Close X
Saturday, December 28, 2024
ADVT 
National

Court nixes rule requiring Air Canada to separate pooches, allergic passengers

Darpan News Desk The Canadian Press, 08 Jan, 2015 05:11 PM
    The Canadian Transportation Agency has been ordered to reconsider a ruling that required Air Canada to separate pooches from passengers with dog allergies in its airline cabins.
     
    The Federal Court of Appeal has set aside the agency's ruling, finding that it was made without any real evidence and without considering Air Canada's contention that a less intrusive remedy could be found.
     
    The agency ruled in August 2013 that Air Canada must create a buffer zone of least five rows to separate passengers with allergies from service dogs or pet canines travelling in carriers in airline cabins.
     
    On planes without a HEPA filter ventilation system, the agency banned pet dogs altogether from cabins whenever a passenger with a dog allergy was on board.
     
    In cases involving service dogs on such planes, priority was to be given to whomever booked their ticket first — the passenger with the dog or the passenger with the allergy.
     
    The agency's ruling on dogs was similar to that issued to Air Canada, WestJet Airlines and Air Canada Jazz a year earlier requiring a five-row minimum distance between travelling felines and passengers who are allergic to cats.
     
    The ruling was issued after a passenger complained that Air Canada's policy on dogs in airline cabins created "an undue obstacle to the mobility" of passengers who suffer from a "dog allergy disability."
     
    Air Canada appealed the ruling to the Federal Court of Appeal.
     
    A panel of three justices concluded last month that, due to procedural snafus, the CTA issued its ruling without considering a detailed submission from Air Canada. And that, the justices said, constituted a lack of procedural fairness.
     
    "I have no hesitation in saying that common sense has not prevailed in the present matter," wrote Justice Marc Nadon, writing for the panel.
     
    "The agency determined important issues, not only for the applicant and all those having dog allergies, but also for Air Canada. It did so without the benefit of any real evidence being adduced by the parties and, more particularly, by Air Canada ...
     
    "Had common sense prevailed, one would have expected the agency, at some point in time, to realize that it was disposing of these important issues without, in effect, the full participation of Air Canada."
     
    In the submission that was ignored by the CTA, Air Canada had argued that the agency's ruling would force it to discriminate against passengers with service dogs, in violation of U.S. regulations.
     
    The airline also argued that dog dander does not circulate in the air as easily as cat dander and that a less restrictive approach could therefore be taken to separate passengers from pooches.

    MORE National ARTICLES

    Four Arrested After Five People Shot In Toronto: Police

    Four Arrested After Five People Shot In Toronto: Police
    TORONTO — Four people have been arrested in a shooting in northwest Toronto that sent five people to hospital, one with life-threatening injuries, police said Thursday.

    Four Arrested After Five People Shot In Toronto: Police

    Bill Cosby moves on to second Ontario show after standing ovation last night

    Bill Cosby moves on to second Ontario show after standing ovation last night
    LONDON, Ont. — Bill Cosby's first Canadian performance may have gone ahead without a hitch but it remained to be seen whether his second appearance would roll out as smoothly in a city where residents opposing the embattled comedian vowed to send him a message.

    Bill Cosby moves on to second Ontario show after standing ovation last night

    Journalism has made some targets in Canada as well

    Journalism has made some targets in Canada as well
    Ottawa teenager Nora Sharmarke was only ten when her journalist father, Canadian Al Iman Sharmarke, was killed over his coverage of Islamic extremism in his native country of Somalia.

    Journalism has made some targets in Canada as well

    Mount Saint Vincent University instructor resigns, says he had sex with student

    Mount Saint Vincent University instructor resigns, says he had sex with student
    HALIFAX — A lecturer at a Halifax university has issued a public apology and resigned from his position after saying he had sex with a student and exchanged explicit images with her.

    Mount Saint Vincent University instructor resigns, says he had sex with student

    Manitoba Opposition leader fires back at accusation he is against gay rights

    Manitoba Opposition leader fires back at accusation he is against gay rights
    WINNIPEG — Manitoba Opposition Leader Brian Pallister once called same-sex marriage a "social experiment" and, with the recent nomination of an anti-abortion candidate, is facing accusations from the governing NDP of being anti-gay and anti-women.

    Manitoba Opposition leader fires back at accusation he is against gay rights

    Alberta MLA Rob Anderson says security boosted after getting death threat

    Alberta MLA Rob Anderson says security boosted after getting death threat
    EDMONTON — A former Opposition member who recently crossed the floor to join Alberta's governing Tories says Mounties have stepped up security at his home and office following a phone threat to kill him.

    Alberta MLA Rob Anderson says security boosted after getting death threat

    PrevNext