government House leader Pablo Rodriguez is not ruling out making it a test of confidence in the minority government.

Liberals propose pandemic-spending committee

WATCH: Canadian Prime Minister Justin Trudeau welcoming new immigrants to Canada despite COVID19

WATCH: Canadian Prime Minister Justin Trudeau welcoming new immigrants to Canada despite COVID19

WATCH: Prime Minister Justin Trudeau is not wanting to scale back on immigration even with closed borders, and record unemployment due to Covid19. Dr Bonnie Henry confirms BC has its first case of COVID19 linked syndrome in children.

WATCH: Canadian Prime Minister Justin Trudeau welcoming new immigrants to Canada despite COVID19

PrevNext