Close X
Monday, November 11, 2024
ADVT 
National

Christy Clark Says Trudeau Legitimizing Unaccountable Senate, B.C. Under-representation

Darpan News Desk The Canadian Press, 06 Dec, 2015 01:45 PM
  • Christy Clark Says Trudeau Legitimizing Unaccountable Senate, B.C. Under-representation
OTTAWA — British Columbia's premier says the Trudeau government's plans for a more independent, non-partisan Senate will make the much-maligned institution even worse than it already is.
 
Christy Clark says the new process for appointing senators on merit will give legitimacy to an unelected, unaccountable upper house in which her province will remain grossly under-represented.
 
B.C. gets only six senators in the 105-seat chamber, although it's the third largest province with a population of about 4.7 million.
 
By contrast, the three tiny maritime provinces, with less than two million people combined, are entitled to 24 senators, as are Ontario and Quebec.
 
Democratic Institutions Minister Maryam Monsef announced last week the creation of an independent, five-member advisory board to recommend a short list of five non-partisan nominees to fill each vacancy in the Senate.
 
Two of the board's members are to represent the province in which the vacancy arises, but Clark told the Global TV show West Block that her government won't participate in the new process because it doesn't want to validate it.
 
"The process doesn't make the Senate any better," Clark told host Tom Clark.
 
 
"I would argue that it actually makes it worse because the Senate is completely unrepresentative of the provinces."
 
Clark added: "The Senate doesn't work now. The only other thing that could make the Senate worse would be having all of these unaccountable, unelected patronage appointments starting to think that they are somehow legitimate and have the power to make decisions on behalf of our country.
 
"They don't. They shouldn't ... And we won't endorse it."
 
While provincial governments will be consulted on the provincial members of the advisory board, the federal government can proceed without their participation if need be.
 
Prime Minister Justin Trudeau has argued that his approach is the only practical way to achieve concrete change in the Senate without getting bogged down in divisive constitutional wrangling with the provinces. His objective is to eliminate the partisanship that he believes has eroded the Senate's ability to fulfil its intended role as an independent chamber of sober second thought.
 
The Supreme Court has ruled that more dramatic reforms — such as altering the Senate's regional representation, imposing term limits, or requiring the election of senators — would require a constitutional amendment approved by at least seven provinces with 50 per cent of the population. Abolition of the chamber would require unanimous consent.
 
 
Nevertheless, Clark reiterated her view that the Senate should be fixed or folded. She acknowledged that would be "hard to do" but said it's preferable to legitimizing senators who are unaccountable to Canadians until they retire at age 75.

MORE National ARTICLES

Quebec Government Tables Bill To Create Provincial Registry For All Firearms

Quebec Government Tables Bill To Create Provincial Registry For All Firearms
Public Security Minister Pierre Moreau said today each gun in Quebec will have its own number.

Quebec Government Tables Bill To Create Provincial Registry For All Firearms

Manitoba Aiming To Reduce Greenhouse Gas Emissions, Create Green Jobs

He says the province will address the problem by creating 6,000 green jobs in the next five years.

Manitoba Aiming To Reduce Greenhouse Gas Emissions, Create Green Jobs

Liberal Plan To Hike Taxes On Top One Per Cent May Lead To Revenue Hole: Study

Liberal Plan To Hike Taxes On Top One Per Cent May Lead To Revenue Hole: Study
TORONTO — The Liberal government's plan to switch some of the tax burden from middle-income earners to the top one per cent will likely lead to multibillion-dollar annual revenue shortfalls for Ottawa and the provinces, according to the C.D. Howe Institute.

Liberal Plan To Hike Taxes On Top One Per Cent May Lead To Revenue Hole: Study

Liberals Announce Advisory Board To Quickly Choose New Independent Senators

Liberals Announce Advisory Board To Quickly Choose New Independent Senators
OTTAWA — The Trudeau government is setting up a five-member advisory board to fill the empty seats in the Senate with independent senators.

Liberals Announce Advisory Board To Quickly Choose New Independent Senators

Retired Couple In Orangeville, Ont., Opens Home To Syrian Refugees

Retired Couple In Orangeville, Ont., Opens Home To Syrian Refugees
The Logels' three children and five grandchildren, themselves frequent visitors to the family homestead located on four hectares outside town, are coming for Christmas, though the Logels recognize the holiday isn't one their guests celebrate.

Retired Couple In Orangeville, Ont., Opens Home To Syrian Refugees

Quebec Tells Doctors To Respect Court Decision Suspending Right-to-die Law

Quebec Tells Doctors To Respect Court Decision Suspending Right-to-die Law
MONTREAL — Doctors must respect a court ruling suspending Quebec's assisted-suicide law but the government won't go on a "witch hunt" against physicians who offer palliative sedation,  the province's health minister said Wednesday.

Quebec Tells Doctors To Respect Court Decision Suspending Right-to-die Law