Close X
Friday, November 8, 2024
ADVT 
National

Court dismisses appeal by Ont. woman who killed daughters during custody battle

Darpan News Desk The Canadian Press, 03 Feb, 2015 11:01 AM
  • Court dismisses appeal by Ont. woman who killed daughters during custody battle

TORONTO — An appeal by an Ontario woman who killed her two young daughters more than eight years ago had been dismissed.

Elaine Campione drowned her daughters, Serena, 3, and Sophia, 19 months, in the bathtub in October 2006 while in the midst of a custody battle with her ex-husband.

Court heard the Barrie, Ont., woman had been diagnosed as having unspecified psychosis and other mental illnesses, but a jury found that did not prevent her from knowing it was wrong to drown her children, as the defence had suggested.

She was convicted of first-degree murder and sentenced to life in prison with no parole eligibility for 25 years.

In appealing her convictions, Campione said the trial judge made three errors in instructing the jury on how to determine whether she should be found not criminally responsible.

But the appeal court found the trial judge properly instructed the jury on the law.

"The jurors were made well aware that, if they accepted the appellant’s version of the killings, they had to render a verdict of NCR. I see no basis for confusion on this issue," the three-person panel wrote in its decision.

"While the focus of the test is on the appellant’s state of mind and her capacity for rational choice, the question is not whether the appellant considered the acts justified according to her own moral code, but whether she was incapable of knowing that her actions were contrary to society’s morality."

MORE National ARTICLES

Suspension of University of Ottawa varsity hockey team prompts class action

Suspension of University of Ottawa varsity hockey team prompts class action
OTTAWA — The lawyer for all but two members of the University of Ottawa men's hockey team says he is seeking approval for a class-action lawsuit against the school.

Suspension of University of Ottawa varsity hockey team prompts class action

Two accused in B.C. terror case plead not guilty at start of jury selection

Two accused in B.C. terror case plead not guilty at start of jury selection
VANCOUVER — Two people accused in what the RCMP described as a plot to blow up the British Columbia legislature have both pleaded not guilty in a Vancouver court.

Two accused in B.C. terror case plead not guilty at start of jury selection

B.C. Auditor General Says Prisons Crowded, Unsafe And Hardly Stop Repeat Crime

B.C. Auditor General Says Prisons Crowded, Unsafe And Hardly Stop Repeat Crime
VICTORIA — British Columbia's prisons are overcrowded, tension-filled facilities that do little to prevent inmates from returning to crime when released.

B.C. Auditor General Says Prisons Crowded, Unsafe And Hardly Stop Repeat Crime

Homicide Investigators Called To Chilliwack To Probe Suspicious Death

Homicide Investigators Called To Chilliwack To Probe Suspicious Death
Mounties say they were called to the scene of a car crash at around 11:00 p.m. Monday and found a man dead inside a vehicle.

Homicide Investigators Called To Chilliwack To Probe Suspicious Death

Road Warriors: Canucks Ready To Hit The Road After Disappointing Homestand

Road Warriors: Canucks Ready To Hit The Road After Disappointing Homestand
VANCOUVER — The Vancouver Canucks are about where Willie Desjardins expected them to be 40 games into his first season as an NHL head coach. How they got to this point is another matter entirely.

Road Warriors: Canucks Ready To Hit The Road After Disappointing Homestand

Search For Missing Vancouver Hiker On North Shore Mountains Resumes

Search For Missing Vancouver Hiker On North Shore Mountains Resumes
North Shore Rescue previously called off looking for Liang Jin because of harsh weather conditions and difficulty narrowing down a search area.

Search For Missing Vancouver Hiker On North Shore Mountains Resumes