Close X
Friday, November 29, 2024
ADVT 
National

Charter Challenge Against Practice That Saw Cops Posing As Reporters Dismissed

The Canadian Press, 11 Aug, 2015 10:48 AM
    TORONTO — An Ontario superior court judge has dismissed a charter challenge filed against a practice that saw a handful of provincial police officers pose as journalists.
     
    Three major media organizations went to court last May to argue that the practice violated the constitution by having a chilling effect on freedom of the press.
     
    But in a decision released last month, Justice Benjamin Glustein said that no such practice truly existed.
     
    The cases at the heart of the charter challenge centred on police efforts to gather information during high-profile protests by aboriginal groups.
     
    Philip Tunley, the lawyer representing the media group, says Glustein's ruling was disappointing and did not address the main questions around freedom of expression.
     
    He says the CBC, Canadian Journalists for Free Expression and the Radio-Television News Directors Association of Canada are considering whether or not to appeal the ruling.
     
    The media organizations argued that the practice of impersonating reporters could place genuine journalists at risk by raising suspicions about who they are, as well as limiting the ability to develop trusting relationships with key sources.
     
    Tunley said Glustein's argument was particularly technical and focused on each individual point raised during the hearing rather than addressing the overarching questions they raised.
     
    The application was centred around specific cases in which police officers impersonated reporters, and Glustein's ruling focuses on why each individual instance doesn't represent a widespread practice.
     
    "What he never does is to sort of sit back and ask the question that we said was important, which was ... are sources likely to believe that there is a practice from all of the reported incidents," Tunley said in a telephone interview.
     
    The application filed by the media organizations cited the cases as proof provincial police pose as members of the media to gather information as part of a criminal investigation.
     
    In one notorious case, two officers filmed protesters at Ipperwash provincial park in 1995 and, when asked who they worked for, named the fictitious United Press Associates. Police confirmed the deception years later at a public inquiry into the fatal police shooting of an aboriginal protester.
     
    In another case, an officer keeping an eye on protesters during an aboriginal Day of Action on Tyendinaga Mohawk territory in 2007 admitted he had pretended to be part of the media, court heard.
     
    Glustein's decision, however, dismissed the argument.
     
    "There is no practice of plainclothes OPP officers engaged in media-presence surveillance to identify themselves as journalists if questioned as to their identity," the decision reads. "Consequently, it cannot be considered a 'real' practice and, as such, I do not address the theoretical constitutional validity of the issue."
     
    The lawyer representing the three respondents in the case — the Attorney General of Ontario, the Minister of Community Safety and Correctional Services and the Commissioner of the Ontario Provincial Police — could not be reached for comment.
     
    Attorney General spokesman Brendan Crawley issued a statement saying that "the Ontario Provincial Police used investigative techniques that were in accordance with the law and do not infringe freedom of expression under the Charter." He declined to offer further comment on the ruling since a decision to appeal is still pending.
     
    Tunley said that decision will be made before the end of the month.

    MORE National ARTICLES

    Three Indian Americans Charged With $2.5-Million Bank Fraud And Money Laundering

    Three Indian Americans Charged With $2.5-Million Bank Fraud And Money Laundering
    US authorities have charged three Indian Americans with a $2.5-million bank fraud and money laundering, media reports said.

    Three Indian Americans Charged With $2.5-Million Bank Fraud And Money Laundering

    B.C. Says Park Policy Offers Protection While Others Fear Development

    The Ministry of Environment is expected to release its policy on issuing permits for research and information gathering within provincial parks on Friday.

    B.C. Says Park Policy Offers Protection While Others Fear Development

    As Canadian Leaders Debated, Donald Trump Was Producing The Wildest Show In Politics

    As Canadian Leaders Debated, Donald Trump Was Producing The Wildest Show In Politics
    The first debate of the U.S. presidential election cycle was only a moment old and arguably wilder than anything that's happened in any Canadian leaders' debate, ever — let alone Thursday's.

    As Canadian Leaders Debated, Donald Trump Was Producing The Wildest Show In Politics

    B.C. And Third First Nation In Campbell River Sign Timber Licence Deal

    B.C. And Third First Nation In Campbell River Sign Timber Licence Deal
      VICTORIA — The B.C. government has announced a 25-year timber licence agreement with a First Nation on Vancouver Island.

    B.C. And Third First Nation In Campbell River Sign Timber Licence Deal

    B.C. Cabinet Minister Wants To Hear Canadian Anthem At Parapan Am Games

    B.C. Cabinet Minister Wants To Hear Canadian Anthem At Parapan Am Games
    NANAIMO, B.C. — Barely three weeks ago, Michelle Stilwell was in British Columbia's legislature locked in a raging debate about the province's pursuit of a liquefied natural gas industry.

    B.C. Cabinet Minister Wants To Hear Canadian Anthem At Parapan Am Games

    Saskatchewan Premier Brad Wall Says Equalization Program Too Rich For Hydro Provinces

    "It is a lot of money to go out in a way that seems to be dated and not always efficient, and infrastructure and tax relief might be an option instead," Wall said

    Saskatchewan Premier Brad Wall Says Equalization Program Too Rich For Hydro Provinces