Close X
Thursday, January 23, 2025
ADVT 
National

Closing Of Duffy Trial Takes Proceedings From The Whos And Whats To Why And How

Darpan News Desk The Canadian Press, 21 Feb, 2016 02:00 PM
    OTTAWA — As a former journalist, Sen. Mike Duffy knows the components of a story — you need the who, the what, the where, the when, the why and the how.
     
    In the 61 days an Ottawa courtroom heard evidence on the 31 charges of fraud, breach of trust and bribery the senator is facing, the Crown and the defence argued the first five points.
     
    But with the start of closing arguments on Monday, both sides will now get to the final element so necessary to their respective sides of the case, says Peter Sankoff, a law professor at the University of Alberta.
     
    "It's about the how — how does all this stuff add up to guilt or innocence," he said.  
     
    Duffy, 69, has pleaded not guilty to all charges.
     
    The closing submissions cap off a trial that began in April and was initially supposed to last just eight weeks. But it's a story that starts back in 2008, when the popular broadcaster was appointed by former prime minister Stephen Harper as a Conservative senator for P.E.I.
     
    Four years later, questions about whether Duffy could justifiably claim to be a resident of that province began to surface and from those, more questions emerged about his expenses and living claims.
     
     
    He'd eventually publicly admit to confusion with the rules and pay $90,000 back into the public purse — money it would later emerge was not his, but came from Harper's former chief of staff, Nigel Wright. More questions would emerge, this time about the partisan work Duffy was doing and whether taxpayers should have been footing the bill for that, too, as he was billing the Senate for some of those trips.  
     
    The whos and wheres and whens and whats of his expenses were the meat of the weeks of testimony that dragged on far longer than anyone expected, including through the early part of the fall election campaign which saw the Conservative government ousted in favour of the Liberals.
     
    There's no question the changing of the political guard in Ottawa took some of the air out of the proceedings, Sankoff noted. But neither side has any room left for it anyway.
     
    "What they were dealing with for long periods, who knew what at what time, who was dealing with the decision, I don't think any of that matters anymore," he said.  
     
    "I think they are really going to focus to the extent that they will on trying to explain why he should or shouldn't be convicted."
     
    But that's not to say that Justice Charles Vaillancourt's eventual ruling will have no fallout, Sankoff said.
     
    "What the judge says could have some impact on how the government does business, because the judge could make some statements about the inappropriateness of some of the conduct of the prime minister's office and I think that has resonance even for future governments," he said.  
     
     
    While two weeks have been set aside for the final submissions, the judge has also asked both sides to present them in writing first, in order to focus them in the hope that the full two weeks will not be needed.

    MORE National ARTICLES

    Kamloops B.C., Family Saved From Carbon Monoxide Poisoning By Crying Toddler

    Kamloops B.C., Family Saved From Carbon Monoxide Poisoning By Crying Toddler
    Fifteen-month-old Celia Rupple is being credited with saving her life, the lives of her parents, and the family's several cats and dogs after carbon monoxide filled their Kamloops

    Kamloops B.C., Family Saved From Carbon Monoxide Poisoning By Crying Toddler

    Science World to Host Award-Winning Bartenders at Science of Cocktail Event!

    Science World to Host Award-Winning Bartenders at Science of Cocktail Event!

    Think molecular mixology, snappy suits and dazzling dresses. For one night only, the Science of C...

    Science World to Host Award-Winning Bartenders at Science of Cocktail Event!

    Newfoundland Man Found Not Guilty In Soccer Stabbing Heard Voice: 'Get That Kid'

    Newfoundland Man Found Not Guilty In Soccer Stabbing Heard Voice: 'Get That Kid'
    Layman heard the phantom instruction moments before plunging a 25-centimetre blade into the boy's neck and chest, Judge Colin Flynn read from his decision in provincial court.

    Newfoundland Man Found Not Guilty In Soccer Stabbing Heard Voice: 'Get That Kid'

    Possible Ikea Return To Halifax Prompts Twitter Buzz From Those Who Miss Shop

    Possible Ikea Return To Halifax Prompts Twitter Buzz From Those Who Miss Shop
    kea Canada said its president, Stefan Sjostrand, will join the city's mayor, Mike Savage, Friday for a news conference.

    Possible Ikea Return To Halifax Prompts Twitter Buzz From Those Who Miss Shop

    B.C. High Court Upholds Manslaughter Convictions For Two Men In Kelowna Father's Death

    B.C. High Court Upholds Manslaughter Convictions For Two Men In Kelowna Father's Death
    Matthew McRae and Anson Schell were sentenced to three-and-a-half years and three-years respectively for their part in the slaying of Dain Phillips during a feud in Kelowna in June, 2011.

    B.C. High Court Upholds Manslaughter Convictions For Two Men In Kelowna Father's Death

    Stephen Harper Relations With Supreme Court Not Especially Antagonistic, Study Finds

    Stephen Harper Relations With Supreme Court Not Especially Antagonistic, Study Finds
    The popular view that the relationship between the Conservative government under Stephen Harper and the Supreme Court of Canada was especially hostile appears to be misguided, a new study concludes.

    Stephen Harper Relations With Supreme Court Not Especially Antagonistic, Study Finds