Close X
Wednesday, December 4, 2024
ADVT 
National

Court Hearings To Begin This Week Into Enbridge Cross-border Oil Pipelines

Darpan News Desk The Canadian Press, 07 Sep, 2015 11:59 AM
    CALGARY — A U.S. court begins hearing arguments this week in a lawsuit that claims increased volumes of oilsands crude have been allowed to flow from Canada into the United States without adequate public input or environmental review.
     
    Indigenous and environmental groups filed a lawsuit late last year against the U.S. State Department and Secretary of State John Kerry in federal district court. Hearings start in Minneapolis on Thursday.
     
    "Plaintiffs' members face increased risk of harm to their health, recreational, economic, spiritual and aesthetic interests as a result of the State Department's decision to allow projects with significant environmental impacts to proceed without fully analyzing and considering the impacts," the groups said in a complaint filed in February.
     
    At issue are a pair of Enbridge (TSX:ENB) oil pipelines between Hardisty, Alta., and Superior, Wisc.: Line 3 and Line 67, also known as Alberta Clipper.
     
    Both pipelines have presidential permits, the same crucial approval for cross-border infrastructure that TransCanada Corp. (TSX:TRP) has been painstakingly trying to obtain for its Keystone XL project since 2008.
     
    The two sides disagree over whether it's necessary to go through that process again if more crude is to flow through those lines.
     
    "Enbridge is operating its pipelines consistent with the presidential permits and other permits that it holds for Lines 3 and 67, while meeting its responsibility and obligations to serve its shippers' needs," said Enbridge spokesman Graham White in an email.
     
    In court documents, the defendants say the claims "lack merit" and ask the court to "dismiss the complaint in its entirety with prejudice."
     
    In early 2014, Enbridge announced it would be replacing Line 3 in its entirety and idling the old pipe, deeming that was a better option than fixing the whole 47-year-old line. At $7.5 billion, it would be the biggest project in Enbridge history.  
     
    In court filings, the defendants describe the Line 3 replacement as a "maintenance-driven" project, while the plaintiffs say Enbridge is aiming to build a whole new pipeline that should be subject to a full State Department review.
     
    The upgrade will enable the line to pump a maximum of 760,000 barrels per day, up from the current 390,000, according to Enbridge's own engineering analysis.
     
    Meanwhile, Enbridge is aiming to expand Line 67 from 450,000 barrels a day to 800,000 barrels a day. The plan does not entail laying down any new pipe; rather, capacity is to be boosted by adding pumping horsepower.
     
    Enbridge obtained a presidential permit in 2009 before starting up the first 450,000-barrel-per-day phase of the line, but the State Department says it needs to amend its environmental review before allowing the expansion to go ahead. That process is taking longer than Enbridge anticipated.
     
    In the interim, Enbridge has conceived a workaround that opponents have derided as a "switcheroo." It involves moving oil from Line 67 to Line 3 and back again through interconnections on either side of the border.
     
    The plaintiffs include the White Earth Nation, an Ojibwe reservation in northern Minnesota; Honor the Earth, an environmental group based on the White Earth Nation; Indigenous Environmental Network; Minnesota Conservation Federation; MN350; Center for Biololgical Diversity; Sierra Club and National Wildlife Federation.  
     
    Winona LaDuke, executive director of Honor the Earth, said opponents resorted to court action because "Enbridge and the State Department haven't listened to anything else."
     
    "If Enbridge would (obey) the laws of this country and the laws of our tribe, then we would not be in court."

    MORE National ARTICLES

    New Offence Prompts One Day In Jail For Man Who Dragged Victim To Death In 2005

    New Offence Prompts One Day In Jail For Man Who Dragged Victim To Death In 2005
    The father of a man killed 10 years ago in a horrifying gas-and-dash in Metro Vancouver is furious about the latest sentence handed to his son's killer.

    New Offence Prompts One Day In Jail For Man Who Dragged Victim To Death In 2005

    North American Stock Markets Rebound In Early Trading After Global Tumult

    North American Stock Markets Rebound In Early Trading After Global Tumult
    The Toronto Stock Exchange's main index rebounded Tuesday morning, making up much of the 420-point drubbing it got in the previous day's tumult as traders adjusted to persistent concerns about the strength of China's economy.

    North American Stock Markets Rebound In Early Trading After Global Tumult

    Heavy Wildfire Smoke From U.S. Has Small Upside For Firefighters In B.C.

    Heavy Wildfire Smoke From U.S. Has Small Upside For Firefighters In B.C.
    Smoke from wildfires burning in Washington state has caused visibility and air quality problems in British Columbia, but it's also helping to keep the province's own fires in check.

    Heavy Wildfire Smoke From U.S. Has Small Upside For Firefighters In B.C.

    Amid Swooning Markets, Leaders Battle Over Who's Best Suited To Manage Economy

    Amid Swooning Markets, Leaders Battle Over Who's Best Suited To Manage Economy
    Stephen Harper was asked about the previous day's phone conversation with the governor of the Bank of Canada, which was publicized by the Prime Minister's Office on a day of widespread market anxiety.

    Amid Swooning Markets, Leaders Battle Over Who's Best Suited To Manage Economy

    Four Brits Among Six Victims In Quebec Plane Crash

    Britain's Foreign Office says four Britons were among six people killed when a sightseeing seaplane crashed in a remote area of Quebec's North Shore on Sunday.

    Four Brits Among Six Victims In Quebec Plane Crash

    Windsor Housekeeper Finds And Returns Guest's Purse With US $4,700

    Windsor Housekeeper Finds And Returns Guest's Purse With US $4,700
    A Windsor, Ont., housekeeper said she expected the usual haul of linens and towels when she began cleaning a room at a Days Inn hotel — not a bag filled with US$4,700 in cash.

    Windsor Housekeeper Finds And Returns Guest's Purse With US $4,700